We’re closing in on retirement. My husband just took a new job (God knows why) after being laid off in July (despite the tough job market he’s had multiple offers since then) but he really only plans to stay working another year (his new employer is 100% aware as he was very up front about it). We’ve been meeting with our financial advisor and we are more than set $$ wise. The biggest issue we are looking at is whether to just draw down our investment accounts or buy an annuity that would cover a large % of our basic expenses (property taxes, food, insurance etc) - rates are very high right now and it would allow us to be more aggressive with our other investments. Anyone else gone this route? Pros/Cons?
I would not consider an annuity, but both my H and I have pensions, plus we will get SS, so we have enough “monthly income.” I also don’t expect to live until my 90s, and of course (corrected) annuities may not go to heirs.
I would consider other options before going the annuity route (for example, a bond ladder).
I don’t know much (anything) about annuities, but I think this depends on the type of annuity.
We chose not to invest in an annuity when faced with that decision. We are comfortable with our choice. However, everyone has a different tolerance for risk, and it is best to discuss with your financial advisor. It can be good emotionally to have the security of an annuity, which is like a pension. It’s really a very personal choice.
If you’re considering an annuity, a poster named Stinky on the Bogleheads forum can offer feedback on what you’re looking at.
You are correct. I amended my post. Thanks
We don’t have an annuity. But… we do appreciate the guidance on our FA for spend-down strategies. (He is fee-based, so I still self-manage my 401K based on his general suggestions.)
We have a elderly friend with a big annuity, deferred withdrawals til old age - his FA advised to draw from it first because int that case he or heirs will get taxed at withdrawal (vs stock which will have step-up basis for heir someday). My guess is thath his annuity was purchased as IRA rollover(?)
Why buy an annuity and pay fees when today you can easily earn 5%+ federal tax free and potentially state tax free - buying highly rated muni bonds. I’ve always talked about them. I bought a Garland TX Electric Utility bond yesterday - Insured by Assured Guaranty but AA- on its own - meaning bullet proof - with ten year call protection so it can’t be called. 5% at $97.60 so I didn’t even pay par.
Annuities worry me - they have fees and often people don’t get their principal back. And they’re near impossible to get out of. My BIL was suckered into one years ago when he sold his home and can’t get out “whole.”. I know there are different kinds but objective financial experts often tell people to stay away. And depending on where you live, the taxes can be onerous.
Annuities = fees.
That was such a big shock for me. I had no idea how big the “widow’s tax,” that shift from married to single, would be.
It is part of the argument/analysis for Roth conversions while both spouses are alive.
We have used a FA and have purchased annuities - some have done better than others. But it does give us the freedom to invest with the stock markets/more aggressive (with DH’s 401k investment choices and with our own individual stock account). I don’t like bond and some do, and some get familiar with other investment options. Having the diversification lets us SWAN. We don’t have any significant work annuities/pensions. One company that DH worked for a long time - Contract Electronics Manufacturing, had different company buy-outs, and had a pensions until the last ownership - so we would get cash and stock out from the active pension value - we actually do have $100/month as a work annuity from the last company buy-out, and IDK if it has a survivor benefit or not. That small annuity has shifted around to different payors too with current one being Brighthouse.
I anticipate that your DH really has his identity and likes working for other reasons - and to me that is great unless it impacts you or your family in negative ways or negatively impacts his health.
You can discuss a lot with FA. We have semi-annual group ‘state of the market’, we get weekly emails with short video clips of what is going on financially, and we meet with our FA every 6 months - schedule for after the ‘state of the market’.
We needed diversification and found our FA in 2013. We started purchasing annuities in 2013/2014 after consolidating accounts (we had a lot to consolidate from both DH and myself including Sar-sep, IRAs, etc.). DH has a large 401k that we manage, and his former employer pays overall administrative costs. As annuities have matured, FA has identified other annuities - we currently have 5 annuities with $4300/month income flow (not penalized annuity withdrawals). Almost all have been spun off over time from DH’s 401k when that got ‘too big’ (meaning our risk was high due to so much with stock market accounts).
We did move some funds over these years from IRA to Roth IRAs. Our current break out (from our Balance Sheet) is almost 33% qualified retirement, 26% annuities (which are all pre-tax), 21% real estate (our home), 13% Roth IRAs, the rest is cash/taxable investments.
Currently we are shifting some funds from 401k to us for our individual stock account - in part to build up accessible cash for a big move (selling current home and moving out of state to be near DD1/family and purchasing a home there - anticipate that transpiring in 2028). We also are in the lower tax years and drawing down some of the retirement funds before RMD time.
Between DH and me, we have had 401ks with a number of financial groups, Dreyfus, Prudential, Empower. I analyzed and learned which were the best investment choices - typically 3 or 4 best performers (I tracked results and analyzed, Morningstar etc.) We have our best results from this 401k, and in the more closely watched recent years, only last year did the overall stock market outperform these 401k results (hung in with a small cap fund that have been a super-performer for years and then was not - should have switched out earlier in 2025). 2023 returns was essentially bounce-back from 2022; our 401k 2024 return was 23.38%; the market in 2025 was 17.86% but our 401k only had 4.74% return.
DH has learned a lot more as he became involved with the education and meetings with FAs. DH prints off our monthly Balance Sheet.
Both DDs have become pretty knowledgeable about their retirement funds. One DD has hers in Roth IRAs, and I helped her get the right mix and get her educated. She had a rollover from working for the state of AL - so moved those into IRA and then Roth IRA.
We educated ourselves in ways our parents had not, which included the purchase of term life insurance. We have some paid-up other life insurance where the premiums are paid from dividends. SIL finally got in agreement on having enough term life insurance on himself (they have 5 children ages 1 - 8 and need the safety of life insurance!!). I still carry term life insurance on both DDs and DH and I are beneficiaries - purchased these policies when they were 21. The small premiums each year - and can eventually have ownership and payor change (DDs are 32 and 30 now).
My previous post was edited by the moderators so I’ll make the point alternatively.
Below is a 10 year US Treasury bond chart. So we’ve seen mortgages go up, probably student loan rates, but what has also gone up are savings instruments. That’s why now is a more fruitful time to buy than, say 6 months and a year ago so it’s a great time to invest in income (vs. the past many years). Of course, no one knows what things will be like in 6 months, 1 year, or 5 years from now, but that’s why many instruments have timed guarantees - like I buy longer term paper that can’t be paid off early until 2036, etc. I’m know other securities - corporate, federal agency and likely things like annuities (through insurance companies) likely have similar stiupulations.
My husband thinks of purchasing an annuity as doing the math to see if it’s an effective investment
After seeing the rate of return and the cost, he decided that the rate of returns with the stock market is a better bet
I have a family member who is convinced that his home is a worthwhile investment. I’m not as sure. In the same way, some people like annuities.
I know that I’m not paying off my 3% mortgage as the stock market is historically better than paying the 3% interest
Why? Because we have a trusted financial advisor who we discussed muni bonds with. He said this was not something we should consider at all. So…we aren’t.
We don’t have annuities either.
Different strokes for different folks.
As long as they are providing tools for you to earn the income that you need.
But people also pay their trusted advisor. It’s their choice, of course - but whether a % or by the hour - people are eating into their returns.
And it’s funny because financial advisors talk about - reducing fees. Many are fiduciaries and still recommend high cost products.
Bottom line - however you find your income (I also own agency bonds and corporate bonds but bought them in tax deferred account), now is a great time.
Not everyone has the same comfort or knowledge and that’s where an FA comes in. For those who choose to use one, that’s fine. It’s their money after all.
I do think where a FA can help everyone is tax avoidance. For example, if someone donates regularly to charity, setting up a fund so you can put appreciate stock there and not pay the gain, etc. Things like that and other of the more peculiar parts of the tax code are definitely areas where having an expert can help all - even the self investor.
I’m going to admit that I don’t think highly of annuities but wonder whether there is something i’m not getting about them.
I don’t understand why you would pay a fee and lock up your money to get a guaranteed return when there are other ways to get guaranteed returns. After you take off the cost of the fees, what kind of return are you assured?
My husband and I assembled a small portfolio of mostly biotech and pharmaceutical stocks. Some pay dividends so our overall rate is about 3-4%. That is our “annuity.” And before I get pounded for not understanding the risks and tax implications… I do, very much so. Of course a dividend is not guaranteed but I have a suspicion that many pharmas would do anything before cutting their dividend. We hope not to touch the principal for a long time. This is not to say that I endorse this approach. Not to be confused with financial advice ![]()
I don’t know much about them, I admit, except that every article I read in a money management magazine say stay away. Yet advisors push them.
I often look at the ones colleges offer - thinking you’re doing a good deed. These ads they put in magazines are meant to pull at the heartstrings and they do.
You give them $100K and then they pay you $7K for as long as you live - then they keep your $100K.
People continue to buy them so…but it’s like whole life insurance, everyone says not to, and yet insurance companies are still peddling.
The reality is - forgetting fixed income (I seek income so I seek it) but few pros even beat the market in general which is why the indexes are more than half of all fund types out there and dwarf actively managed. Of course, some advisors use index funds.
Here’s some basic info on annuities - to maybe try and learn more.
Annuities fulfill a specific need that is not fulfilled by bonds or stocks, rather than being a simple good or bad. For example, suppose a risk averse retired person wants a constant fixed payment throughout their lifetime, regardless of how long they live. Annuities can do this well, while stocks and bonds may be less effective.
In theory withdrawing <4% from stock equities each year is very likely to last a lifetime, but it’s not guaranteed. If there is a Nikkei type decades decline, balance may drop to 0 prior to death. Bonds can provide a fixed income stream throughout the bond contract, but after bond contract is over, new bond rate may change dramatically after contract… potentially close to 0% as we saw prior to COVID inflation. In contrast, annuities can continue payments at same or inflation adjusted rate, throughout lifetime.
Annuities can also have more variable contract terms to fulfill specific retired persons needs than is common in bonds or stocks. For example, there were some recent comments about financial challenges if spouse dies. Annuities can have terms that change payment rate after 1 spouse dies. One can negotiate specific terms to meet this type of need. Unlike bonds annuities could have terms that wait until a particular age/date to start payments, or annuities can have terms related to unexpected large long term care costs.
That said, annuities have numerous downsides as well. With more variable terms, there is more opportunity to get stuck in a bad contract, contract that does not meet expressed needs, or contract with much higher fees than stocks or bonds. There are many unscrupulous salespersons. It’s common to have limitations that restrict selling early, and it’s common for insurer to keep value upon death instead of passing value as inheritance.
I don’t have annuities or plan to purchase in future, but I can understand why others would choose to do.
Not exactly true - there are zero coupon bonds that start paying after a certain time. While not common, CUSIP 977266HX6 Wiseburn California School district was a 0% since inception on May 4, 2011 - but steps up to 7.3% on 8/1/26.
One thing a bond can’t assure is through a lifetime, unless they are issued as non callable - which is possible but might pay a lesser rate. Many bonds have a 10 year non-call from issuance but when you buy them on the market as most do, you are not buying from issuance. So I buy, today, recently issued - because the 10 year has risen so precipitously that prices have dropped. The beauty of a bond is you don’t need to care about the price - if it dropped - because you will be paid back in full, short of default which is rare to never. But you are correct, in ten years, if the bond is called, I will earn a different rate. Interestingly, the New York MTA called 3.75% bonds a few months ago which was a gift. I replaced it was a larger coupon at well under 100 - so it works both ways.
One other issue with annuities - there’s no assurance the backer will be in business. I suppose one can say that for cities, states, public colleges and airports too.
If people want to purchase annuities, it’s their choice and that’s fine for them. Some pay more, willingly and thank goodness because these providers support many jobs.
I don’t like high commission products and if I were to buy one, all the discount brokerages have experts, and i’d likely start there, at least as a basis for comparison.
It’s too hard to make money, to then give it all away on what is in essence a commodity (in my opinion). Others think otherwise so that’s great for them. No issue at all.
Anyway, really the point is - for income seekers, now is a much better time to strike on these products during any time over the past many years (except for a very quick period when we all thought Covid was going to end the world.
Hence I put up the 10 year bond chart - that’s really the only point. Of course, because of this rise, high yielding stocks have likely fallen because their advantage isn’t as great vs. when bond yields were lower.
The issue is more with bonds having a fixed duration vs lasting whatever is the combined lifetime of both spouses, rather than non-callable not being available.
The risk of default varies wildly with the quality of bonds. For example, a 10-year bond with C rating historically has a ~70% chance of default. While a 10-year US treasury bond has a historical 0% chance of default. Bond yield varies to compensate for this variable risk.
