Northern Ohio has the Cleveland Clinic, I think it is known for good quality healthcare. I have family members who speak highly of it. There are other health systems in the Cleveland area that are highly rated.
Southeast Michigan also has good health care facilities. I think it’s called Corewell in its latest form and is in the Detroit and Grand Rapids area. There’s also the university of Michigan healthcare system.
I wouldn’t worry about healthcare in those areas. Isn’t it funny sometimes what these surveys or articles say?
In northeast Ohio, there is Cleveland Clinic, Metro Hospitals, and University Hospitals…all large and very well established health care systems.
My family lives there and two sisters worked for Cleveland Clinic. Back in the day, my mom worked at University Hospital main campus.
I have a ton of high school and college friends who live there, and they say accessibility to doctors and network strengths are very strong.
If I could convince my husband to move to Ohio, health care would not be a concern of mine at.all. Also, the cost of living there is much more modest than where I live in New England. IOW retirement money would go a long way there.
As we have talked about before each of us will have different criteria. For me it’s weather, family, liberal politics and accessibility to good health care.
I can find all of that where I am. I’m in a high cost of living area but I’ve been here my entire life and have owned the same home since I was 29. My living expenses are much less than someone moving here from a low-cost of living state. I’ve also saved based on wages paid in my state that might be higher than someone who has worked for years in a low wage area.
I could take my home equity, sell my home and move to a lower cost of living area and live off my gains. I know many who have done that.
The criteria is listed. The top rated cities for heath care were Sioux Falls, South Burlington, Missoula, Fargo, and Rapid City – small cities often in the Dakotas/Montana area. The criteria is below. It seems to emphasize number of doctors/dentists/nurses/therapists/health facilities… per 10,000 residents more so than the quality of healthcare or depth of specialists.
Health Care – Total Points: 25
Family Medicine Physicians per 10,000 Residents: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Gerontologists per 10,000 Residents Aged 65 & Older: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Dentists per 10,000 Residents: Half Weight (~0.93 Points)
Nurses per 1,000 Residents: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Physical Therapists per 10,000 Residents: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Number of Substance Abuse, Behavioral Disorder, and Mental Health Counselors per 10,000 Residents: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Suicide Rate for Elders: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Health Care Facilities per Capita**: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Quality of Public Hospital System**: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Note: This metric is based on the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ ranking of public hospital systems.
Top-Rated Geriatrics Hospitals: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Share of Population Aged 65 & Older with a Disability: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Home-Care Facilities per Capita: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Life Expectancy: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
Death Rate of Population Aged 65 & Older: Full Weight (~1.85 Points)
I think we have excellent healthcare providers where we are, but we definitely need more. Our population growth is accelerating at a faster rate than our ability to draw more MDs to the area. Someone told me it was several months before they could get in to see a neurologist.
I live in the Pacific Northwest - I read that piece and my personal thought was someone would have to pay me so much money to live in the majority of the places they listed!
I hear you on the pay me to live in Wyoming! I live in a beautiful area with lots of opportunities for outdoor activities and several continuing care communities. The cost of real estate would be low if you were moving from a higher cost of living area. I don’t want to hike, fish or play bingo - all popular where I live. Sure, these care communities are in the area, but the waiting lists are lengthy. Real estate? The median costs are low but so is the inventory. The picture doesn’t match the reality.
I have asked Claude to compare a few different locations and that has been helpful when targeting locations based on my criteria. I can even tell him what I don’t want in a community. I am reluctant to include information re: my political views as one never knows how our information is going to be used in the future.
Google/Gemini. I just asked about percentage of Tampa/St. Pete and Miami would be underwater in 2050. With Orlando I asked about the effects of climate change by 2050 and similarly with Scottsdale. If you want more depth, you can instruct Gemini to do Deep Research (by clicking on the + and then selecting Deep Research). I did not do that, but it is very useful.
About health care, I just went to wallethub to understand the criteria, which @Data10 later added to this thread. They are evaluating availability of providers, which is important, but not quality, which is also important. They are also not evaluating the quality of the dominant insurers in the region. Some insurers have a basic strategy of denying claims and making subscribers jump through hoops to get approval for work that is clearly covered (though they deny it over and over again). Others actually pay for the things they say that they will cover. I have seen both. When my dad was seriously ill and then dying, I had to hire someone to deal with rejections by insurers (and manage claims generally). I never have that problem with our current insurer nor with the previous one. (We switched because the first one did not cover something that my son was going to have to deal with and the current one does). Some parts of the US have mostly the former. Where we are, the latter seems to predominate as far as I can tell.
The criteria is listed. The top rated cities for heath care were Sioux Falls, South Burlington, Missoula, Fargo, and Rapid City – small cities often in the Dakotas/Montana area
[/quote]
I was really trying not to comment on this. I certainly understand that there has to be some criteria and some reasoning for this.
But I really wonder that the healthcare in the Dakota’s and Montana is going to be better than in an urban area of the Detroit metro area?
I have my doubts. Just trying to get my head around physician recruitment and retention.
And who is going to retire there voluntarily? One of my kids looked at a job in MT. They love the outdoors. But the cost of living and access to an airport were disqualifying factors. This was a high paying job. I also have my doubts that they were going to love the very long winters.
@deb922 I also have my doubts about healthcare in the Dakotas.
When H was hospitalized here last year, I met people who lived in the Dakotas who were at that hospital in the Twin Cities because they could not get the level Of care needed where they lived.
one of the things that these surveys gloss over is the availability of health care to new (medicare) patients.
For example, a good friend just moved to Colorado and has a new issue with significant pain, and which needs a rheumatologist per the new internist. 6+ month wait for an appt at Univ of Colorado med center. She contacted Mayo (Rochester) with the though of flying in and spending several days for a complete workup. Was told, ‘sorry, our Rheumatologist is not accepting new patients.’ My orthopod, an excellent sports med guy, is no longer accepting new Medicare patients – just allowing patients who have aged into Medicare.
FYI, advantage plans can have lower reimbursement than supplements which is why you are seeing a move away from advantage plans to major cancer centers
It’s very unfortunate and something to think about if we think about moving near one of our kids.
My mom had pretty good luck with the Cleveland Clinic if your friend wants to try another option
Reading through the comments lately has got me thinking. If you eliminate all the places you won’t live it might make the decision easier.
I used to think I could live in small-town america and now there is no possible way I could do that. I also don’t want snow. I don’t want to live in FL. We won’t be super rich at retirement so that knocks out CA.
I am also a person that only goes to a doctor when I really really need to healthcare situation is not hugely important. I know that could change on a dime, but I just don’t want that item to dictate where I will live.
Very interesting thought and makes complete sense. A higher number of physicians per capita is a good thing, but getting a specialist to see you if you are new to his practice and on Medicare may be much tougher than seeing the specialist where you already are. I have the sense that where we are, the specialists will see you as a favor to your specific doctor. A couple of years before my back surgery, I saw a surgeon who was the head of one of his hospital’s practices. He suggested getting steroids epidurally injected to see if and how long that made a difference. If it lasted three or four months, it might have been the solution to my problem (alas, it didn’t). If it worked for a while, it would be a good diagnostic tool to figure out which vertebra might need fusions. He recommended one particular pain management doctor who he thought was the best person in the Boston area (don’t know why but other folks have very high regard for him). I called and the first appointment I could get was six months later. Then the specialist’s office said that the surgeon’s office had called and they were going to schedule the injection three days later. But, to benefit from that, you probably need to be plugged in to one of the docs who other specialists want to be nice to. That is true of some concierge docs but probably not all.