I have a need to be in Ivy... But should I mention this in my applications?

<p>Hey all,</p>

<p>I’m an “international student” applying to transfer out of my community college. I put that term in quotes because I’m 19 yrs old and I’ve been living here for 15. I don’t have a Permanent Residency card nor a citizenship so I’m international on papers.</p>

<p>This is an obvious disadvantage for two reasons: no top tier college needs more international applicants and nobody gives a decent scholarship to us except, of course, top tier colleges.</p>

<p>I can’t afford to go anywhere. Scrapping up scholarship money (which gives $1k AT MOST) to go to a $60,000 school every year is just impossible. I can’t take out any loans or apply for financial aid. Any job that pays well enough for me to pay for school out of my own pocket takes years of experience to get or a citizenship (i.e. paid research/internships).</p>

<p>That makes me desperate to get into a good private school, but it doesn’t mean that I have no personal longing to attend. I’m currently an Engineering major at my CC with a 3.9 GPA. Last semester, I created a science club which has become greatly popular. We made several public appearances in academic fairs, organized and hosted high school fairs as well as created our own annual robotics competition. Currently, I’m taking Differential Equations, Calc-based Physics II and several engineering courses. I’ve never taken a grade lower than A- and all the teachers love my enthusiasm. They highly recommended that I apply for schools like MIT or Caltech and would vouch for me to anyone.</p>

<p>Basically, I can succeed in any environment. However, I don’t need to be in the best schools. I would be perfectly content attending RPI or Georgia Tech if only the price tag was affordable! Is this an issue that would be considered positively in applications? I have a need and I have the skill to produce excellence, but some may say the need is off-putting. I hear universities like students with a good financial background…?</p>

<p>For freshman applicants, Harvard doesn’t track or care why students want to attend their school. Admissions assumes that Harvard is everyone’s top choice. For transfer student’s, it’s a bit different. I think Yale has some great advice for transfer students that also applies to Harvard</p>

<p>

So, as a transfer applicant, you need to explain in your essay what Harvard can offer you that you cannot find at any other school. And saying “great financial aid” will not open any doors. BTW: you do understand that Harvard admits about 15 transfer students per year from an applicant pool of over 1,500 transfer applicants – that’s a 1% acceptance rate, which is significantly lower than the freshman admissions rate. </p>

<p>With regard to what gibby said, I think it is particularly important to define the academic reason why you want to attend if you are transferring from a 4 year. Everyone knows that if you are at a 2 year you need to transfer. But if you are at a 4 year you don’t need to and they want to see your ‘compelling’ reasoning. why. Not that you shouldn’t say why the target school is important.</p>

<p>Harvard isn’t a good target because of not taking many transfers, but there are other meets need colleges that are. Caltech does take community college transfers. I don’t know the situation at MIT. </p>

<p>With regard to your question. No, I don’t think financial need is something to mention. I think it will be quite obvious. You can spend the limited space you have talking about your qualifications and how they meet the target school, and why you would be a good admit for the target school.</p>

<p>I guess you are not in CA and can apply under the Dream act. Maybe if you are unsuccessful you should try to establish residency in a state friendly to your issues.</p>

<p>I am under the Dream act for my state (which is not California). It allows me to pay in state tuition for all state colleges, but that’s still $40k every year. I still can’t apply for any aid or loans, just private loans. Even then I’ll need someone American to sign off that I will be able to pay that off eventually (which I probably wont be able to with such a high interest rate).</p>

<p>MIT does take transfers. It’s my top choice to transfer but there are so few that get in and close to zero international transfers. I know Harvard also has ridiculously low acceptance rates, but what other choice do I have? Go back to my native country?</p>

<p>A lot of public schools give full ride, merit-based scholarships to good students (yes, even internationals). You just have to search!
Also, many LACs give amazing financial aid to students. It’s not just the Ivy League! </p>

<p>“in state tuition for all state colleges, but that’s still $40k every year”</p>

<p>What state has annual attendance costs of $40k+ for in-state residents? Are you sure that’s correct? Even in the states where the flagship costs that much, there are cheaper options.</p>

<p>I suppose it’s moot if you are undocumented and therefore unable to borrow, but you shouldn’t have to spend this much per year even in the states with the most expensive in-state flagship tuition (New Hampshire, Illinois, Pennsylvania, etc.).</p>

<p>Remember that just because a school does not guarantee to meet the need of internationals doesn’t mean that they have zero aid for internationals. A school that wants you badly enough might make institutional funds available, especially if you are a URM.</p>