How Much Do You think You Need to Retire? What Age Will You/Spouse Retire? Investment and General Retirement Issues (Part 3)

DW and I are the same age. We recently got info from her pension that might allow us to retire 1-3 earlier than planned. Then I started running scenarios of taking SS early instead of at 67.

I am still early in running those but I like the idea of taking less out of the IRA early in case the market takes a dump.

It is crazy the pension changed by $1500-2000 more a month than earlier estimates. DW has a very complicated pension because it is really two separate pensions in the education world.

4 Likes

That sounds nice news for pensions :wink: In your SS scenarios, include variations where one of you claims earlier and the other defers (ideally to age 70 / max benefits).

1 Like

When interest rates go down, often pension net present value goes up.

I was offered a buyout by my old employer. The fed lowered 1/4 point and I got 3.7% more than I was offered.

With interest rates going up, it would have had the opposite effect so now values may go down (at least lump sum).

I imagine defined benefit should remain stable though as the benefit is defined.

1 Like

It really has been an interesting journey on this pension for DW. We are both accountants and never really thought one or both of us would be in the pension world. When DW left the accounting from right out of college she went to work for a Spec ED Coop. She stayed there 2.5-3 years. Then moved on. Eventually we had kids and she stayed home for 7 years. As she got back into the workforce she worked PT at a library. Then going full-time. Then she moved over to our HS to do payroll. At some point we bought back those years for the pension. She had taken the little she had and put it in an IRA. The key point in all of this is those early years let her be grandfathered in on the changes that have been made to the pension over the years. She then progressed up to bigger roles and switched schools. It will end up being a significant part of our retirement.

She does qualify for SS as she has enough normal quarters in, but her SS won’t be half of mine so she will take the spouse benefit when we claim. She moved from the support employee pension to the teachers pension about 6 years ago. Luckily both pensions count total years because of reciprocity. This is done because people wouldn’t want to move up into administration if not. School administrators are part of the teachers pension and support staff is a different one. Also being in the teachers pension she doesn’t pay into SS.

If I lost anyone there don’t fret it is definitely an out of the ordinary path. Me on the other hand I am normal corporate employee with no pension or anything. Just been saving in a 401K.

1 Like

One reason I went ahead and took SS is so I could let my pension ride. It’s significantly more if I wait on the pension a few years – double and eventually more than triple! Waiting on SS doesn’t get me that kind of growth. Of course, I could’ve waited on both! But like I said, I like having the cash now and not even considering touching the retirement accounts.

8 Likes

If this is considered political, feel free to delete.
I’m wondering if anyone has an opinion or historical knowledge of how things tend to work out with the stock market when we go from republican to democrats in charge of Congress?
I considered taking my money OUT of the market after the 2024 election, but I stayed in and I’m glad I did. Now I’m wondering if I should move more into something else. (But I’m not sure what that would be).

Historically, you are better to leave it in - no matter the party and especially after bad days (a big drop where people panic).

Here’s some charts - they’re Presidential (dems do better) but this is different.

But if you have Dems passing plans and Trump veto-ing, that’s the gridlock investors traditionally like.

I suspect the market performance is because of a handful of stocks that dominate the S&P, not either President or Congress, etc. but it’s just a guess.

Of course, for many, as you age, you might decide to take your foot off the stock gas.

Interest rates are high and likely going higher. As people can earn more in fixed income, stocks tend to go down or slow down - because if you can get today, say 5% tax free and depending where you live, that can be 7%, 7.5%, even 8% after tax equivalent - and many only target that for a desired return, well people will buy fixed income instead given the mitigation of risk. So that can reduce the demand for stock - hence causing struggle.

In the end, past performance doesn’t assure future results, but unless you are re allocating for age, etc. - historically inaction would make you more money than taking action.

But that’s past - no clue about the future.

Good luck - to us all :slight_smile:

19739_1604955570_en.pdf

4 Likes

Reminder that political discussions are not permitted in this forum. Data/facts are ok but not opinions or conjecture. TIA.

In our earlier years, we were so directed in so many ways. I agree about feeling better with having more money in non-retirement accounts. That is where we are heading with our ‘lower tax years’ before we have the RMD withdrawals and taxes. But we are applying a strategy for the here and now that fits for us, as others on this thread are doing.

It sounds like some have brokerage accounts that are significant to do some additional Roth conversions. We are comfortable with our level of Roths at this point.

Great @gpo613 about your wife’s buy-back within education and being in the better pension timeframe. DD2 and I both had a few years with state/education/retirement fund - but work opportunities were better with other employment. DD2 now has Roth 401k with employer matching; I helped her move her rollover IRA into Roth IRA. She is managing that now, but when she wants me to review her investment choices, I will. Having selected great investment choices in DH’s 401k has been very important to us because neither of us have pensions.

With my ‘sunset career’ I was earning enough on SS to claim my own, and gave us the flexibility for me to take it right at 65 (although it was not at full SS for us, as we were both born in 1956, which meant 66 and 4 months for full SS or 66 and 8 months I don’t remember off the top of my head). DH took his SS before he turned 66, but those extra months was helpful with him having a bigger monthly benefit. I also had 401k and 4% matching, and that was helpful money at my retirement - it was nice to have. My brother that is a year older than me waited to take his SS at age 70 (which happened last year), but he has such a strong financial position that he just looked at the SS as the 8% on the guaranteed gain, and not the opportunity cost of the cash flow in on those years between full SS and age 70 - and those SS funds were helpful for us not to spend down invested funds which we worked hard to accumulate.