How Much Do You think You Need to Retire? What Age Will You/Spouse Retire? Investment and General Retirement Issues (Part 3)

I have seen a story or two in the past with individuals living on a much lower end almost 100% sea travel, with cargo ships that have accommodations along with other kinds of travel by sea mixing in - and one knowledgeable mixing a lifestyle. Very few would really want to do that IMHO, but it was something a few are doing.

One doesn’t know what kind of personal funds individuals have after the Villa Vie Cruise ship stoppage of service (and abrupt stop of contracted services).

One does hope that changes external - where one lives - does not make it impossible to continue to live in retirement place.

1 Like

Not really - it would be too hard for me to give up a “home base” residence, a key part of making it financially viable. But we do joke about it sometimes at our weekly beer night, where most of us are in our 60s or 70s.

2 Likes

They had to price to attract. At the same time, fuel was unknown but they had asked people to pay more and they did. I don’t know if possible fuel charges were in the prospectus.

Hopefully all could afford this. One said it was buying into a startup. They knew the risk of that.

My dad is on 4 or 5 cruises now, back to back. If someone really wanted to do this, they could probably fund established cruise line cabins for many years, adding an occasional flight and hotel - to change ports.

It’s sad but hopefully no one is destitute and they will recover, having had a truly awesome experience.

2 Likes

There was a WSJ article a few years ago about elderly people who had were going cruise to cruise to cruise as a permanent life with no home base because they could get all kinds of assistance on the ships and didn’t have to cook or manage many details of life and that it was less expensive than assisted living.

5 Likes

Gift link about the Villa View Cruise ship issue, from today https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/28/travel/endless-cruise-suspended-villa-vie-passengers.html?unlocked_article_code=1.M1E.mzZU.3MgNbyuDv4QE&smid=url-share

Financial excerpts: Its priciest options, which provided ownership of a suite and permanent residency on the Odyssey for the life span of the ship, cost from $119,999 to $439,999, plus fixed monthly fees of $3,500 to $11,000; a five-year ownership plan started at $49,999 plus monthly fees. There were also flexible and short-term rental rates." … Villa Vie said its monthly fuel expense per cabin in parts of Asia had risen to $6,000 to $8,000, from $1,800. “We cannot simply pass increases of that scale on to residents,”…The company tried to introduce a $1,500 monthly fuel surcharge, but 70 percent of residents refused to pay, Mr. Petterson said. Many had already contributed thousands of dollars in cash to keep the ship afloat this year.

5 Likes

For those interested in helping colleges out while maintaining an income, I’ve seen multiple college ads like this for annuities
Pomona and maybe others. This from Kiplingers.

Your principal will be gone - never good in my opinion - but you’ll have income and support a good cause.

1 Like

I’m always looking for the “best” place to retire. NYTimes had an interesting article which I’ve attached the gift link for and also a link to the WalletHub information the article discusses. A lot of places I wouldn’t ever want to live!

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/29/realestate/the-best-cities-to-retire-in-2026.html?unlocked_article_code=1.NFE.0ude.LS4t_herHvOq&smid=url-share

2 Likes

I saw that in NY Times today, and they don’t spell out all the 5 matrixes (they list the best reasons under the top cities and the worst rated reasons on the bottom) - too bad they didn’t give the whole list of cities along with the rating on each of the five matrixes. However, none of it can drill down what would be quality of life for specific retirees - some who want to live in a certain location or who have family near a certain location.

I thought this was a good look at something in a particular area that is answering some individuals’ ideas of what works well for them.

Renting in White Plains to Be Close to Family, and a Lichtenstein - The New York Times

1 Like

If you look at the second link all of the cities are ranked. You can sort them by the criteria most relevant to your needs.

3 Likes

I think a number of the places in Florida that wallethub/NYT link may lose a lot of economic value as the water level rises and extreme storms become increasingly more frequent. Orlando is probably unaffected by both, but the projects for Tampa/St. Petersburg, as an example, are not pretty. My casual persual suggests a modest decline in property values for Sanibel already.

4 Likes

I’m not sure why Detroit is ranked low in healthcare. The city and surrounding area has excellent healthcare options.

1 Like

Our DD live in Orlando, but on the northern border (Altamonte Springs) - and the rain during the big hurricane that hit south of Tampa a few years ago had some flooding in southern portions of Orlando - and also loss of power. At her residence she lost power for about 24 hours - and her nearby company office had already shut down for that day in anticipation of the storm. She did the best she could for having her work done (as an engineer she puts her time to the projects).

As another indicated, one plans for contingencies in various areas. Our niece’s home is in the ‘greater’ Tampa area but in Wesley Chapel - so far from where the storms came through. Not sure how well they could do with 100-year type situation.

We owned a house in Houston for less than a year because we took a company move (it was our first purchased home, 1979). During that ownership time, Houston did have flooding, and the first home we put an offer on did flood (it was an established home/neighborhood and the owners decided not to sell). The home we purchased had a very large concrete bayou behind it (very big, very deep) and thankfully it did not come close to the top. One of my coworkers had a home where the flood came up to her front door (2 story home), and she had owned the home a long time and had lived through earlier type situation.

I do think newly retirees do need to think very carefully on selling current home and relocating/buying elsewhere - and also if they are relocating to where their children/grandchildren are, if that is not going to change. Many jobs don’t move as much as they have in the past, but one can change employer/industry and the seniors are left rethinking their situation.

I found that perplexing as well. We’ve actually been looking in Michigan and Northern Ohio and healthcare factors in heavily for us.

MrSabaray thinks he would like Florida but we’d need a lot more $$$ and honestly, hurricanes and flooding scare me more than blizzards.

4 Likes

Good points, @SOSConcern. Changes in weather and related events just seemed like a consideration that was not in the mix of great places to retire. As examples, in four of the top five places, the next 25 years could lead to pretty stark changes that reduce property values and quality of life in some of those places:

Miami: Researchers project that South Florida will face severe, chronic flooding and up to around 10 to 18 inches of sea-level rise by 2050 (25 years from now), with a long-term projection of nearly 60% of Miami-Dade County becoming submerged or chronically underwater by 2060.

Tampa/St. Petersburg: In 25 years (around 25 years from now in 2051), the Tampa and St. Petersburg areas will not be completely underwater, but they will experience 1 to 1.5 feet of sea level rise, leading to significantly more frequent chronic flooding rather than total permanent submersion. [1, 2]

Key Projections for 25 Years Out (2051)

  • Sea Level Rise: According to the Tampa Bay Climate Science Advisory Panel (CSAP) and NOAA projections, sea levels in the region are expected to rise roughly 10 to 18 inches (about 1 to 1.5 feet) above 2000 levels by 2050. [1, 2]
  • Permanent Inundation vs. Tidal Flooding: While vast portions of the entire region won’t be permanently submerged day-to-day, low-lying neighborhoods and coastal flash points—such as St. Petersburg’s Shore Acres, Tampa’s Davis Islands, the St. Petersburg waterfront, and parts of Clearwater Beach—will face dramatic increases in sunny-day and king-tide flooding. [1, 2]
  • Frequency of Floods: Tidal and nuisance flood days (which used to happen only a few times a year) are projected to jump drastically—potentially escalating to tens or over 70 days per year in low-lying spots. [1]
  • Storm Surge Vulnerability: The real danger in 25 years is how higher baseline water levels amplify hurricanes and storm surges. An extra foot of sea level means a standard storm surge will push much further inland, threatening homes, infrastructure, and local real estate values

Orlando: Over the next 25 years (through roughly 2050), climate change will reshape Orlando primarily through rising temperatures, heavier rainfall including more frequent and disruptive hurricanes, and increased strain from severe weather and urban heat

Scottsdale: Triple-digit days will continue to expand, with projections showing days over 109.3°F rising sharply from around 7 annually historically to nearly 47 days a year by 2050. Plus there will be increasing pressure on water supplies and remarkably much higher risk of flash floods.

@kelsmom, it looks like the criteria for health care heavily weight number of providers per capita more than the quality of the facilities there. Boston was number 18, I believe, in health care, which does not make sense if you weight quality of the docs and hospitals (and Sioux City, IA was number 1, I think) but might make sense if you look at availability of providers per capita.

7 Likes

While amusing to read, any selected weighting is likely to have little resemblance to what a particular person values, making the ranking have little meaning for a particular person deciding where to retire. I’d make similar comments about college rankings based on a formula for “best college” using arbitrarily selected weights of a lot of different numbers.

For example, looking at the Wallet Hub list, the city ranked highest in Quality of Life is Scottsdale, AZ. I am familiar with Scottsdale, and it certainly wouldn’t be highest Quality of Life for me. The 25% weighting Quality of Life category seems to be based on ~14 sub-category weightings of either 1.7% or 3.3%, such as strength of elder abuse protections, share of population 65+ living alone, and mild weather. I’d personally place a far greater weight on mild weather than 3% and a far lower weight on many of the other categories, which would lead to a very different ranking for my highest quality of life.

Or the 25% activities ranking places equal weight on bingo halls per capita, fishing facilities per capita, and ~10 other categories. I don’t care about bingo or fishing, but I do care about other things that aren’t listed such as proximity to quality hiking areas; so again my list of locations with best activities would be completely different.

5 Likes

Can’t a post just be for entertainment once in a blue moon? Bingo and fishing aren’t high on my list of activities either, but I know there are many people who enjoy those activities. Availability of and ease of access to public transportation is something that is important to me, but I don’t see that factored in. I’m sure someone will correct me if I’m wrong. I don’t know that these are intended to be considered seriously by people looking to retire elsewhere. For a long time I thought I wanted to live close to my D, but I’ve realized I wouldn’t be happy in the DC area for a variety of reasons. I just know I don’t want to stay here!

7 Likes

Yes, my post began “while amusing to read”… fine for entertainment purposes. I’m sure many people also use such lists to help decide where to retire, rather than just for entertainment.

1 Like

I agree with @Data10 and other’s comments. I’m not concerned about fishing, I’m a lot less concerned about daily COL but would give higher wait to state taxes and inheritance taxes and would care about whether there is an active critical mass of high quality artists more than I care about the number of museums.

But, my concern was really about what they did not rank rather than the weights of the things that they ranked. It does seem to be a pretty weak ranking system if 50% or 60% of your third-ranked city is projected to be underwater in 25 years. It is a safe bet that having half the city underwater will reduce the quality of life in many other ways if bingo halls and museums have to shut down (though possibly fishing facility numbers could increase). Subway systems and coastal highways could be permanently flooded. Am I missing something here?

2 Likes

When we chose where to move, we were strongly considering political and climate issues. One big consideration was to be above the 42 parallel (so much farther north than Texas), and in a place that has access to farmland and water, and jobs for our kids and their spouses.
Another biggie was to be in a more socially supported space. GLad we left before the attack on libraries and the right to read, and the posting of the Ten commandments!

We looked at the data and projections for floods, wildfires, storms, temperatures.

8 Likes

Crazy that Chicago was 19th on activities and Cincinnati was top 5. Blows my mind.

It is fun to read lists like this, but we all have our own differences.

7 Likes