Identifying a more holistic or relaxed Ivy or reach for my creative child

I’m trying to help S18 identify a reach or two that would be a good fit for him. He’s got a few LACs on his list that would be reaches, but I’m thinking those might be too small for him. He’s very creative/artsy and kind of edgy and politically minded and intellectually curious and needs a place that is not going to be hardcore competitive academic (not that he doesn’t want to study, but he needs a more relaxed atmosphere). Says he wants a humanities major but the specific major changes a bit depending on the school he’s researching. I suspect he may end up doing English or creative writing. Here’s some info about him:

GPA is 3.7 UW. School doesn’t rank but I suspect he’s top 20% (it’s a rigorous private school). ACT is 34 from one sitting and a 35 superscore from two sittings. He’s gotten 5s on the AP exams he’s done and will have a total of 6 APs. National Merit Semifinalist, a healthy dose of honors societies and awards at school. Extracurriculars at school include varsity sport, and various other academic activities and clubs. Outside of school, lots of music/fine arts. Leadership in student government at his school. His essay is very good, according to GC. GC also said his teacher recs were outstanding.

With the GPA being on the lower end of the tippy top schools, I want to direct him to schools with more holistic admissions policies. As a “whole” applicant, he is appealing, but in a school that demands a 4.0 and top 10%, he won’t make the cut. Some reading on here suggests Brown might be a reasonable fit for him. Is that accurate? Any other suggestions? Financial aid is not an issue. No legacy status or hooks at any of these kinds of schools.

Brown sounds like a good fit. It’s going to be a high reach for anyone. It helps being male as Brown gets many more apps from females.

@Dolemite Glad I was “getting” the vibe about Brown. I’ll suggest that. Someone told me Yale, and I thought that was crazy. Yale seems to have a very competitive vibe for students. And the irony re males! I’ll push him a little towards Brown. If anyone else has suggestions, I’d appreciate it!

Is Macalester on his list? Or Pitzer?

@intparent I suggested those, actually. But they are really small. He’s got similar reaches on his current list, and so I was trying to find some bigger schools (like ~5k undergrad students). Pitzer has the advantage of the Claremont colleges, of course.

What about Wash U or U Chicago or Stanford? My inclination is that the northeastern ivies tend towards more numbers and hardcore atmosphere. But honestly that’s total speculation on my part.

He could start with some of these schools, then screen by additional criteria of importance to him:

“The 10 Best American Colleges for Writers” | USA Today

Emory
Hamilton
JHU
MIT
NYU
WUStL
UIowa
Columbia
UMichigan
Colorado College

http://college.usatoday.com/the-10-best-american-colleges-for-writers/

“The 10 Best Colleges for Creative Writers” | The Freelancer

Emory
Hamilton
JHU
MIT
NYU
Oberlin
Princeton
Sarah Lawrence
Sewanee
Yale

http://contently.net/2014/11/06/resources/10-best-colleges-creative-writers/

“The 25 Most Literary Colleges in America” | Flavowire

Princeton
UIowa
Brooklyn
Pomona
UHartford
Wesleyan
Sarah Lawrence
Oberlin
Williams
Vanderbilt
Smith
UMississippi
NYU
Colorado College
UChicago
Hamilton
Harvard
UIUC
Sewanee
Emerson
UT-Austin
Columbia
Vassar
Bennington
The New School

http://flavorwire.com/409437/the-25-most-literary-colleges-in-america

I’d include Kenyon as well. Of the schools above, Vassar, Wesleyan or Oberlin might be good matches for his general preferences. Hamilton might be a good choice as well for its flexible curriculum.

“Holistic admissions” is most commonly found at colleges where a large number of applicants have top-end academic stats, so subjective holistic review is used to distinguish between the mass of applicants who are difficult to distinguish based on academic stats. But it means that an applicant that does not have top-end academic stats will be at a significant disadvantage. A 3.7 GPA and rank below top 10% would make any super-selective college a super-reach.

https://www.brown.edu/admission/undergraduate/explore/admission-facts indicates that Brown admission rates for ranks #1, #2, top 10%, and below top 10% were 19%, 14%, 10%, and 2% respectively.

Emory is noted for creative writing, and–among LACs–both Kenyon and Sewanee have strong literary traditions that reach back to the heyday of the New Criticism in the early decades of the 20th century.

If you want an all-around strong school with a “relaxed” vibe, you should consider Rice. Wash U is perhaps a bit more buttoned-down than Rice, but it still offers a more collaborative vibe than do some its peer schools.

U Chicago is anything but laid back. Stanford may seem a little laid back on the surface, but don’t be fooled. WashU might be a good choice. Be sure to show interest there.

Pitzer does have the advantages of a small and a bigger school because of the layout and shared resources of the consortium.

I couldn’t agree more with what @ucbalumnus said above. For example, Stanford has a holistic approach, yet their admit rate for “below 3.70” GPA was 1% in 2016 (Class of 2020). http://admission.stanford.edu/apply/selection/profile16.html

Wouldn’t “laid back” have a lot to do with the student’s major and course work selection? For example, a biology major sharing courses with pre-meds may find a more competitive culture than someone in some other major where there is less grade/GPA competition.

I would take a look at Wesleyan and Oberlin - each at about 3,000 students, so large by LAC standards. Vassar is about 2,400. Being male provides a small admissions boost at LACs. We visited all of these schools and the student vibe might appeal to your son.

Wash U’s admission rate is less than 20% and demonstrated interest is important. Lovely school, but I wouldn’t classify the the student vibe as predominantly “edgy” or progressive.

In a small private school your counselor should have a good sense of where students with his stats apply and end up, particularly if they use naviance. The counselor will also know precisely, but may not share, the class rank. I know more than one parent who thought their child was top 5 percent only to learn they weren’t top 25 percent. Your counselor also will have a better sense of any special relationship your school has with colleges-sometimes a college will take a lower gpa from a known school than otherwise; sometimes they never admit from that school. Absent a hook, that gpa isn’t competitive for the very top schools.

Thanks, everyone. I appreciate all of this thoughtful advice. Rice is starting to sound like a viable option for a reach. Wash U, too. I’m going to read their website tonight. Wesleyan would be good for size, and it’s definitely a reach for him. Shall investigate that, too.

The GC retired last year and so the new one is just settling in. We haven’t had a chance to meet yet b/c of our work schedule. According to Naviance and previous GC, Emory is a match, Sewanee, Oberlin, Kenyan, Miami, and Alabama are safeties. And, to be honest, we already have a few safeties he likes. I’m thinking the reputation and rigor of his school might have a positive effect on his GPA or something (???). He is toying with Emory but resists schools like Kenyan in small towns. Sigh. I’m really looking for 1-2 reaches w/ 5,000 undergrads for him to investigate. And Rice and Wesleyan and Wash U might be just the ticket. I also am reluctant to suggest a school only for its creative writing program b/c, well, he changes his mind on a dime!

@roycroftmom I think your comment about school relationship might be right on. When I look at graphs in naviance, the lowest GPA for accepted students from our school is lower than collegedata.com says it should be, making me think that the reputation of our school (or their relationship with the college) has the effect of boosting the GPA value. If that makes sense. If schools consider weighted GPAs, then S’s is much higher. So maybe that’s in play too.

Wesleyan – he sounds perfect for it

@ucbalumnus Those are sobering %s for Brown. And I do need that sort of reality check. S would technically fall in the “school does not rank” category (10% accepted). My guess is that he is somewhere between 15-25% if I look at the GPA spread from the last 3 years. So I could be way off if his own class is more competitive or less. My hunch is that his class is less competitive than previous years. But in truth he could be top 10% or 30%. No access to his class’s GPA range, so hard to know for sure. Frankly, I don’t think the colleges would be able to even estimate his rank, though they could compare him to previous applicants, I suppose.

No need to look at Naviance for Alabama. 3.7 HS GPA and 34 ACT means an automatic $25,000 merit scholarship at Alabama (almost as much as out-of-state tuition): https://scholarships.ua.edu/types/out-of-state.php

Be careful with “safeties” that use level of applicant’s interest in admissions (see their common data sets, section C7, or their admissions tabs on http://www.collegedata.com ). Level of applicant’s interest is sometimes measured to see whether an “overqualified” applicant may be using the college as a “safety” but is unlikely to attend if admitted. In this case, an unpleasant surprise in the form of a waitlist of rejection may be delivered if the college finds insufficient indications of interest.

Note also that the colleges may have rather different social and political environments (e.g. relative political left/right leanings, presence and size/influence of fraternities/sororities, spectator sports, overall size, etc.).

My D sounds very much like your son. Being a male humanities applicant will give him an advantage at some schools like Brown and Emory which have more females than males. My daughter, who is a Psych/English double major, came down to Emory vs. Rice and chose Rice. Rice has an equal number of males and females. Both schools were good fits for her, but she preferred the residential college system at Rice. Rice ranks very high for happy students and quality of life. Rice is more stem focused than Emory, but has a strong humanities department too. If he wants to be considered for the Emory Scholars prize he needs to submit his application November 15.

Does he already have Pomona on his list? It is very small but is a member of the Claremont consortium.

Wesleyan writers:

Robert Ludlum (“The Bourne Identity”)
Robin Cook, MD. (“Coma”)
Sebastian Junger (“The Perfect Storm”)
Amy Bloom (“Away”)
Lemony Snicket (aka, Daniel Handler)
Akiva Goldsman (screenplay writer)
Joss Whedon (screenplay writer)
Alex Kotlowitz (author, “There Are No Children Here”)
Alex Kurtzman (screenplay writer)
Matthew Weiner (creator, “Mad Men”)
Beverly Donofrio (author, “Riding in Cars With Boys”)
Charles Olson (one of the original Black Mountain poets)
among many others.

Beware of outliers on the Naviance data. Generally they have a hook which counterbalanced their stats and altered the results in a way not applicable to you. The new counselor will know class rank and it will matter, particularly if others from his high school are applying to that college as well. Ask the counselor how he will compare, as an overall package, to others, from the same school applying. Also use early decision to your advantage of a full pay male applicant.