This discussion is very interesting about sharing decisions about money. When we did our estate planning, it created several of these very discussions. It forces you to think about what is his, what is hers, and where the kids’ inheritance fits in. It got some issues out on the table.
Pretty good analysis - she seems to be a spender and he is more conservative. I suspect she wanted to wait until a better time (with her husband) to discuss her sister’s need and what a crisis situation it was - but it was wrong to not discuss with him before she helped her sister with the $25K. It also sounds like she might actually need to get a job (if she is able to get something decent) to get more of the things she is wanting – and also put all in perspective. “I’ve wanted to go to Italy since I was 19” - maybe that is really down the list, especially with some more immediate things that should have been saved for (like car replacement planning). She might be good handling the money and household - but if she was in the work force, it could put her in better perspective with it all - it seems he is the one concerned about having enough funds for retirement. Many in the US don’t have enough funds for retirement.
Sometimes one spouse (the frugal one) can have some weird ideas about some things ‘lasting forever’. Also, a spouse can have justified feelings that spill over from one area to another. For example, DH insisted that we do not get a SUV when we needed a new family vehicle, and with that limitation I got a large sedan for the family (5-year, 0% financing which allowed me to get a very good one new that would hopefully last), which then was ‘my car’ - driving the kids to school, family trips. He had a pickup truck that was his. The year I received some funds from inheritance (a 5 unit apartment was sold and cash came to my four sibling and me), we took advantage of ‘cash to clunkers’ and got rid of his 18 YO truck and got a new Toyota Highlander using cash from my inheritance. DH immediately used that for his work vehicle, and it also became our family travel vehicle (I said nothing because nothing to say in his mind). We kept the sedan for 18 years - just out of warranty we had a system of things fail, so we did get out money’s worth out of it including those repairs. We got a second Highlander, used from CarMax, as we had the teenage drivers, and one off to college needed a vehicle. I went back to work with a ‘sunset career’, and driving the sedan to work - I could see the electronics was going and I immediately needed to get it replaced. I had the experience with CarMax to look up a vehicle quickly, and used my earnings to get a used Highlander from there, selected the next day and got brought in within the next few days from a regional lot – it actually was one that had the ‘technology package’ - added bells and whistles, panorama sunroof, two tone leather interior, front seats heat and cool, all-wheel drive, etc. - it had been an executive leased vehicle for 3 years and was in like new condition with just the miles on it. Sometimes DH has critical comments that I just have to ignore “why do you need AWD…” - yet it absolutely came in handy when he decided to go walk on an icy day against my pleading (with cars in the ditches who didn’t need to be out on the road) and had to call me to come and get him because he fell and broke his leg…I drove past 4 cars in the ditch on the road outside of our neighborhood to get him.
Examples of more minor things (believe it or not, a toaster that he thought should last forever) - I bought a nice Oster one that has the long slots and lots of features. DH fussed so much that I gave the toaster to DD1 who needed a toaster. When DH got frustrated enough with our old toaster (it was one that had the automatic drop down, but you had to jiggle and jiggle it, practically beg it to work and he then came to the conclusion that it needed to be replaced), I got the same Oster toaster (2nd one I purchased) for us. Several years later, both at our daughters’ home and at our home, he now praises that toaster, completely forgetting the grief he gave me.
Prior to the toaster incidences, our coffee maker stopped working - so I replaced it; he fussed about replacing it, but it stopped working! I chalk some of it on his work stress.
Hopefully in every household, one is very good on retirement investments. I have been the one with that.
I heard something recently “perfect marriage - imperfect man and imperfect wife…” each living with the other’s imperfections.
In the response, it was stated that the couple had $2.1M in retirement savings
It was difficult to post the response here as I saw this on my Apple News feed.
It’s an interesting discussion. The response agreed with others are saying.
My H is much more of a saver than I am. But when we do spend money, he’s one to go with quality, make sure it’s going to last.
We have a similar situation as the couple except that we are already retired. Older cars, an original kitchen, a wife who wants to travel some. The difference being that my mil is still with us, no inheritance to speak of yet.
We did the travel, we are currently doing the remodeling. We are driving the older cars for now.
To me what the wife did giving their money to her sister was irresponsible not to communicate to her H. I suspect that she did so because she knew what his reaction would be. Better to beg forgiveness than ask permission.
It’s “their” money - but many of us had to help parents and things like that. We were newly married and both my wife’s parents died a few years after we married. We helped them and would continue to.
But this is where investing for income rather than spending principal comes in - and it will last longer.
It’s likely the family can generate enough income to pay for what was mentioned (over a few years) rather than spend down the principal and it’s gone.
And I suspect that’s what a FA would tell them.
It is a bad idea to make any kind of financial decision without involving your spouse. My husband agreed to a financial arrangement with his siblings and parent that significantly disadvantaged us - never discussed with me. It put us in a huge hole when paying for college as we suddenly went from eligibility for a lot of aid to full pay. Still the source of a lot of bitter feelings for me.
When my mother died, I inherited substantial assets, including a home which is still in my name only. I’m the one making the decisions about the assets. As far as I’m concerned, H lost his right to opine on how to use my inheritance when he decided to “help” his family without talking with me.
My friend’s mother often was not able to get important things (for her and her DDs) past her DH - at that time, some thought of braces as a luxury for example. She inherited some money, and so she was able to use that for these expenditures. When they had an empty nest, she found a nearby job that was fun for her and gave her spending money.
As I’ve frequently shared, both of my parents died when I was 24 years old. I am an only child. I was engaged to dh when this traumatic event happened. Whether their estate would be considered, “substantial,” or not could be debated. It was certainly a substantial amount for a young couple both in their first post-college jobs. The very last thing the attorney representing the estate said to me as things were wrapped up was, “Hoggirl, Hogboy is a wonderful man, and I have no doubt you will have a long and happy marriage. However, in this state inherited assets are not marital assets, and my advice is to keep these resources solely in your name.” Other than commingling some of that money into our jointly held first large home, that is what I have done. I shared what the attorney had said to me, and my then fiancé/now dh had no issue with it.
Interestingly, dh’s paternal grandparents, though not wealthy AT ALL, set up a generation-skipping transfer trust. When they both had passed, that money was in a trust for my fil’s lifetime benefit with the remainder to be split between dh and his sister. Fil was the trustee and could have spent all of it. It had no restrictions. He used some for travel with mil. When fil died, he had spent down around 25% of it. The remainder went straight to dh and his sister. The grandparents’ clear intent in creating that GST trust was to keep their money out of mil’s hands. (Of course fil could have spent all of it for her benefit). It seemed sort of harsh to me at the time because mil and fil had been married over 25 years when they created the trust. Sure doesn’t seem that way now that mil has remarried Bob!
Assuming mil doesn’t change her will or use up all her money subsidizing her second husband, whatever she owns will be split between dh and his sister. I have no expectation that I should have any say with what he should do with any inheritance he receives.
We have yours, mine, and ours in our household. It’s what works for us. YMMV
It sounds like you have done well thoughtfully moving forward with handling the inheritance from your parents at an unexpected and shocking time. How crushing to lose your parents at such a young age. Virtual hug. My dad died 16 years after DH and I married, but we lost him too soon - dad was 64 and DH and I were 39 at the time of his death. Mom lived another 15 years as a widow. DH’s parents lived 11 years beyond my mother, and they both died at age 92.
I can still remember when my DW and I were just married we had a discussion about what amount of money could be spent without consulting each other. This was 30+ years ago and the amount was $75. That is what we agreed to. Of course over time the amount has increased but we have never had a formal discussion about a new number. It set the tone for our marriage that we are in this together.
My Mom passed 2 years ago. I got an inheritance. Not life changing. We sat down and talked through what we wanted to do with the funds. We made a list. It was a list like we used to make early on for big purchases. We would save up funds and purchase the item and mark it off the list and then start saving for the next item. What I have liked most in the last two years is we have been able to cashflow some of the items on the list. Meaning we haven’t had to use the inheritance for some of the items.
I will say it would seem like $25K would be way too much to spend or give away without a full discussion.
We have never had a discussion about the amount, but we have always agreed that we are in this together and neither of us would give $25K to anything without discussing it with the other (with the exception of my putting it into investments). Other than charitable contributions, I think we would be discussing most purchases at a $1K threshhold or less. On charitable contributions, ShawWife will sometimes tell me that she’d like us to make a charitable contribution to some cause for a $2K and I would not object. I have made a contribution to my alma mater almost every year and I don’t believe I’ve discussed that with her. For the most part, we have a budget each year of charitable contributions and the contributions to my alma mater and whatever charity she has in mind fit in that budget.
I funded a scholarship in honor of my father at his alma mater for promising students in his field who (like him) had financial need. I discussed this with ShawWife as this amount was considerably larger. Similarly, I imagine that we will make a sizeable donation to a museum or university that agrees to act as a steward for ShawWife’s work.
Giving the sister $25,000 without a discussion would not happen in my household. Anything of that amount would be discussed. I once loaned my sister $1000 so she could consult a lawyer without her husband knowing. She paid me back several years later. She ended up taking another 10 years to go through with the divorce. She had to use credit cards to pay her attorney but I was glad she didn’t ask me for a loan.
I got a small inheritance from my mom. We considered that my money. I used it for some spending on kid activities. My spouse will inherit from his parents and that will be his separate property that will go to our children one day. We live nicely without the money.
Ironically giving or loaning money came up today. One of mine wants to buy a pony. She asked me for a loan. I said she was talking to the wrong parent. She knows I wouldn’t do it without her dad knowing but was hoping.
Have you done a deep dive on re-allocating the assets in your retirement account?
I’m the “big cash reserve” part of our marriage. Spouse is the “make every dollar work hard” part of the marriage. We found that some rebalancing of the core assets has satisfied both of us-- and therefore I no longer freak out when we have to sell something for a distribution, and he no longer gets angry when the money market (still interest earning although liquid) is a little over his comfort zone.
A side benefit- it’s an annual conversation not a monthly one!! so a once a year look-over vs. “hey, it’s the 28th of the month” reminder!
I’m not sure about how re-allocating the assets would help, we’d still have to pay taxes in a higher bracket. We have plenty of money market funds in the retirement accounts, so it’s not a matter of what we have to sell, it’s the taxes. We leave the money in there until we need it, as we may as well get some return on it, though it would feel better if we had saved a lot of money in non-retirement accounts. I think that’s the issue that this article was addressing, the non-liquidity of assets making people feel uncomfortable.
I have rebranded my retirement assets as my “tax deferred nest egg” so it no longer bothers me to pay taxes on the money. I earned it, I invested it where it grew tax free, and now that I need it, the taxes are due. Just a little reminder to myself not to get agitated…
Real estate is not accessible but your 401(K) accounts are liquid. You saved there tax free to fund your retirement. Now it will be used for that purpose and you pay taxes as you withdraw.
The whole reason for having these savings is because your pensions don’t cover your expenses and you didn’t expect them to.
Note the clock is ticking on these accounts anyway, they will be part of your RMD when you reach a certain age.
Had these monies been invested over the years in non-retirement accounts, you would have been paying more taxes over those years.
I’ll admit to having some stress before we started SS. We had plenty of assets, but doing Roth rollovers (that really were a good idea) ate into our other assets to pay the taxes. Having a FA to help us with our plans was quite helpfu. Now that we have SS, cash flow is good. But we are still benefitting from quarterly FA coaching as we start some justifiable IRA splurge spending.
Our thoughts about our 401Ks and IRAs are exactly like you. We were able to save and invest for 40 years tax free and now with H retired we will make withdrawls and pay the taxes on that money.
I try to keep my IRA withdrawals below the IRMAA limit.
Will be easy to do right now. Might be harder when we have to do RMD’s
The hardest part will be when there is only one of us.
Same here. It’s a balancing act but so far, we have been able to do this even with DHs significant RMD. I have RMD also, but I’m drawing on one account already, and the other, I make my charitable donations from which helps.
And agree, our CFP has been terrific about crunching the numbers for us.
Yes.
We met a couple of weeks ago with our new Vanguard FA. He asked a couple of things our previous one never did, specifically about passive vs active investing. I chose to get out of all active investing as I already have a higher stock allocation and figure that adds enough risk. Plus I didn’t want to pay the higher fees.
I did keep my domestic/intl allocation roughly the same.
Our brokerage account is in a HYSA. We keep our emergency funds (minimal as so much of our income is fixed) in there as well as what we will need for home renos and property taxes in the next year or two.
I started my SS earlier than I had planned (this year, at 63.5). When I ran opensocialsecurity and my Monte Carlo analysis, they both said take it now. In retrospect, I realize that the reason my MC went up likely is that taking SS (fixed income) introduces stability to my portfolio and the stability is what made my chance of success increase. Regardless, I’m really glad that I started it as it’s nice to not worry about touching my retirement funds.
We continue to do Roth conversions, trying to stay in the 12% bracket. Paying the taxes on that also comes out of the brokerage account. I hate seeing that balance shrink, but I know that it’s smart in the long run.