I like too many schools??

Hi everyone!!
As I am beginning to look into colleges, I am noticing that I like a variety of different types of schools. For instance, I love Caltech but I also love Columbia and UChicago. While I am definitely a STEM student, I also enjoy many of my other english and history classes, hence my immense interest in the core curriculum found in Columbia an UChicago. Could I possibly just like each school because of the persuasiveness of college websites/tours? Or is it “normal” for a student to like schools on opposite ends of the spectrum and be a fit in different types of schools?

Those schools have something in common – very bright people and very intense academics. I had a kid whose college list was built around those traits. She was a STEM major with a passion for literature. The trick for her was finding matches and safeties that had that flavor, too.

Have you looked just down the road from Caltech at Harvey Mudd? My kid got in everyplace she applied, and that is where she picked to attend. “Mudd gave me the best shot at becoming a polymath,” she explained to me once.

@intparent wow that makes me so relieved! I certainly have a drive to learn, and I really want a place that would help me cultivate my many interests. Yes, Harvey Mudd is definitely on my list!!

So you gotta find some matches and safeties, too. :slight_smile:

A little of column A, a little of column B. I think everyone can agree that Chicago has mastered the art of college mailings.

At the risk of adding more reaches to your list, Swarthmore may interest you, particularly if you want to combine liberal arts and engineering. For a match, take a look at Reed.

Swat was on my kid’s list. Carleton, too – not quite the intensity of the other schools discussed, but a decent high match/low reach for her. She liked Reed when she visited, too, although it didn’t end up on her final list.

Hm. Wondering when someone will post some matches and safeties for the OP? I know this comes up a lot on CC but intensely academic schools are harder to find in those categories. @intparent Do you have a child who attended Dickinson? What do you think about Dickinson as a safety for someone like OP?

…

We need to know state of residence and budget to provide safeties.

Privates that meet full need tend to be reaches, not safeties.

Yes, D1 went there. Dickinson could be a safety for someone with high stats, but showing interest is important. My D2 (the high stats kid) refused to apply after our tour guide asked if she had a sister on campus (they look alike). :slight_smile:

My D2’s full list was Mudd, UChicago, Swat, Carleton, Mount Holyoke, Macalester, Kenyon, and Lawrence. She didn’t apply to Columbia because she doesn’t like NYC. Caltech came off the list because she felt like it was too tech focused, and she didn’t want to completely give up her other interests. Reed was off the list at my request for some reasons regarding how I felt the environment might mesh with her personality in a negative way (and she was ok with that).

Franklin & Marshall might make a good safety for a high stats STEM kid (not engineering), but they don’t give merit aid and we weren’t interested in being full pay at a safety. There are certainly other STEM focused schools further down in the ranking that might be considered. I’d think about Case Western, too.

Case Western might be a good safety or match depending on stats. I think I heard they were strong in non-stem subjects too.

U of Rochester? Don’t know about their financial aid, though…

Both Grinnell and Oberlin have great STEM programs and both provide merit aid.

@Sportsman88 I live in New Jersey. Household income is ~100k per year. However, I definitely want to go for a phD and research so that presents something to consider. Thank you all for your suggestions! Does Dickinson have a good STEM program?

How much have your parents said they will pay? You need to run the net price calculator on each school website with them.

Dickinson is okay in STEM. Can you tell us your stats? We could make better suggestions then.

A PhD program pays you. You typically TA for ~20 hours per week for a year or two while taking classes (tuition is covered), pass your qualifying exams, then enter the research/thesis phase of the program. If you don’t pass quals, you usually leave with a master’s degree after 2 years. You continue to be paid your stipend during the research/thesis phase, but don’t usually have to TA during that phase. A few students get to start as research assistants right away and skip the TA part. The stipends aren’t huge. Generally my STEM kid found the higher ranked the school, the higher the stipend. You can live on it, but not at all lavishly. It all takes several years (5-6 seems pretty typical for STEM students). Main point is, don’t save your money for grad school if you are focused on a PhD.

SAT: 1600 (23 essay)
Subject SATs (I’m going to take more): Chemistry- 800; Math 2-800
APs: Biology (5), English Lang (5), Physics C E (5), Physics C M (5), Calc AB (5), Calc BC (5), Psych (5), Chemistry (5), Macroeconomics (4), Microeconomics (5)
GPA (my school only does weighted): 4.3/4.0

Okay, great test scores. Top colleges will usually unweight/recalculate your GPA. You might want to do that yourself, as your GPA may look a lot weaker in that light. Essentially, for example, a “B” is worth 3.0, whether it is in a regular, honors, or AP class.

I would not bother to take more subject tests, although a high score on a non-STEM test could add to your application. I’m assuming you are a junior. Put your energy into GPA and ECs instead.

I believe Princeton gives a little boost for NJ residents. Still a reach but take any boost you can get. I’d at least consider applying if your GPA matches your SAT.

I just calculated and UWG is 4.1. @Sportsman88 I always though that Princeton being easier for NJ applicants was a myth?

I can’t speak first hand. I’m going off what I read here. It’s worth more research at least. BTW, you can’t have an unweighted GPA above 4.0 unless it’s on a 5.0 scale.