How Much Do You think You Need to Retire? What Age Will You/Spouse Retire? Investment and General Retirement Issues (Part 3)

That would be a helpful thing if Trust does what you want. Great that the neighbor has lawyers. Of course if the plan looks promising you’d need your own lawyer. Do watch carefully about type of trust - I’ve heard cases where only irrevocable trusts yield tax advantages.

1 Like

Ugh, I keep getting conflicting answers from AI. I’m just going to see a lawyer!

4 Likes

similar to TV show “Ozark”

1 Like

A suggestion, if you really want the land - is to fashion an agreement with purchasing the entire property and binding that he can lease the home until he dies. To me that would be a cleaner way to do it. Something to discuss with your legal counsel.

2 Likes

She said he isn’t interested in a lease, but the more I read back about this possible agreement, is that it’s very one-sided. It’s all based on what he wants. It sounds a little rigid and inflexible and unwilling to consider what it will take to make the deal work. Maybe if @busdriver11 sits back and waits, or lets him know that the options he’s proposing are not workable for them, he’ll have to cool his jets and be willing to reconsider it if it’s if his if his goal is to avoid probate when he dies. It’s also worth considering to have the property and the house appraised since he’s come up with a number that may or may not be appropriate.

I also wonder/worry what he has told his sister about this potential deal because who knows if she’s expecting to come into Money and inherit this property. And I wonder if he’s having some cash flow problems because he’s pushing to sell this property and unwilling to pay to lease the house back. It seems to have a lot of red flags.

3 Likes

There are a lot of red flags, but I think much of it is because he’s elderly and very stubborn. I do have a call into a real estate/probate attorney today, so hopefully that will enlighten us.

I thought I came up with a perfect solution yesterday, and then my husband said nope, too confusing. I was thinking we could purchase it from him, give him a 20% down payment, and he would carry the loan….with the remaining amount upon his death to be paid as a balloon payment to his sister upon death. Zero interest for us to pay, and zero payment for him to live there. That way we lock it up and he also gets what he wants. I don’t even know if that could be done.

2 Likes

If he wants to drive this deal, then perhaps suggest he come up with something else (if he isn’t open to your suggestions).

1 Like

Sounds like something Marty and Wendy Byrd had to deal with.

I haven’t seen that series. My husband could be Jason Bateman, but I’m no Laura Linney. :laughing:

I think his only suggestion so far is that we purchase it and he stays there for life. He’s 89 years old and very stubborn. He seems to be open to other possibilities, but he isn’t coming up with them.

There’s got to be a win/win scenario in this somehow. I’ll find out in a few hours!

Not to be too dark, but what would happen if he died today? It would be the thing that he doesn’t want, right?

2 Likes

If he passed away today, everything would go to probate. His sister would eventually end up with dealing with the house and hopefully since his friends know we want it, it could be sold to us. Or it could be years and eventually go onto the market, or be reclaimed by the bank of mortgage payments stop.

So the one thing that would happen is the one thing he knows he doesn’t want – for this to go to probate and his sister having to deal with it all and be delayed in receiving her inheritance. That’s what I would tell him, that not making a decision is making a decision and that decision would be the one thing he has said he is trying to avoid. In other words, prime the pump for trying to get him to see that his stubbornness is going to result in the thing he doesn’t want. Are y’all able to speak frankly like that?

6 Likes

I do have a lot of experience doing deals. In this kind of circumstance, logic is not likely to be sufficient to motivate him to act. @busdriver11, you should convey @Youdon_tsay’s point, which is that doing nothing means, in effect, the outcome he wants to avoid. So, he needs to do something. More generally, while positive self-interest can motivate people to act, they are more likely to act to avoid a loss. Fear is a better motivator than greed in many cases. So, I think it will be important to make the downside case of doing nothing salient. Details about what will happen to a German citizen inheriting a US property through probate.

What’s tricky here is that the prospective seller is not listening particularly well and maybe not be thinking well. He is unlikely to trust anything that @busdriver11 says. Is there someone he will listen to? Does he listen to his attorney? His sister? A child?

Once the vision of downside becomes real to him, he is likely to become more flexible about transferring the property in a mutually beneficial manner.

6 Likes

We have a friend who did this with the home their family grew up in. The neighbor (which was a local business) wanted to buy the property. This was about 20 years ago. The friend’s mother and brother were still living there. The deal they made (with a contract), was the neighbors bought the property and would allow the mother and son to continue to live there as long as they could. The mother died about two years later. The son died last year.

This worked well for everyone. The small business got the house, and my friend’s sibling and mom had a place to live in for life.

The new owners did all of the outside maintenance. Anything infrastructure wise, they also handled. Anything IN the house was the old family responsibility. So when they needed a new fridge, my friend actually bought it….things like that.

Is it possible to do this in your state @busdriver11 ?

2 Likes

If you do a “for life” deal, considering putting a cap on that. Perhaps 10 years (or maybe less).

2 Likes

He is 89, so there’s that, and not in good health. But you never know.

His friends have been speaking frankly to him about this. We just don’t know him enough to do this, though, but it was his idea. We didn’t broach this to him, he offered it to us, so I think he gets it.

2 Likes

It is very tricky. He is highly suspicious of anyone who seems to want to take advantage of him, but we absolutely don’t.

As far as @thumper1 's post, that is about what the attorney came up with that I talked to today. She said no, don’t do the revocable living trust, too much legal peril and questions in this scenario. She also said the TODD would leave no guarantee that it would end up going to us. The sister could sell it to anyone. Or not knowing what to do, no one.

We’re bringing him an offer tomorrow (or at least a suggestion of an offer) with a standard purchase and sale agreement for the price he wants, with a Life Estate deed. We get put on the property title and deed, and when he dies, it automatically goes to us. He gets to live there until he dies, but he’s responsible for all taxes and maintenance. Since we won’t have full access to the property till he passes away, we don’t want to give him all the money, so we’ll give him a deposit for the amount of his mortgage owed, and a balloon payment with zero interest for the rest, payable to his sister (with a no-probate transfer clause) upon his death. We’ll also add something about the Life Estate ending if he permanently moves to assisted living. Apparently this is a clean deal, nothing untoward.

We’ll find out if he really wanted this, because it gives him what he wants!

7 Likes

I worry that if he passes, maybe his German custodian has other thoughts.

It just may not be meant to be.

No matter what you suggest, he’s going to be wary.

If he’s not willing to rent back, it’s odd he approached you.

What is it he wants - you to pay him and he’ll live free?

That’s the sense I get - so something breaks and you have to fix.

I think I’d walk away, regardless of the adjacency and future desire.

It’s too big an expense and something can go seriously wrong.

Maybe it’s not meant to be, but it was his idea, he’s seeing his mortality and we are the perfect people to sell this to. We would have appreciation for his property and take care of it more than any other person. I think he’s aware of that on some level. He reminds me so much of my dad.

He doesn’t want to rent back because I don’t think he’s ever been a renter in his life, he can’t even conceptualize that. I believe that someone else offered him a deal like this and then changed their mind. The positive for us is if he agrees to carry the note. The purchase price is 800K, and I’m guessing his mortgage is around 200K. So we give him the $200K, and the balance is due at the end of life. The balance is minus any liens, property taxes and maintenance we pay for (things that he should have been paying for). So if we have to come up with money to take care of the house, and I don’t know why we would, he’s done a great job taking care of things, that subtracts from the final payment.

We REALLY want this property, for so many reasons. We’d probably pay more if we had to.

1 Like