How Much Do You think You Need to Retire? What Age Will You/Spouse Retire? Investment and General Retirement Issues (Part 3)

The Kiplinger article was posted because of the topic of this thread. No judgement. Just an interesting article and things to think about. And yes, the median income of their readership is higher than the median population. Again, just a fact.

3 Likes

But a house that you live in is not and should not be considered investment. Unless it is investment in peace and quiet and ability to do what you want (subject to local laws and code lol ). Also consider how much you would have paid in rent to be able to live in a similar house, and maybe it was not a bad “investment.”

9 Likes

I think the article gives food for thought. I’m fortunate that my house is fully paid for and has appreciated at a higher rate than I ever could have imagined. I couldn’t come close to buying my house today. I also know if I sold and wanted to rent a similar house I couldn’t afford it. My expenses for my house are significantly lower than what my kids pay in rent for a standard 1960’s tract house in an okay not great school district. If necessary I could sell my house and take my profit to a less expensive COL area.
Also my Medicare plus supplement and Irmaa are close to $1000.00. My husband pays over 1000 a month for his ACA plan. Right there we are at $2000.00.

6 Likes

As I have mentioned here before, my plan is to sell my house next year and rent an apartment. House is paid off but RE taxes are high and there is always some home maintenance/ improvements that need doing. It’s not cheap and honestly I don’t want the bother.

8 Likes

The “bother element” is definitely a factor. When it almost outweighs the positives, it can be a decisive one.

7 Likes

Thats true. But many of them (the seniors struggling living on their social security) are probably not reading this thread (the topic of which is how much is needed/when to retire). And the reasons many seniors are struggling with their SS benefits is a conversation for the Political forum (but only for 2 more days!)

3 Likes

We can sell our (tear down special) house now for megabucks, invest that in CDs, and live off the interest in an apartment (oops, we have one - a condo in the center of the universe that we will be selling). Can I grow 100 pounds of tomatoes there? Nope. Can I make quince jam there? Maybe, I saw a quince tree near there. Can our grands roam free in the 1,000 sft of space devoted to an indoor playground when it rains cats and dogs outside? Nope. Can my husband enjoy yardwork like he does here? Nope. Not moving even though we are paying a premium for the experiences. :joy:

10 Likes

Exactly. I know several people who prefer staying in a house with a yard because they genuinely enjoy gardening or other reasons.

It’s good to be in a position where one can make a choice as to what living situation suits them best. I consider myself very privileged to be able to have options, as I know others do not.

12 Likes

I do like gardening (although this year due to our vacation schedules I skipped planting veggies, only giving the front gardens water and attention). It does not interest me as much as it did during Covid, fewer other options. Still it has occurred to me that if my husband (7 years older) slows down I’ll really like have that so-close-to-home hobby. Of course neither one of us like messing with some of the headaches of home ownership, so future housing plans are still tbd.

5 Likes

It strikes me more as a title to get clicks. The title is " Can You Live on $10,000 a Month in Retirement?" , not “Is $10k/month enough to support your preferred lifestyle…”. The obvious answer to this question is, “yes, it is possible to live on under $10k/month”. Even if a large portion of the Kiplinger readership has a $10k/month income, having a $10k/month income does not mean it’s not possible for them to spend under $10k/month in retirement, like the overwhelming majority of retired (and non-retired) persons in USA.

After seeing the title, I expect many people click to open the article in wonder how the author could suggest that it is not being possible to live on under $10k/month. The article content gives no reason why the title chooses a $10k/month figure, and the article’s “high end monthly budget total” was $6,700/month… well under the $10k/month number in the title, as one would expect.

The specific totals in the article seem to be based on national averages, which often bears little correlation to how much a particular individual or household will spend in retirement. For example, the article mentions a 2-bedroom apartment costs $1900/month; so the total assumes retired persons spend $1900/month on rent. Only a small minority of retired persons live in apartments, and among that minority, rent expenses are all over the map. This makes the $1900/month rent expense not applicable for overwhelming portion of readers. It’s a similar idea for the other totals.

4 Likes

As many suggest here, the type of place you live in has to match the lifestyle you want at that time in your life. As a young married couple and then raising our daughter, we wanted our own house in a suburb with a good school system, nice fenced in yard, etc. Once we retired, the house was no longer the lifestyle we wanted. I love our new lifestyle, renting in a locations where we can walk to everything (including a commuter train to visit the city my daughter lives in). We were never good gardeners or enjoyed DIY, so we don’t miss either of those things.

We never ever considered our house an investment - it was the place we lived and honestly loved for the time we lived there. But this is a thread about money and retirement, so we discuss the costs associated with different living arrangments.

3 Likes

But some of us have plenty of friends and family who are in this situation. I had a discussion several years back where my coworkers didn’t believe me that old people have to file taxes. None of their parents have for years. They thought it was due to age - I had to point out that it’s their income that isn’t high enough.

9 Likes

I count my blessings every day that I have the resources for a very comfortable life. I would be hard pressed to think of ways to spend $10000 a month if that was after taxes! I think we sometimes lose sight of how the vast majority of people live. I also don’t think we should assume CC readers are all well-off. I know for most of the time I’ve been here I certainly wasn’t.

7 Likes

This relates to retirement. If DH and I were to sell our current house, we would realize 6 times what it cost us to build this house in 1994. BUT with current real estate costs and rentals where we would want to move (nice walkable area, one floor living in a house that needs very little work, etc), we would not have enough money to buy…or rent…where we live. OK…we would have enough, but we would be giving up a lot if we move (remember, we live in a lake community in the woods, with two acres, and great neighborhood).

We will likely live here until we can’t drive…

5 Likes

I’ve posted several times that, were it up to me, I’d sell the AZ house and keep just the cabin where we could live quite comfortably on SS alone. DH is of a different mind, though.

I also think that now that our son appears to be firmly planted in the DC area and will probably make some progress on that one child he and his wife agree on, we will leave AZ (when our parents are gone) for the mid-Atlantic. We both like the idea of renting, at least for a while, for all the freedom others have expressed.

The point is that life changes, and you match your living arrangements to each new reality. And I, too, am grateful for the financial ability to continue adapting to the changing seasons.

13 Likes

No one is assuming that. The article was linked b/c of the topic of this thread. Sure we all know people who have financial difficulties. That is not the topic of this thread.

1 Like

This thread is for all…

Having enough to retire means that you will be someone who can afford to retire. I think that’s what the thread is about. Some people reading it are big money and some aren’t.

It’s asking how much folks feel they need to retire, and this price point certainly varies…just like paying for college costs for our kids.

I think info from a variety of POV is interesting to read.

3 Likes

It is clear you love your home and neighborhood and all it has to offer. I hope that you are able to enjoy it for many more years even if you don’t need all the space now or even with home updates, etc. I mean this in the most sincere way!

Very important points brought up here about home value and the whole idea of homes being worth so much more than what was paid at closing. But a lot of factors go into that cost then and now and all the costs in the years in-between. You’ve all opened my eyes some to how/why renting at some point can be a relief and convenience of sorts!

2 Likes

By the time you can’t drive, it is highly likely that you will be able to buy or share a car (like uber or waymo) that will drive for you. Our Tesla’s Full Self Driving is pretty impressive already. Assuming that you have 10 or 20 years or more before you can’t drive, your inability to drive will not have to cause you to move.

4 Likes

Great point about life changing. If H were still living, we would be staying in our current house. I have actually considered staying another 3-5 years but it’s only going to get harder to move. For me, the best thing to do is move soon.

10 Likes