<p>Perhaps she doesn’t care about politics? What if her intended career has nothing to do with government regulation? Not everyone has an opinion/stance on something. Unless she led you into the topic, why put her in an uncomfortable situation where she had no time to prepare her defense on a topic she may not even be familiar or even have an opinion about?</p>
<p>I love business but I don’t give a rat’s ass about the “morality” of it all and I won’t for my entire career. I felt like my interviewer and I were on entirely different realms of thought the whole time. </p>
<p>Oh well…at least Penn is looking a lot brighter now. Hope everyone has better experiences.</p>
<p>I’d be a bit careful about playing fast and loose about what you just said. Interviewers are not just there to evaluate you academically or intellectually. We’re also supposed to rate your character and/or ‘personal qualities’. I can tell you if you said that to some interviewers, your rating on that end would certainly be compromised, Harvard or Wharton.</p>
<p>@Spiffy: This candidate was very vocal about her politics and economics intentions. That’s why the subject was broached. Then her answers fell flat.</p>
<p>Hopefully, your critical thinking skills were on display, unlike hers. As for your amoral stance on business, I find that unfortunate. </p>
<p>Spiffy
As a Harvard grad and business professor, I have to say that attitude is either 1) immature and temporary or 2) permanent and entirely unappealing. Likely to be ostracized even by ither business students. </p>
<p>A real dealbreaker for me as an interviewer. Really the school doesnt need people like that</p>
<p>I know interview season is over, but I wanted to confirm what many others said regarding the format. My son had an interviewer who while kind and very supportive, also said that of the dozen interviews he has conducted in the past couple of years, none of those he has interviewed got in. The interviewer conveyed this in a lamentable way, not in an arrogant and self-important manner. That did not upset my son in any way, as it was just a reality check that confirmed what he already knew. That said, the substance of the interview was about basic information first–name, rank, serial number data–and then definite questions about major AND current affairs. I would find it hard to imagine anyone who is applying to Harvard is not aware of, at a minimum, basic national and world events and, most importantly, would not care about those sorts of things. Anyway, the interviewer was gracious and very positive about his alma mater, but clearly knows that for anyone it is a long shot. As I said to my son, however, “If you don’t apply, you’ll never know. If you don’t get in, well, you’ve got lots of wonderful options and you can always shoot for graduate school at Harvard.”</p>
<p>I just had an interview with Harvard (it was late but no one else in my region had been contacted for one either). It went very well and conversation flowed so smoothly between my interviewer and me that it didn’t even feel like a real interview. I brought a copy of my resume and we just went over that while we talked about everything from music theory to Neanderthals to Warren Buffet. It was definitely better than I had anticipated (although I doubt it could have substantially helped my application).</p>
<p>my interview was… interesting. an alumni interview, and nothing like any other admissions interview i’ve had. he told me from the get-go that he wanted to understand my “world philosophy” and we then began what was actually a fascinating conversation about the roots of global change. i think i made a few good points, but toward the end he started talking more and more, giving me fewer opportunities to say anything. overall, who knows?
since he deviated so much from the “script”, it seems, i don’t know how useful the report will be to harvard adcoms</p>
How about you get your head out of your ass? Are you that stupid? Stop believing everything you see in movies. Mark Zuckerberg created Facebook because he had a passion for creating websites and software. There was no ex-girlfriend. That was put in ‘The Social Network’ for Hollywood purposes.</p>
<p>I had mine today! It only lasted about 30 minutes, and he only asked me one question(the “tell me about yourself” question)…so I’m kind of worried I blew it. At least he was nice and we laughed a lot throughout.</p>
<p>I haven’t been contacted for an interview yet, does that mean I’m not getting one? (I applied EA). I submitted my application pretty late on November 1, so maybe they haven’t processed mine yet.</p>
<p>@Mythical8: Don’t worry. Getting or not getting an interview on time usually has to do with the regional alum clubs and how on top of their game they are rather than admissions or their impression of your candidacy. Where are you located? It can sometimes be hard to get interviewers in certain parts of the country/world.</p>
<p>I’m really nervous about this interview just because I’ve heard a lot of people in the past say they were asked their opinions and justifications on a lot of tough current issues. Did you guys get these kinds of questions?</p>
<p>also any other kind of help would be appreciated :)</p>
<p>Of Harvard, Princeton and Yale, Harvard’s interviewer was the last to contact my son last year, and I believe it was about a month after he submitted his application, which was November 1. He didn’t apply EA, but just wanted to get all his applications in at once, and out of the way.</p>