For me the main effect would be ruling out all of the places ShawWife won’t live. That means we aren’t moving and we probably aren’t even buying a place somewhere warm for the winter.
Not all parts of Ca are expensive. The further away from the coast housing prices go down. Also all of Montana isn’t inexpensive. My friend considered moving and realized all the spots she liked in Montana were as much as her place in a higher cost state.
One factor I’m seeing with my in-laws is that while they have a small hospital with a good emergency department the area lacks many specialty doctors. For many doctors and procedures they need to drive to a larger city 45 minutes away. This was no issue until the last few years.
The health care metric focuses on density of health care providers per capita, rather than quality of health care or depth of specialists. I suspect that Dakotas, Montana, and similar do well on the density per capita metric due to a regional hub effect.
For example, the highest population cities in South Dakota are below. There is Sioux Falls on east, Rapid City on west, and nothing else with 30k people in the state. According to SD dept of health ~60% of SD population lives in rural areas. Rather than locating in rural areas like the majority of state population, health providers often locate in one of the two 80k+ population cities and let the majority of SD population who lives in more rural areas travel to them. The result is these two 80k+ cities look like they have a high number of providers per capita when you compare to the population of the city, but not as high when you compare to the population of the larger area that they serve. This contributes to both locations being among the top 5 highest ranked health care locations on the Wallet Hub list.
Quality of health care is something else. I wouldn’t assume these locations are going to have a higher quality health care than other locations. Lists that emphasize quality of health care usually rank certain bigger cities as highest, rather than any of the 5 locations noted in the WH survey.
great idea, thanks
I am using only anecdotal information here. We moved to MA a few years ago, some of the best health care in the world, several world class hospitals for every type of health issue. However, you have to wait a year to get a PCP, due to the extreme shortage of PCPs accepting new patients.
Again anecdotal, my friend had a rare blood cancer. He received what I consider suboptimal care in the Phoenix area. I feel confident that had he lived in MA and used Dana Farber, his care would have been better.
So does MA get a high or low rating on health care for retirement?
When I was pregnant I was healthy up until the day I wasn’t, when I rapidly developed pre-eclampsia and HELLP syndrome (hemolysis, elevated liver enzymes, low platelets). Without identification and treatment immediately the maternal mortality rate of HELLP syndrome is around 25%. And infant death of mothers with HELLP syndrome ranges from 8-60%.
Those are jaw dropping numbers, and the rapid progression of HELLP, as well as other hypertensive disorders in pregnancy such as pre-eclampsia, are caught only through receiving regular and thorough healthcare throughout pregnancy by knowledgeable providers who have the ability to treat the emergency that it is.
When treatment is delayed by hours, women die. Babies die. There isn’t time to get a patient to a hospital hours away, one that is also understaffed and no longer has a large practice of OBGYNs.
So adding to your key points about where those doctors are located when stats are “per capita,” when there is also particular types of legislation passed in some states, and the result is OB-GYNs are pushed to leave those states as they are blocked from providing healthcare (and prosecuted)—it doesn’t matter in those states if there are 1,000 primary doctors, because without OB-GYNs half the population is shut out from receiving essential healthcare throughout their lives, along with critical prenatal and maternal care.
My very, very good plastic surgeon (cancer) moved to Sioux Falls, SD to open a new practice when he left the military.
it seems they really needed another doc and perhaps the hospital made him an exceptional offer to get him there to build a practice.
His colleagues have said he’s doing well there.
I thought about flying to him for follow-up treatments!
I think anyone looking to live permanently someplace other than their current city or region does need to dig carefully on all the pros and cons, and in a period close in time (maybe 1 - 2 years) prior to making major changes towards a move - and ‘making sure’ just before selling/moving. It seems things keep coming up with changes outside of one’s control - and depending how big those changes are that would impact one’s QOL or finances in new location.
We will be moving from needing 2 legs on many airline flights to potentially a lot more direct flights.
We already know we can keep our Medicare B supplement with the move to new state (Blue Cross Blue Shield) and will just pick up whatever Plan D has for new area. We currently use Walgreen pharmacy but can go to CVS or other pharmacy that are ‘heavy hitters’ in new area and what is most convenient. The trick is getting new PCP as over age 65 (a MD or group accepting new patients) - typically the specialists are not a problem.
Changes one has from go-go years to slow-go years – is the new location still a good fit?
Also how good is it with immediacy of care when you most need it - if you have a stroke or a heart attack, how quick to get to the right care. I have a friend that delivered her daughter’s baby in greater Atlanta area because they would not get to the hospital in time; the ambulance got to her home after successful delivery at home (my friend is amazing and was calm in the situation).
DH’s first cousin has a daughter living in an area in TX, and these parents decided with a number of factors to purchase a home in a 50+ community not far from this daughter, while keeping their large motorhome - because of the trips they would do with the motorhome while also having the activities in their community. I think they are happy for all the planning they did and their finances working out well. They had both grown up in the Madison WI city, and later in career the fellow needed to move to Atlanta area for his work and finish out his career. They purchased a home that worked well, and they could sell it quickly and make some money as well. They had to move themselves from WI to GA which kind of sucked, but it is what it is. They also had made very good money on the sale of their WI home, and paying less taxes in GA and now in TX.
I like the comparison of this ranking to the various college rankings. How much did any of these rankings affect your student(s) - a lot of information to ‘dig through’ when you have no familiarity of stuff beyond what is provided on by literature. We all have certainly known families that had their student go to a particular college, and they realized after the fact that it was not a good place for that student (either to be successful or it was more expensive or had other problems on the student attending there). Similarly with retirees.
To answer on what @anxiousmom posted, Agree about the considerations you noted.
We already know where our DD with children live - after living just 100 miles from us, they relocated summer 2023, had their 5th child, and now they have permanence with their location. They are not homeowners yet, but their rental home works well for their family. We will be giving up a nicer climate, and essentially restarting in many ways in their city – but we have friends and some family in their state and DH and I have also lived there for a few years (and I received a graduate degree in the largest college program in their state as did SIL, son-in-law).
I am slowly making my home ‘check list’ on purchasing there. When we visit over Christmas, will put my head together with DD on general locations for home ownership.
A lot can change between now and Spring - Fall 2028 (and maybe we even put it off another year from there). If there is a real scarcity of homes to sell in our current home’s price range (it is already in pretty strong demand, plus our home’s location), that will get us putting our energies towards pack up and move. DH has activities in our current location that can’t be duplicated in the new location - but he knows we need to be where our grandchildren are, as well as with our aging to have DD’s guidance (in addition to mine). DH has a lot of familial longevity and I do not. My dad died at age 64 (of cancer) and my mom died at 77 (of dementia, but she was on very strong meds for about 20 years for bipolar and just believing in medications for her psych needs). I survived aggressive cancer at age 53, but who knows what the future holds.
I know some guys (and maybe some gals) really love to regularly fish in their area - we have great bass fishing areas and we have neighbors that have fishing boats and go out often weekly while working, and more frequently when retired. Others might do fishing with a vacation, be it deep sea or something specialized like Muskie fishing. DH and his brother have done Muskie a few times, including this year and DH actually caught a good sized one (a few feet long) which isn’t super big for Muskie from what I am told (catch and release).
The home we built is on a bit of a hill - so we know it will never flood. We just have to see what is available and a best match. Have to look at good water run-off and drainage in the occasional heavy rain episodes in new city.
Agree. Though I’d probably want to rule out places that are likely to be underwater (or have big areas underwater) or uninhabitable because of heat within my lifetime.
We love Madison, and would consider retiring there if not so far from family. It is often on numerous “best” lists- or has a good marketing team.
Living outside of Madison ‘proper’ is where I have a niece and nephew - affordable and young families, and my sister’s newest place is Middleton (just outside of Madison). My hometown county is the next county (Madison is in Dane, my county was Green). There are people that commute into Madison from the general area. Some winters (typically January until spring) can be tough with the wait for spring. My sister schedules a sunny vacation spot during that stretch.
I don’t share articles I read but I’d love to hear opinions about how to spend or save an inheritance
Dear Quentin,
My husband and I have been married for 30 years, with four grown kids. He’s planning to retire in 18 months. I’ve been working part time since 2004, when I cut back to raise the kids and then look after my dad.
My mother-in-law died in April and left him $500,000, mostly from selling her small house in Scranton. She clipped coupons until she was 88, so the money meant a lot to him. I sat with her during her final two weeks, and I don’t think he’s forgotten that.
I thought we could finally do a few things we’ve put off. Our kitchen dates from 1999 and the oven only works if you hit the door a certain way. Between them, our cars have a combined 310,000 miles. And I’ve wanted to see Italy since I was 19.
“I proposed spending $130,000 ($45,000 for the kitchen, $70,000 for two cars, $15,000 for the trip) and investing the remaining $370,000. He said no. He wants nearly all of it invested and untouched, “for security,” and nothing decided until we meet our adviser in January.
When I said we’ve shared everything for 30 years, he said: “I’m not saying that’s changed. I’m saying this money is mine to decide about.” There’s another complication: Last year, I gave my sister $25,000 from our joint savings when her divorce was about to cost her the house. ”
“I told him afterward. He was hurt, and he still brings it up every time I mention the inheritance. He says I made a big decision alone and now I’m expecting him to go along with another one. I’ll admit that’s partly fair. But my sister was in a crisis.
It feels like he’s quietly building a separate life with this money after three decades of “ours.” I keep wondering if he’d feel the same if the money had come from my family. I don’t want to force him to spend a dime he’s uncomfortable spending.
Is he entitled to keep it separate just because it came from his mother? ”
A couple of things. First of all, she sounds like someone is used to getting her own way. Giving a large amount of money to your sibling and then telling your spouse sounds insane. I told my husband I can buy a pair of shoes without permission but give my sibling $25,000?
Since many of us seem to be dealing with our parent’s mortality, how do you feel about inheritance and sharing? What to do with an inheritance?
My mom passed away this year and I received a modest amount. My H and I discussed what to do, made a joint decision. We gave some to the kids, put the rest in savings.
We are doing some remodeling but that was on the board and planned for this year before I received any inheritance.
Although I think this might be more about the giving of money to the sibling.
I think it’s reasonable to not want to spend because it may be able to be invested in a way to help make all the wife’s desired purchases. So waiting to see the FA is fair.
And obviously the wife stepped in it with her sister - not in helping but rather in not discussing.
Ultimately his mom is leaving to him - not her. I get, you are married - it’s shared - at least in my house but others keep their money separate.
I think it’s fair to have a discussion but I lean on the hubby is right in exercising caution. That doesn’t mean, the money can’t be invested to spawn off income that he might be willing to spend.
Like everything - every household is different. And I don’t think one person’s (a stranger’s) opinion necessarily applies to this situation.
But hopefully they communicate regularly and honestly although the Mrs clearly doesn’t when it suits her.
In my case, this money would go into a joint account. I don’t have another but this couple may be set up differently.
When my mother died, I inherited everything she had. It was a good amount (2003). The money was used for things for our kids mostly. But we did get a new mattress (which we really needed…and we went high end), a new couch for our family room (old one was pretty sad), and went on a family vacation just one time.
I hope the financial planner tells this husband what ours told us…he told us to spend more. I wanted to get our master bath redone, and the financial planner said to do it.
I think it’s reasonable to discuss this all with the CFP, but in the end, I hope this couple can come to an agreement to do some nice things now for themselves with a part of this money, and invest the rest.
You can’t take it with you! And it would be nice to have the home updated!
ETA…two of my sisters and I have bailed out the fourth sister a few times. We even bought her a new stove when her old one died. None of us asked our husbands first. But we were all working at the time.
Inheritances aren’t automatically shared property between spouses. If the husband keeps his inheritance separate (doesn’t touch or go through joint accounts) it remains his sole property.
I think the wife needs to accept that her husband can do anything he’d like with the money his mother left him. If his mother had wanted to leave her daughter-in-law money - she would have written that into a will.
Choosing not to spend inherited money immediately seems like prudent planning. Whenever we’ve received a windfall - we’ve waited at least 6 months before spending/investing it.
It also sounds like the projects/spending wife wants to do should come from ordinary savings. Why haven’t they been saving up for new cars if that is something they’ve both agreed would be needed? Why did wife decide to give her sister $25k without a conversation? That’s the trip to Italy plus some.
I’m definitely in the husband’s camp. He hasn’t said absolutely no to all of those requests. He wants to pause until talking to his financial advisor first. Sounds smart. The guy’s mom just died and she said the $$$ meant a lot of him. Let him enjoy having it there for security for a little bit before pulling it away.
They also don’t say how much they had before the inheritance. What if that $25k was half their savings? I could easily see that and it would be a huge betrayal without talking about it first.
We share everything, but if my H inherited something.. I should first back up and say that I do 100% of the financial stuff. He has no clue and doesn’t want to have a clue, so he would rely on me to give advice. I’m definitely more the saver. But that being said, I would consider it to be mostly his and want to make sure he could spend at least part of it on something just for him. I would let him take the lead, though I would push to save some for our retirement since we still need help in that department.
I want to say that when each of us got an inheritance from a deceased parent, the decisions of what to do with the money were made jointly with the opinions of the person whose parent had died carrying more weight. We were in different places during these times, however. When my mom died we were in better shape financially so we made different decisions, including giving some of the money to our sons.
The wife really stepped in it with not telling her dh about the $25k gift to the sister until after the fact. I don’t blame him for wanting to keep more control of the money as the dw has shown herself to be a bit deceitful. Nothing wrong with waiting until January and the meeting with the FA. The dh might decide what the wife wants is a good way to spend some of the money.
I may be reading between the lines, however…
My mother-in-law died in April and left him $500,000, mostly from selling her small house in Scranton. She clipped coupons until she was 88, so the money meant a lot to him. I sat with her during her final two weeks, and I don’t think he’s forgotten that.
She wouldn’t bring this up if she didn’t believe it to be a justification for spending this money right now. Her husband just lost his mother, he’s grieving, and she’s reminding him that she spent time with his dying mother—therefore she deserves to be paid out…?
I hope she didn’t say this to his face. That would really hurt to hear.
I thought we could finally do a few things we’ve put off. Our kitchen dates from 1999 and the oven only works if you hit the door a certain way. Between them, our cars have a combined 310,000 miles. And I’ve wanted to see Italy since I was 19.
“I proposed spending $130,000 ($45,000 for the kitchen, $70,000 for two cars, $15,000 for the trip) and investing the remaining $370,000. He said no. He wants nearly all of it invested and untouched, “for security,” and nothing decided until we meet our adviser in January.
He just lost his mother and she wants to start spending this money as soon as it hits their bank account instead of waiting a few months and to consult with their financial advisor. Are you kidding? He just lost his mother and she is badgering him to start spending her money. Has she even considered that her husband is grieving? That he may not feel like jetting off to Italy?
When I said we’ve shared everything for 30 years, he said: “I’m not saying that’s changed. I’m saying this money is mine to decide about.” There’s another complication: Last year, I gave my sister $25,000 from our joint savings when her divorce was about to cost her the house. ”
“I told him afterward. He was hurt, and he still brings it up every time I mention the inheritance. He says I made a big decision alone and now I’m expecting him to go along with another one. I’ll admit that’s partly fair. BUT my sister was in a crisis.
Backing up to her shopping list and the amounts she wants to spend: $70k for two cars. This is where I’m reading between the lines. She’s talking about a couple of Honda Civics at $35k apiece. And for this couple that is a significant amount, because they’ve been driving their current cars for 150k+ miles, and they haven’t bought new ones, and the ones they would be buying would next only be about $35k. Not $65-$95k cars. But modest Honda Civics. (And good for them! This is not a knock on their car decisions; it is me reading between the lines on what their financial situation may look like.)
So when she took $25k out of their joint savings…? That wasn’t a modest amount for this couple. This was a LOT of their money. And she still believes her actions were justified!
I think the husband is being beyond fair. He’s not saying no to anything, he’s saying “let’s wait, and talk it over with our financial advisor.”
She’s out of line.
