How selective of a school can I get into?

Hi everyone,

I just finished my junior year in high school and am furthering my college search. I am very active in my school, as I am a tutor, freshman mentor, and involved in several community service/ leadership clubs as well as a member of the bowling and softball teams since freshman year. I take the most challenging classes (all honors or AP) in my very challenging school, and receive an equal amount of A’s and B’s. My SAT score is a 1450. Knowing the competitiveness of the elite college field, I was wondering what my chances are at a highly selective school, such as Northwestern. My sibling goes there and I also live in state. Other colleges that interest me are Boston University, University of Richmond, Vanderbilt, and Carelton College. If my chances are low, what colleges can I get into based on my grades, SAT score, and extracurriculars?

Thanks so much.

Your SAT score roughly matches Northwestern’s 25th percentile for students admitted last year, and is about 100 points below the 75th percentile. That makes your chances of admission even less than their average reported figure of about 9%. In most cases, a score closer to, or preferably above the 75th percentile would give you a better shot. Search various colleges’ admissions sites for their Common Data Sets, which include additional admissions stats. You could try retaking the SAT. Don’t fall in love with any one school. Talk with your family about how much they can afford to pay. If you’re aiming for merit money, you’ll want to be among the stronger applicants in most cases.

What is your unweighted GPA? That is more important than test scores at most schools.

Why is selectivity your most important criterion? If you are following the most rigorous curriculum possible, have a mixture of A’s and B’s, have a solid SAT score (and you do), and have some nice ECs (plus thoughtful essays, solid letters of rec), you will be just fine. There will be a lot of terrific schools to choose from, and, yes, if you are interested in finding a school with a sub-30% acceptance rate (though why in the world this would be important, I have no idea) that can certainly be in the mix, too.

What are your academic, extracurricular, and career interests? Competitiveness is a consideration but shouldn’t be your first filter.

Implies that unweighted GPA is 3.5.

“and receive an equal amount of A’s and B’s.”

I interpreted this in the same way as @ucbalumnus, implying an unweighted GPA somewhere roughly around 3.5. I think that this is likely to be the biggest issue at the most selective universities such as Northwestern. However, there are plenty of very good universities that you could get into with a 3.5 UW GPA, particularly with a challenging course load.

The first two questions that come to mind that @acarr13 needs to answer before it makes sense to suggest schools: (1) What is your budget? and (2) What state do you live in? You say that you are in-state for Northwestern, which I take to mean that you live in Illinois. The budget however is also something we should know.

Assuming that you are in-state in Illinois, I am thinking that a 3.5 UW GPA and 1450 SAT makes UIUC perhaps a good match. I don’t think that it is quite a safety although I am not from that part of the US and we didn’t seriously consider anything that far west for our kids. We did look at BU moderately closely (including a visit and tour) and to be honest I don’t understand why anyone from Illinois would pay the extra compared to UIUC to attend BU.

Depends on division or major. If the desired major is an engineering major (including CS) or business, UIUC should be considered a reach with a 3.5 GPA.

https://admissions.illinois.edu/Apply/Freshman/profile

@acarr13 I’m originally from Illinois, and I was accepted to UIUC & BU (amongst other schools). With my financial aid package, the cost of BU fell ~8K per year below UIUC. (I ended up attending BU.)