<p>@Monepo: most things are fair game to ask you about. Often, the purpose is to see if you have an informed opinion and your rationale and your thoughts on the opposite opinion. It’s OK to say you’re undecided but show why-- rather than it’s not important to you. </p>
<p>I once interviewed a young lady who said she was interested in PoliSci. It was the dawn the mortgage melt down (Spring '09) and things were definitely in flux. I asked her opinion and she gave the oft-heard line about “need to diminish Govt regulation”. I asked her about the prevailing conventional wisdom about the opposite opinion that too little oversight precipitated the then-current crisis. She couldn’t even say much at all about that opposing thought and just parroted her earlier “solution” – which was carved right out of talk-radio. Not that I disagreed w/her stance per se (that’s not why I offered the counter-point to her to discuss) – but that she couldn’t even approach the slightest logic of the opposing viewpoint or even understand it.</p>
<p>I wasn’t impressed – and that encounter formed the bulk of my report narrative.</p>
<p>@Mythical8: I wouldn’t be surprised if sometimes one school is assigned multiple interviewers. I’d love to say that all interviewers are responsible and prompt, but that’s in an ideal world. But beyond bad excuses, sometimes certain interviewers are just really busy; I’m sure you’ll be contacted soon.</p>
<p>Had mine yesterday, lasted about an hour. We talked about 50/50 politics/my academics. It was really fun, and I feel like the point is just to see that you can have an intellectual conversation about whatever your interests are. The best part was the total lack of “gotcha” questions like “what are you bad at” or “what’s your least favorite subject”. I even prepared a long speech for “why harvard,” but it didn’t come up once.</p>
<p>I chose Harvard because of the masterful parody of Yale’s “Why I chose Yale” video. Great reason, hm. Lucky it didn’t come up in a serious context in interview, haha.</p>
<p>I had my interview today. We had a nice conversation; she asked me about my ECs and what I enjoyed doing. It lasted about an hour and I think it went well.</p>
<p>ya i thought that too, i said i appreciated all the information and help. i just used the first name, completely forgot. Ya i think it would be awkward too, i dont know if people take offense, i know i wouldn’t.</p>
<p>Interview went well! He scheduled it for an hour, but it ran an hour-and-a-half! Much better than some of my interviews. This was less question/answer, and more discussion about every topic of interest under the sun: politics, psychology, economics, computer science, music…</p>
<p>Why on earth are Harvard interviewers supposed to ask for stats (like test scores) that would be on the student’s application anyway? Surely the admissions committee has absolutely no need to get this info from the alum interviewer?</p>
<p>Very off-putting. Rather than make these alums seem like the human face of Harvard, this question (which seems much rarer at interviews for peer schools) only serves to reinforce negative stereotypes about Harvard and its grads.</p>
<p>IMO, this is a bit of a blunder, but it is far, far from a big deal.</p>
<p>I have never invited applicants to call me by my first name, although they know it from the first contact I make with them.</p>
<p>Because I am middle-aged and the applicants are 17 or 18, and I haven’t invited them to call me “Igor,” I do expect that they’re going to call me “Mr. Sikorsky.”</p>
<p>But if an applicant did first-name me, it wouldn’t have any effect on my interview report. And I wouldn’t expect an apology from the applicant, either. So, anonymou2, I think you can relax. But if you have more interviews this season, I recommend you wait to be invited to address interviewers by their first names.</p>
<p>I want to send my interviewer a thank-you note, but I’m 99% certain he doesn’t have an email address, at least one that can be found online. He called to arrange the interview - what should I do? I want to thank him, but I feel like sending a note snail-mail might be a little over the top. What do you think?</p>
<p>I had my interview a couple of days ago. It was great but I felt like I was talking to a friend instead of a college interviewer. As an alumni, she didn’t ask me many questions; but I tried to talk about my EC’s and show my passion about them. We laughed a lot and she congratulated me for some of my awards and successes. She also said ‘‘Your English is great’’ which made me happy (because I am an international student (although a US citizen)).
Yet, she seemed to take the interview very lightly; as I said she asked only a few questions (no ‘fav book’, no ‘why Harvard’), she didn’t take any notes but she seemed pretty pleased (or she was simply being nice). It lasted exactly one hour, but I don’t know if it will have any positive effect on my application.</p>
<p>testobsessed (!) wrote: Why on earth are Harvard interviewers supposed to ask for stats (like test scores) that would be on the student’s application anyway? Surely the admissions committee has absolutely no need to get this info from the alum interviewer?</p>
<p>Interviewer here. The two reasons that come to mind are: 1) We get very little information about you – your name, address, telephone number and high school, that’s it. 2) I think it’s a little honesty check. Do you present yourself honestly to the interviewer, even if you are unhappy with your SAT MathII score?</p>
<p>But you know, I don’t think I’ve ever spent more than a minute discussing an applicant’s scores; I ask for them, I note them on my forms, and we move on.</p>
<p>…I was not asked for any transcript or SAT scores. It seems foolish for interviewers to know that information. They are judging us as people, not academics. But, anyhow, my interview went awesome! No academics were really discussed. Just a bit about my EC and then the standard: Why do you want to be accepted? What do you offer? etc.</p>
<p>I found that the reason my interview went so well was because I remained very true to myself. I was never trying to perpetuate a confident student with all the right scores, all the right grades, and relentlessly dedication-indicative EC list. I was very comfortable in revealing that yes, I am nervous as hell. I offer Harvard nothing but myself. I’m only 17…I still don’t know who I am yet. It’s not about what I offer Harvard. Rather, it’s about what Harvard offers me. It offers me an atmosphere advocating experimentation with the alien and unknown. The key is to always convey the true you. So basically, why I want to be accepted and what I offer are all intertwined. And the central theme of discovering oneself is why I enjoyed my interview. I felt that it would be important to emphasize one aspect of me that is indicative to the whole. A perception of me would thus be more likely to stick with my interviewer; who seemed to love me!</p>
<p>Another interviewer here. Unlike some schools that explicitly ask interviewers not to inquire about grades or SAT scores, Harvard leaves the decision to the interviewer. We’re given the option of asking for SAT/ACT and AP scores, as well as GPA and rank (if available). </p>
<p>I don’t think it’s particularly foolish. Your academics ARE part of who you are. Not the entirety, and maybe not even a majority, and it’s certainly a part of it. If you display extraordinary knowledge in a certain area during the interview, but your grades don’t seem to confirm that (or vice versa), it could be a signal for the interview to probe further. And in some cases, might even help the applicant.</p>
<p>@WindCloudUltra I didn’t think of it that way. You’re completely right. My interviewer asked mostly about who I am and my EC’s. I did not bring a CV since it was not requested and the first thing he asked was, “Tell me who you are.” and our conversation went from there. I mentioned academics simply because it seemed logical too but no score or gpa was inquired about with specificity. He also asked me how I manage everything with so much going on. I wasnt sure if that was good or bad. I dont want to seem to thinned out. So i said that in school im a confident, and knowledge-seeking academic, on the field I’m a dedicated and gifted athlete, and on the weekends I’m a normal teenager who hangs out with his friends. Hope I dont sound pretentious. He also liked that I expressed my own views about GPA and rank - personally, I just feel that individuals cannot be judged based upon a number. I’m not a number…I’m a person. I dont go to school to get A’s - I go there to learn and become a more powerful individual. In the end, I do end up getting A’s and have achieved a spot at the top of my class but I’m also very apt to admit that I have failed a test or quiz before. I mean, from an alumni point of view, dont you think it’s a tad insulting to label Harvard admissions as one who only cares about 4.0’s?</p>
<p>I can’t speak for the admissions committee. I don’t think it’s “all about 4.0s,” though. GPA is one piece of the puzzle, test scores are another, but in some ways I suspect they are small pieces. What I mean, and what I think WindCloudUltra alludes to below, is that not all 4.0+ GPAs or 2250 SATs are alike. </p>
<p>Most of the students I interview have SATs that are remarkably similar. The students themselves are a diverse group, and some present as far stronger candidates than others despite similar SAT scores.</p>
<p>My interview lasted for an hour ish and went really well! She was a high school math teacher and I am planning on going cellular biology so you can’t get much different than that… haha but we had plenty to talk about. She took notes like a mad women, I remember about 30 seconds into the interview I said “I like interviews because it makes the application into an actual person” and she whips out her handy dandy notebook saying “I have to write down whenever you say something interesting like that!” Needless to say, she made me feel very wise with all the scribbling.</p>
<p>As far as questions, the first thing she said to me was “This is a conversation. Just talk. Pretend it’s not an interview.” I liked that because our conversation naturally progressed instead of awkwardly stopping when you exhausted a topic and needed another question. The time flew by, and I honestly think I covered everything I could! Of course, you will always regret not saying one little thing but you have to just forget it and trust yourself. I suggest focusing on things that might not have been explained very well in your application, or left something to be desired. Even if the interview does not “count” for much, as some people say, it will still be read in conjunction with your application, so all it does is clarify and add to what you already sent in. She did ask me for my scores, for those wondering about that. She did express some surprise when I said I got a 1600 CR+M so I guess that meant something to her? Haha all I can say is to be relaxed, most likely it is not your interviewer’s first ball game and he/she will be able to get good stuff out of you no matter what. Good luck all!</p>