I could've gone to an ivy, but depression during my sophomore year pretty much stopped me from doing so

This student is still pretty far away from being on campus and needs help sooner than that. With parents who culturally oppose the idea of depression and treatment, and apparently a primary care doctor who agrees with that, and an environment that stresses Ivies, I am wondering what other resources this student can access. In my area, depression screening happens at every appointment.

1 Like

Yes, that really does concern me. My son’s doctor told me it’s scary how many parents resist medication. As shocked as we were by both our sons’ diagnoses, we never resisted the idea of meds. They really are lifesavers. I wish my middle son would try them again, frankly.

3 Likes

I like your screen name. You are a shooting star! :collision: :smiling_face_with_sunglasses:

We had a young woman post here yesterday that she had just been accepted by Cornell. Her gpa was 3.81. There is no magic number. There’s more that goes into it than that.

And there are applicants with 4.0 who get turned away. There are so many factors that go into that decision.

And going to an Ivy doesn’t guarantee anything. I was reading a story last week which included mention of a Brown U alum. He was homeless.

College is the means to an end, so you need to know what the end is that you want. If you know where you want to go in your life, then you can identify the colleges which can best help you get there. They might be Ivies but more than likely they will not.

1 Like

Not to mention OP mentioned big names - but given his desired major, they’re not necessarily big names at all.

I’m looking at various CS rankings - the Brown Open source puts NU at 27 and Rice at 30, behind schools like Maryland, Wisconsin, and UMASS. WUSTL is 54 and Vandy 83, tied with Nebraska. Dartmouth (Ivy) is 58.

CSR rankings.com puts NU at 25 and Rice at 51 but Maryland at 10, Wisconsin at 16 and UMass at 22. Your Ivies - Yale at 37, Brown at 50. Heck WUSTL is 57 and Vandy 65.

If you look at go elite rankings, Wisconsin is 18, Maryland is 20, UMASS is 25. Northwestern is 28, Rice is 32, Johns Hopkins 46, Washu 52, Vandy 61. Dartmouth 74.

So i’m not a fan of rankings, but if OP is going to make a huge thing about real schools and you want to study CS, let them go to their higher echelon US News schools while you may end up at one that will be ranked well ahead of their alleged high echelon schools (I checked 3, US News only ranks 9) - so in general, if that’s going to matter to you, you weren’t looking at the right schools anyway.

2 Likes

Your original post starts out with a false premise, right at the outset. “I could’ve gone to an Ivy, but…” as if straight A’s in 10th grade would have nailed down an Ivy acceptance. It would not. Plenty of kids with straight A’s and high standardized test scores get turned down by Ivy League schools. There are far more straight A students in this country than there are spots in Ivy, or even Ivy+ colleges. No matter how perfect one’s grades, a balanced list of colleges is needed, including ones that your “mean girl” peers would apparently look down upon. The most important part of anyone’s college search is finding schools where acceptance is likely/assured, and where the student could be happy to attend.

In terms of what you need to do going forward, you aren’t in a meaningfully different position than you’d be in without those B’s. Either way, you would need “safety” and “match” schools, not just “reaches.” Either way, you could get turned down by your reaches, and if/when that happens, you’ll never know what factors contributed most to that decision. Yes, with a transcript that isn’t flawless, your odds of an Ivy acceptance are a little worse, but those odds are low-but-not-zero in either case, and the appropriate course of action is identical: apply to well-chosen reaches but also to matches and safeties.

What’s torturing you is the fact that you see any outcome but a “T20” acceptance as a catastrophe. This is quite simply distorted thinking. In fact, as others have noted, many if not most of the best CS programs in the country are at non-T20 schools.

And tbh, your mental health is far more important than which college you attend or what you major in when you get there. Can you step back from the admissions arms race for a moment, and consider what kind of environment would allow you to be your best self, to feel supported, and to recover from the challenges you have faced in high school? If you could go into the college admissions equivalent of a witness protection program, and nobody would ever know where you attended, where could you start fresh and actually flourish?

It sounds like music is important to you. Maybe a school like University of Rochester, which has a wealth of music opportunities for non-music-majors, strong STEM, an undergrad business school, an LGBTQ±affirming culture, and full-need-met financial aid, could be a good fit.

I don’t think you’ve shared your gender. If you’re female, women’s colleges like Barnard (which is part of Columbia U) or Smith (in the MA 5-college consortium) could be worth considering.

It doesn’t sound like you really have clarity about your major/career, and that is totally fine. Just look for schools where you can explore your interests, evolve as a person, and graduate without debt if at all possible.

Honestly, 90% of the angst you’re describing results from distorted thinking, which your peer group is unfortunately reinforcing. You do have financial constraints, and that will need to be taken into account, but your record is strong enough to get into schools with good financial aid. Your prospects are very good, yet you’re mired in gloom-and-doom over the prospect of not attending one of the 20 most competitive colleges in the country, as if 99% of college students were doomed to failure in life by virtue of not going to those 20 schools. Is this really worth being miserable over?

I know it’s probably unrealistic to not think about college plans at all, at this stage. But I would challenge you to face the prospect of not getting into a “T20” head on, and focus on identifying more-attainable schools that will provide a healthy environment, sufficient financial aid, and the right array of academic and extracurricular opportunities. Table the T20 obsession until you have identified “match” and “safety” schools that you can develop a positive attitude about attending. Sure, you can apply to super-reaches, and you might even get into one, but you really, really need to recalibrate your perspective on what will happen if T20 doesn’t work out. You need to be able to imagine this, not as the end of the world, but just as the beginning of another path which can still lead to a great life.

Conversely, plenty of kids at T20 schools struggle with depression, have negative experiences in college, and do not set the world on fire after college. It’s no guarantee of anything, and not the best path for everyone, to attend one of these schools. Fixating on them as the only acceptable option is counterproductive in the extreme. Please get whatever support you need to reset your perspective.

6 Likes

So, the bottom line is that if a student is going to aspire to a top school, the follow up question should be, “Top for what?” ??

2 Likes

I thought that the above points were worth repeating and taking a second look. :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

I agree completely. However…

I tend to be influenced to some extent by people I have worked with. I have worked with a LOT of CS graduates from U.Mass, some from Wisconsin, and a few from UMD. They have on the most part been excellent and have made their alma mater’s look very good. In the case of Wisconsin at one point I worked with a team of current students at Wisconsin who were doing a software project for us. Again they were excellent. One I stayed in touch with long enough for him to fly to my wedding and me to fly to his wedding.

U.Mass by the way also has a good music program.

If a students wants to study computer science, there are a LOT of universities that are very good for CS. The Ivy League has some good programs, but is not particularly known for CS. Maryland, Wisconsin, and U.Mass are all excellent. There are many other universities that are very good for CS, and OP’s stats will get him into most of them.

Exactly!

3 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.