My sister has lived in Grinnell for the past 20+ years, including half of those working in the school system there, and the college has interesting things as well as some profs remain in the town after retirement. The college offers facilities for their faculty/staff to enjoy life there. Not too far from Des Moines. My sister has lived in small towns (the largest was LaCrosse WI which is not very big but bigger than others where she has lived). The cold/snow/ice winter is a drawback, but her children/grandchildren are pretty close by.
Upper midwest is GLORIOUS in the summer, but I am one to have more than that to travel there.
As much as some people will not live in the states my daughters and we live, I can say the same for some of the other states. I choke when I see the property taxes on homes various costlier places as well as other drawbacks.
Our move is a big undertaking which I have pushed off into 2028. DH is glad to have another year in our current location.
Sometimes it sure is a tough call. When you’re still young (we all are young on this forum!), it seems like such a balancing act. You might have 40+ years of life, and you don’t want to be dependent on your kids, plus you don’t want to have to massively cut back because you gave too much away. It’s a quandary for us too, and then it’s a challenge to work it out with my husband, who has different ideas than I do.
I think it would be easier if it was more obvious, like if family had a serious need (and I felt they were responsible), or if I got a windfall. When it’s just your own accounts building up slowly, it’s a tough call. In my mom’s case, it should be a ridiculously easy choice for her, but since she’s lived her entire life like she’s poor, it seems impossible to change.
We are open minded to sharing some of money with the kids now. But it can be a tough sell getting them to accept. They do however seem ok with us underwriting fun family travel
We have probably not done enough of that but will probably start. We have worked to convince ShawWife’s 94 yo mother to do some of that, and she did provide ShawD with CAD$250K to help with her house downpayment and said it would be classified as an advance against her inheritance.
ShawD is setting up her own psychiatric practice. As someone who thinks a lot about asset protection, I realize that a number of the steps I would take (have a trust own her PLLC, have a provide capital to her company in exchange for a royalty if equity is not allowable, etc.) are blocked by state law. So, our trust is going to lend the PLLC $100K. The PLLC will pay interest every year, but the $100K would be senior to any claim against the company. Given that the company probably won’t have a lot of cash as it will likely pay out income on an ongoing basis, that would put her in a better position to negotiation with potential claimants.
It could be worse. I didn’t put the kibosh on it, but didn’t encourage my husband’s desire to fly private airplanes after retiring as an airline pilot. Skilled, experienced, cautious, whatever….single engine flying is dangerous. And now he’s too busy with 43 acres of trees that we purchased, and enjoying doing the work himself. Yes, mowing down trees with a chainsaw is dicey, but there are worse things.
May our husbands never team up with their chainsaws!
Then there are homeowners association fees — which can top $500 a month — plus insurance, food and other daily expenses that quickly add up. Throw in costly hobbies and a pricey retirement community, and that $10,000 won’t stretch nearly as far.
We have 2.5 homes (no mortgages, though) and one is a pricey active adult community with HOA fees over $500/month, and we do it comfortably on less than $10K/month.
The answer, as always, is this:
Depending on where you live, your health and your lifestyle, it could be a lot higher or lower.
…
The key is aligning your location and personal habits to make that money last.
Median household income in US is ~$7k/month. Among retired persons, median household income is ~$5k/month. Of course it’s possible to retire on $10k/month. The overwhelming portion of people in US do so with less. I think the key unknown that may change this result is medical expense. It can and often is negligible beyond insurance premiums, but for a small minority, out-of-pocket medical expense alone is >$10k/month.
I think I’d have trouble finding a way to average $10k/month in spending. However, I have few major expenses since I don’t have mortgage/rent, don’t have debt, work from home with little travel expense, live in moderate climate without much heating/cooling expenses, don’t have any significant medical issues/expenses, and don’t have particularly expensive hobbies.
Exactly. After my Dad passed my Mom was probably clearing $3200-3600 a month after tax and she had more money than she knew what to do with. But of course had a paid off house. Paid off car. Low property taxes. No HOA. She barely ate much.
I am looking at Condo living in retirement with a pretty high HOA think $800-1000 but it will replace a pool and gym costs. We will be able to go down to one car.
But that may not be Kiplinger’s target audience as those may not be the folks with subscriptions to that magazine or online articles.. I think the point is well taken that there are many hidden costs that people don’t always consider when they calculate their annual expenses (federal and state taxes, real estate/home owner, taxes etc). If you want to take vacations, etc. expenses can climb.
I think people also don’t realize that a condo or house that is fully paid off can still cost tons of money each year in HOA, real estate taxes, maintenance, utilities, etc. In a high cost of living area, these costs can be add up to almost the same, if not more than a monthly rent.
My mortgage had been paid off for years before we sold our house, but yet our housing expenses in suburban NJ were still very high.
We moved from NJ to MA, both high cost of living locations, but I still got sticker shock on my car insurance and utilities (both significantly higher in MA than in NJ).
Retirees may spend less because they become less active, travel less (not us!) less mobile and have less to spend it on. But I don’t plan to be one of those retirees. My husband gives me some large number and says he doesn’t think I could spend that in a month. I am happy to rise to the challenge
I think there’s a difference between CAN you live on $10,000 a month and the fact that you don’t have to.
If you had to, I think that $10,000 a month is more than adequate. In fact, I think it would be a very generous budget.
It’s kinda silly to think that it’s not a number that can cover expenses and that many live on much less. What a privilege I have that I don’t have to worry about gas prices, eating and paying my mortgage
I met with our new Vanguard FA today. I liked him, and he asked me questions that the previous guy didn’t. And he set a second meeting for next week so he could cover more things we weren’t able to do in 45 minutes!
Seriously, giving the impression that $10k a month is where most people are at in retirement or even NOT in retirement is surely offending even many here on CC. Even the educated who buy and read magazine subscriptions….
Btw $10k isn’t $10k after taxes - unless you have tax free income - like munis. There’s a difference.
Our garage motor just died. Not sure how much $$. The door is bent so may be told have to replace. A broom got stuck under it. Ugh
Our roof and gutters were near $38k
If my house has doubled in 20 years and it’s a big if, that’s a terrible rate of return.
We are taking about selling but nothing is selling. We could invest the principal tax free and live off the income in an apartment. All the maintenance issues wouldn’t be ours - at least we think.
We sold our house and yes we got a lot of money for it (the market was good at the time), however, when you calculate it, we also got a terrible rate of return. Especially, when you add up the real estate taxes over the 35 years we owned it, the home improvement costs (2 new roofs, 3 new hot water tanks, 2 new AC units, 2 new HVAC systems, a new kitchen, 2 new baths, landscaping, new patio, new deck, etc.), the annual maintenance costs (mowing, snow removal, tree removals and trimming, etc.), and the various other things (leaks, painting, plumbing, etc.)
We are now in an apartment and all we pay is rent. If something breaks - we call the maintenance guy and they come and fix it. And my husband is thrilled to never have to go to the Home Depot again. Yes, rent can go up (and it has every year we have renewed), but so did real estate taxes.