Identifying a more holistic or relaxed Ivy or reach for my creative child

@contdes, I agree Wesleyan sounds like a good option. I would also suggest your son look at Williams, even though it may be on the smallish side for him.

I think your son’s participation in sports plus art/music would be appealing to Williams as they favor the trifecta of academics, the arts and sports or outdoorsy activities. It would be a reach, but I think he fits the Williams profile of energetic, multifaceted, multitalented kids who are both arty and sporty.

Williams’ academics are rigorous, but I wouldn’t call the atmosphere competitive. The English department is top rate with several well known fiction writers on the faculty. Williams offers diverse performance and museum/studio opportunities fo continue involvement in music and fine art, even for those that major in something else. Double or even triple majoring is common.

I’m feeling so much better. This all sounds very encouraging. @ucbalumnus I hear you re “interest”. We have several weekends reserved for trips coming up and will make a point of visiting anywhere he might apply (I’ve also signed him up for every possible “on the road” admission event in our city. For AL, he would actually get a full scholarship and then some, assuming his NMSF status goes to NMF. But he will not be happy at a big state school in the south. He is adamant about this.

@Houston1021 Yes! Pomona is on his list and we have a visit coming up. I’d heard they are strict about GPA for admissions, so was a little worried. Naviance suggests he is competitive (with others who’ve applied from his school), but it’s not as matchy as I’d like! ; ) Retired (and extremely knowledgeable) GC puts it as a high match but not a reach. I think I must convince him to apply to Emory. He has visited, and Atlanta is a big city that he’d like. Rice is gaining traction, too (at least for me!). He seems to have this aversion in general to TX (he likely assumes all of TX is conservative), so we will have to work on that. It’s crazy that males (esp white) might have an advantage anywhere, but I’ve been hearing that more and more. And I think that’s esp true at LACs. I see rather surprising imbalances of M/F at those schools.

@circuitrider Ha! I was looking up that very thing. Shall show list to S. Inspiring.

@roycroftmom There is one outlier that seems to appear on every graph and I keep thinking it must be the child of a very wealthy and well-connected Fortune 500 CEO. Otherwise, S is smack in the middle or above of a bunch of green checks for his safeties. Even the old GC would roll his eyes when the subject of that outlier came up. I will ask about class rank. I do worry about multiple kids from same school applying to same colleges.

@momrath A friend of mine went to Williams and I keep throwing it out there to S. He seems to think it’s too remote or too small a town. Can you help me persuade him? I really like the idea that he could continue a focus on art while majoring in something else like English.

I mean I know im known here for saying this, but UC Berkeley could be good. They have a great art culture here thats especially free, and if his sophomore and Junior year grades are good they actually only look at those two years. So, you could mitigate the gpa issue

Williamstown IS a small town, a mountain village really. For my son this was a big plus because he was drawn to the natural beauty and outdoorsy activities as well as the focus on art, art history and museum culture. It’s highly subjective, though, and kids tend to love it or hate it. A visit will tip the scale one way or the other.

Williams’ culture is, to me, a unique balance of intellectual curiosity, physical activity and commitment to the arts. There’s a high level of energy and diversity of interest, which sounds like what your son is looking for. The students are bright, talented, friendly and down to earth. The faculty are supportive and accessible, and mentoring relationships that endure long after graduation are part of the package.

The Berkshires feature a lot of highly sophisticated exposure to the arts (music, theater, dance, art). Notably in or near Williamstown, the Clark and MassMoCA both worldclass art museums, offer students hands-on opportunities to interact with museum professionals and artists and the art itself. Same with music – several of my son’s friends were serious musicians, both classical and jazz focused, and though they majored in other disciplines, they continued to perform regularly while at Williams. The English department is really superb and authors like Jim Shepherd and Andrea Barrett set a high bar for fiction.

My son’s second choice probably would have been Wesleyan. He liked Brown and Yale, though his preference was toward the LAC experience. He also really liked Kenyon and Hamilton, though they are even more remotely located than Williams. He had a wonderful four years at Williams and would do it again in a heartbeat.

Tufts might fit - it straddles the line between a LAC (i.e Wesleyan) and a Research U (i.e. Brown)

5,000 undergraduates, small grad school and graduate IR school located on the Medford/Somerville campus - just outside Boston. Carnegie Classification of “Arts and Science Focus” with a small Engineering School that is tightly coupled to the School of Arts and Sciences.

Museum/Fine Arts School located downtown next to the Museum of Fine Arts- w/ many studio courses also taught in Medford/Somerville

Large, inclusive music program in Medford/Somerville & a conservatory program with the New England Conservatory located downtown

The Medical, Bio Medical graduate, Dental and Nutrition schools are located on a separate downtown Boston campus and the Vet school is located on a separate campus in Grafton (This makes the university feel smaller)

Laid back, friendly culture (more “find your passion” than “work hard/play hard”). Big on global perspective (6 course language/culture core requirement), Very interdisciplinary, (with strong distribution requirements). Big on community/global service - (has an entire college of civic life), Peace Corps is popular.
More “quirky” than “edgy”.

A little easier to get into than Brown (14% acceptance rate)
Very holistic, requires 3 supplemental essays, looks for “emotional intelligence” and creativity, likes community service
Will super score ACT
90% of admits in top 10% of class, but will evaluate GPA in context

Good Luck!

You may wish to check the common data set of each school, which breaks down the admissions rates by gender. The difference can be substantial. And I can assure you that neither Rice nor Houston is conservative. Solid blue city with thriving gay population led, until recently, by super popular gay mayor for 12 years.

@contdes you should be able to determine your son’s approximate ranked by looking at your high schools School profile. Usually high schools (even private ones) keep that available online so that colleges can find it easily. In most cases there is a GPA percentage breakdown in the school profile and you can see where your son’s actual GPA fits into that break down. If you can’t find it online I would ask the GC for it or just call the office. It is a public document

3.7 is a soft GPA, even from a good independent school. One of my kids had an identical situation. She got in everyplace she applied (including some top schools like UChicago, Swarthmore, Mudd, and Carleton). But she had a very strong app otherwise (almost perfect test scores, recs that strengthen her app, and interesting & fairly strong EXs). Otherwise I think she wouldn’t have had such good results. I suspect it would have kept her out of Stanford if she had applied there, though.

Here is an article that discusses gender gap in admissions at some highly ranked schools. Brown and Pomona are mentioned.
https://www.■■■■■■■■■■■■/the-ivy-coach-blog/college-admissions/gender-college-admission/

:open_mouth:

@circuitrider, how could you leave Lin Manuel Miranda off the list of famous Wesleyan writers?!

He probably thought Miranda went to Hamilton rather than Wesleyan. :">

@momrath That’s such a great advert for Williams. I will share this info with him. I think we could try to do a trip to Wesleyan, Williams, and maybe somewhere nearby.

@mastadon I like your handle. Tufts. I hadn’t really thought about Tufts b/c I always imagine it as kids going into foreign service (pathetically narrow minded of me), but S is fairly globally minded and so may like it. He would be happy about the proximity of Boston, too. I need to make a list of depts/divisions and have him go through it: like the Tufts fine arts program. As I type this, I’m remembering a postcard he got a few days ago from SMFA! And frankly the “find your passion” might be exactly the kind of attitude he needs. He is the type of kid who will go down and intellectual or creative rabbit hole and not emerge for days.

I actually have another question that thinking about SMFA raises. If S were to apply to Tufts as an art major, what happens if he changes his mind and wants English? LACs seem pretty fluid in that regard, but at somewhere like Tufts are you applying to a particular school and therefore tied to it? That may be a stupid question. Blame the fact that it’s our first child going to college!

@intparent by “soft GPA” do you mean sort of “must keep in perspective of school”? I was confused by the “even from independent schools.” S’s old GC who knew him pretty well was suggesting schools that I thought S had no chance at. He even dismissed the matter of S’s GPA but encouraged him to get his SAT score up (evidently suggesting that the test scores would be more important in the context of his application/school, etc). Ultimately he did better on ACT (34C or 35C SS). I’m happy to hear that your D with a multifacted app got into so many places that we would assume wouldn’t take a 3.7.

LOL @roycroftmom He will definitely appreciate the value of the gay mayor of Houston!

@suzyQ7 That’s basically what I did. But the school hasn’t published the profile for this/my S’s class, so I looked at the last three years and lined up my S’s GPA with the % categories. One thing I’m not sure how to resolve is the fact that the school only provides weighted GPA (and does their profile accordingly). So with those profiles I had to work with S’s weighted. Then I recalculated S’s GPA without the weights b/c I know schools do that. His weighted GPA is a 4.35. An A at the school can be a 4 or a 5, if it’s AP or Honors. So it’s kind of hard to know where he would be ranked for unweighted. And I honestly am not really sure I’m even making the right assumptions about how the GPA works. Good grief the whole thing gives me a headache.

Bottom line, these days a 3.7 is on the low end for top schools. That is what I mean by a “soft” GPA. Below that and it is very challenging to get in.

You’ll have to talk to Tufts about their policies for transferring between schools. That would be not only adcoms but the administration of the schools, like a dean or advisor. It can also help to talk with students, as they can tell how easy or hard it is if they’ve tried it. In general the tougher the school is to get in as freshman, the more restrictive the school will be in transferring later on. So engineering at say Berkeley or school of foreign service at Georgetown would be tough to transfer into and easier to transfer out of. English is typically in the Arts and Science college and those tend to be easier to transfer into.

As I understand it Tufts/SMFA offers a 4.0 year BFA (which is more art intensive than a BA) and a 5.0 year joint BFA+BA/BS (which allows more breadth, but takes longer). Be aware that the SMFA is in a different location from the Tufts Medford campus, about half an hour by shuttle bus. Studio classes tend to extend over several hours and art students tend to work late in the studio, so some additional coordination may be needed.

The dual Brown/RISD program is similar to Tufts/SMFA but is wildly selective. Brown also has a good art department of its own separate from RISD, and all Brown students can take courses at RISD.

If art is a big part of who your son is, he should submit an art portfolio with his applications, even if he doesn’t intend (or hasn’t decided) to major in art. This is true at mid-sized privates with strong art programs and especially true at small LACs. Same for music and creative writing; if his talent is notable, submit supplements. I would also suggest including an art (music/writing) resume that lists relevant courses, awards and significant accomplishments. A third supplemental recommendation from an instructor or mentor can also be a good idea. My observation is that admissions committees at arts-friendly LACs and medium sized privates consider arts participation an important EC and it’s critical to get the message across in the application.

If you do visit Williams be sure to spend some time at The Clark and MassMoCA. It’s hard to imagine that museums of this calibre could be found in this rural environment. Skidmore (which I think would be a low-match or safety for your son) is another school that has an excellent fine arts program and a very good museum, located in a lively small town.

I would be cautious about submitting supplements. Is an admission officer qualified to review? Will it be reviewed by a professor? Reviewers will have differing tastes and biases.

In my opinion, its better to seek external validation on your art, writing and/or performance from say Young Arts Awards, Scholastic Arts and Writings Awards, published work, art awards, theater or film credits; then simply list the awards/publications/credits on your common application.

Of course that’s for BA program. An art school or conservatory, like RISD, would require a portfolio submittal.

Submission of an art portfolio is common at LACs even when they aren’t making a specific judgement on whether your art is ‘good enough’ for their school. As @momrath indicated it, it is evidence of a sustained involvement in an area that is harder to quantify than it would be for a member of the school orchestra, the choir, the debate team, etc. Even the process of creating the portfolio submission t some effort- arguably as much as an admissions essay.

Of course, external validation is great, and especially useful when applying for an actual art program.