True. But I imagine you’d be the quicker/easier deal. At least with that option you have a lot of future flexibilty.
Study Life Estate factors carefully. Life Tenancy may be more appropriate(?)
For different Life Estate situation, I recently learned that if a Life Estate person leaves before death, owners need to buy out remaining time based on IRS rules.
Could you pay less up front but don’t charge him rent - but put in the contract that at his passing, you’ll pay the delta to his sister.
So if it’s $800K, pay him $700K but don’t charge rent - and then pay the difference at his death, minus x amount per year that he would have paid rent…if that makes sense.
So let’s say the price is $800K but you give $600K. Let’s say you charge $3K per month rent.
So if he lives 4 years, that’s $144K and you’d then pay the extra $56K to his heir?
I’m just - throwing an idea against the wall.
I get that you are the perfect buyer - I just see how these things go sideways. And that scares me.
At 89, living alone, that’s pretty dicey - but no one wants to hear that - for sure.
Could you talk to his sister to at least have a relation for when something happens? It’s tough.
I don’t know German, so talking to his sister is out of the picture. The offer that I just typed out is pretty simple. He gets his price, but only enough to pay off his mortgage at first, with the rest to be paid out upon his death/leaving the property. No rent from him, no cost to us. I think this is actually what he wanted (except for the amount paid at closing, we’ll see how that goes).
Within your agreement, what will happen if the sister dies first, and whatever it is, will it keep the deal intact?
Do you think the attorney you are speaking with is familiar with the kind of thing you’re trying to do/an expert in that type of issue? The reason I ask, is I’m getting the impression the person picked by people I know is NOT the right person for their particular situation, but someone made a decision without understanding how complicated their situation is, based partly on time constraints, not asking enough questions beforehand.
@busdriver11 - I hope you find a solution suitable to all. I didn’t realize he still had a mortgage. I assume for you it will be a cash purchase.
Think about what your path will be if he does not pay taxes, insurance (by decision or by elderly oversight). You can put it in the contract, but you can’t know that he will follow through on his end. Just be ready with risk mitigation idea.
We’re going to see if he has an alternate beneficiary, and put that on the note. The lawyer that I’m working with is wonderful, I’ve worked with her before on both estate matters and real estate closings. What is so bizarre is that she is the attorney that my legal plan assigned me to randomly. I was amazed, because I’d been searching for her after she left her last firm, and here she is now. So pleased.
I’m assuming he has a mortgage, because I was able to look at what is recorded on the property, and it looks like the only lien. We would not get a mortgage.
The great thing about still owing a big balloon payment at the end is being able to deduct any expenses we have over the years, that he should have paid and didn’t. Fortunately his huge property tax discount stays on the property with a life estate.
I would definitely consider you paying the taxes.. as he gets older, he may forget or not be able to pay them. adjust the price accordingly and figure on 10 years of tax payments when making the adjustment!
Note that there may be an income cap for that senior tax discount (NY is $110K, I think). And he will get windfall income at house sale. Oh.. the lookback is prior tax year, so it would while til discount denial (if it happens).
The cruiseship has been all over the news! I feel particularly bad for the woman who has to deal with paperwork to travel with her cat that was onboard with her.
As for @busdriver, what if he decides to get a live-in caregiver? Would he/she have any guaranteed housing rights (probably not but worth a thought). And what if he lives like the woman in France? To 122??? Unlikely, but……
We had a meeting with him today and I think it went really well. We left paperwork with him so he could look at. The reality is, we like him. We admire him. And if he lives for a long time, good for him. We would only have a relatively small amount of money tied up in the property, which would guarantee we do get the property after his passing. If someone else lived with him, it’s irrelevant, it’s based upon his life.
And looking at the property again, he has done a very admirable job of taking care of it. I don’t think that will stop.
I came here to comment on the Villa Vie Cruise ship issue, but someone has already posted. I have been trying to understand the situation from a financial perspective. Examining the financial disclosures of any enterprise where you commit your money is the key. In this case, fuel prices are the easy scapegoat, but I think the business model was flawed and the cabins were underpriced. We are so risk averse, but we have had five hurricanes in ten years, so we know nothing is risk-free. Anyone else had the dream of moving onto a cruise ship instead of independent living?