I asked DH about a bond ladder, and he said we have an equivalent with structured notes. It’s all above my pay grade.
The annuity products we have purchased have typically been insurance company products. We pay in an amount, and some have choices on investment options with various guarantees. Certainly our FA does receive a commission. Our FA manages many things on it for us, so after a year we choose to receive draws from the annuity that is penalty-free. The hope is that the annuity retains its value because the investment earnings keep pace with the draws. Our annuities have ranged from 5 years to 12 years when they ‘mature’. One can exit an annuity prior to maturity and take the contracted penalty. At maturity or withdrawal, we have the remaining cash value.
To respond to “every article I read in a money management magazine says stay away” from annuities. Some FA may push in part due to their commission, but purchasing annuities can reduce one’s overall portfolio risk.
Annuities can range from bad to good, and ‘the devil is in the details’.
Similar to any other fixed income products.
@Data10 of course you don’t buy speculative paper when you are buying for a secure cash flow - ie C paper. But even junk muni defaults are nowhere near 30%. They are single digits.
Personally I don’t buy less than A+ / A1 rated and often but not always insured. Yesterday I almost bought Oakland U, a public college in Michigan, with outstanding financials. It wasn’t insured and while strongly rated, it was a notch below what I bought. It was $1.10 cheaper and I’d have no concern with it but I opted for what I did. Many minds, like the Oakland bond, are refunding bonds - meaning they paid off earlier paper with it.
But I would never recommend anyone buy junk paper and not even investment grade B paper when looking to protect principal. Every state, even Illinois, is rated in the As. They were B paper, still safe, but the governor has turned around the balance sheet. Big cities are also mainly high rated although Chicago is in the Bs. They are calling bonds now. I have one called this week so it’s a good trade for me. I’ll buy a higher rated, same coupon, under par. But they have no issue servicing their debt, regardless of headlines.
As for any product, it’s easy to compare a price for the identical at a discounter (like Schwab or Fidelity) vs full service. You can easily determine how much more you are paying. On bonds, usually 1.5-2 percentage points - not insignificant. They all sell identical paper as they are not owned but sold over the marketplace for any broker to access.
My earlier figure was not specific to municipal bonds. I’m not aware of anyone tracking default rates for C rather than combined CCC+/CCC/… category. I expect failure rate for ‘C’ (not CCC+/…) would be above 70%+ for municipal bonds. The combined category reaches well above 30% for S&P, as pictured below. However, the specific default rates aren’t important. My larger point was that one cannot assume bonds will always have a default rate of “rare to never” as was claimed. If you want a default rate of “rare to never” choose the specific bonds that correspond to that rarity, which is obviously not C rating, but also not B rating and not some types of A’s as well.
Again I don’t think it is a simple good/bad… more different products for different purposes. The price/rate of the bond settles on a level that the market determines as fair compensation for the increased risk of default. With a high enough risk of default, the bond yield to maturity could be >= 20%/year. In theory one could purchase a large number of lower rated 20%/year type bonds to distribute the risk, leading to a higher risk adjusted return than other alternative investments. However, I agree that this degree of risk likely corresponds to a different type of investor than a retired person considering annuities.
Can we move on?
This has been litigated over and over again on this thread.
Is the municipal the dotted line and corporate the smooth line on the graph?
Probably the first time I’ve seen Oakland U mentioned on CC. My S has a degree from OU. ![]()
OU has been mentioned b4 - U of Oklahoma ![]()
If we ever have a college hoops thread, Oakland could appear. A few times at least, they’ve shocked the world !!!
I’ll edit to add that there are many OU grads in my industry - plus the Michigan directionals, Kettering and schools like Albion which makes sense give the historical of automotive dominance in Michigan.
Corporate is the dotted line on the left. Municipals is the solid line on the right.
What is your timeframe? From 1970-2022, munis defaulted at .08%. A default doesn’t mean they don’t pay, btw but rather could be they were simply late.
This might be an easier way to see the data. Many brokerages, btw, including the two I use, don’t offer junk paper to retail purchasers. They leave that for institutional buyers.
As stated, default rate varies by rating. Earlier graphic was for 10-years with S&P rules/definitions.
Munis mostly depend on the marginal tax rate.
Most folks add fixed income (bonds, bond funds, GICs) to their pre-tax account. But if one’s Investment Plan suggests that that they need more bonds (to manage their Asset Allocation), AND their pretax account is already 100% bonds, their only choice is to add bonds to their taxable account. And, if they have a high marginal tax rate (fed+state), then Munis can make a lot of sense.
Depends on the type of bonds. Corporate and federal yes. They are taxable so they belong in pre tax. Munis - no - as you pay no federal tax nor state tax if it’s a bond issued from within your state or any U.S. territory. So they belong in a taxable account. 5%, if your bracket is 33%, is like a 7.5% taxable yield.
Here’s a little more - from anyone interested. They note they’re not just for the wealthy, because from Warren Buffett to Ray Kroc (McDonalds) to Pres Trump and really tons of wealthy people are. That’s why I note them. If you are retired, it’s a great way to have significant cash flow, with a better after tax return than other instruments.
This was a really good summary of three retirement ‘traps’
1 - Having been a world class saver, and now you have trouble turning on spending. “Build a joy fund for some experiences”
2 - Retirement gives/means freedom, but “freedom w/o structure is like a long Sunday afternoon that never ends.” Figure out what gives your days meaning and shape, and schedule to do those things to stop from feeling lost including one significant thing in the first 12 months of retirement.
3 - The changes, be it declining health, shrinking social circle (as fewer surviving friends as time goes on), lower energy. Be prepared for this - and continue to do what you can do with being between go-go years and slow-go years.
Thanks everyone for sharing your thoughts on annuities. I’m well aware of their potential downsides (I worked in financial services for 15 years) and have been disposed to reject them out of hand. The one we are considering is fixed and would pay 7.45% for the rest of our lives - it’s a joint product - and if we both went down in a fiery crash our heirs would get a portion of the principal back unless we’d been paid out more than our initial investment. The one other thing that has caused me to consider it is that we would purchase an annuity with $$ from our 401k which would reduce our future taxes (the purchase would be tax free although we’d be paying tax on the income). It’s really a question of paying taxes now or later on -taking payouts from our investment accounts would be lower tax for now but would leave us with enormous MRD later on. Still undecided, of course, but those are some of the things we’ve been thinking about.
It sounds like you are a good researcher and have found a reasonable option. Good luck as you sort through the pros/cons.
It’s always hard to know what long term plan is best. So for me it gives peace of mind to have diversity… in a portfolio with different kinds of investments (which may or may not include annuities). Of course I don’t want to be so scattered that it confuses the kids someday if they are helping us with finances (and eventually dealing with an estate).
I don’t know your tax bracket but if you had a 5% muni at let’s say $98 (so a 5.1 yield tax free) - if you’re in a state where your tax bracket is 33% (fed, state, city), you’d lock in income for 9 years + (don’t know your life expectancy) and no heir would ever lose a cent. In fact, they’d be paid back whenever the maturity was called or matured - at 100 cents on the dollar so whoever collects will make $200 for each $9800 spent.
If you live more than ten years and it’s called (meaning paid off early, which is not assured but possible), then yes you may have to reinvest at a lower rate or rates may be higher.
Personally, I don’t understand being ok with loss of principal. That principal can be used to create income for future generations, long after you’re gone. But they can’t use it for future income, if the insurance company takes it.
When I read this, it sounds like - really you are the one paying yourself interest via your own principal - hence it’s being reduced. That doesn’t seem a great deal, to me anyway. It is a great deal for the insurance company, who for all intents and purposes, would be thieving you.
Not sure I understand this.
(And don’t forget, some of that ‘guaranteed’ payout is just a return of your original principal.)
I’m surprised at you @Data10 for allowing the inclusion in your post of a graph that connects discrete points with no meaning interstitially!
Whatever the choice of investments, do try to keep some kind of good summary page.
I’ve mentioned it before, but repeating in case new readers. My husband’s one-pager financial snapshot is great! It includes investments handled by our FA as well as those not in his fee-based accounts. (FA advises knowing the big picture of all.) It can be a very simple page, numbers gathered/noted by hand. In our case, the data for the summary is fed automatically is from mu husband’s beloved, complicated multi-tab spreadsheet he started many years before retirement. He sends it to our FA before our quarterly-ish meetings, prints a copy for me. Most but not all of the accounts I studya see via online access, but the summary page is ever so helpful.

