How U.S. News college rankings promote economic inequality on campus

Very interesting analysis by BENJAMIN WERMUND/ Politico.com
Search in google:
How U.S. News college rankings promote economic inequality on campus

Some statements from the article which I wonder about.

http://www.politico.com/interactives/2017/top-college-rankings-list-2017-us-news-investigation/

“a university’s prestige has an inordinate effect on who applies and how easily students are able to get jobs with lucrative employers.”

“More than 40 percent of Harvard’s class of 2021 are legacy students”

To be honest, I didn’t get by that sub-headline…The Evils of US News College Rankings = Trump

This is a very poorly thought out article.

“We are creating a permanent underclass in America based on education.”

True. However, that can’t be fixed at the college level, and it certainly can’t be fixed by US News. By the time students are 18 years old, an average-below average student is many, many years behind the top students. Probably 5 or 6 years behind. More behind than there are college years to learn.

Foolish people with agendas run around telling people that the SAT and elite colleges cause the problem. The reality is that they are just killing the messenger.

SATs, and elite colleges are performing a great service by telling us all that, on average, the best students are disproportionately coming from higher income families and are on average massively ahead of their lower income peers. Then the foolish people want to blame the SAT, blame US News and blame top colleges for the problem. The idea here is that when one group is way behind of another, it is easier to attack the group that is ahead and slow them down, rather than to do the hard work needed to improve the group that is behind.

To effectively deal with this issue we need focus on what needs to be done to prevent average mid-lower income students from getting so far behind to begin with. Students need better education and more education from an early age. Poor students need to have their basic needs met better, they need people who care about them and teach them to have high expectations for themselves, they need to have a better understanding of why school matters and they should care, they need to begin their education at a younger age, and they need a longer school year. There is no magic to it. It is a lot of hard work improving reading, writing and math skills.

Once people realize the amount of effort and money it will take to really close this gap, they seem to decide that it is easier to just blame US News and ignore the real problems entirely.