If No on Colby Where to?

Hello,
I have an ACT-27(am retaking), heavy family responsibility, 3.5 UW 4.3W, consistent EC w/ 2 leadership roles, AA female, very low -income, and from SC.
While Colby may sound like a reach, I was accepted into a fly-in program there where we were heavily encouraged to apply, and Colby is my dream school.
However, I understand I need to apply to a range including safties and fits. I am looking for small-medium LAC’s with similar commitment to financial aid (Colby is no-loan) and focus on international opportunity as I would love to be a diplomat.

Any help pointing me in the right direction would be greatly appreciated :slight_smile:

Colby is a very promotional school so I am not surprised you were “encouraged” to apply. Realistically schools like Lafayette, St. Lawrence, Union College, Franklin and Marshall, Muhlenberg and similar might be a better mix of applications for you. Colby gets a staggering amount of applications for its size and the proof that it is a heavily promotional school is the low yield rate compared to its peers.

I’d suggest you get your hands on a good college guide book (ex. Fiske, Princeton Review, Insiders Guide) which you should be able to find in your guidance office or at a library and start reading up on other LACs – there are a ton of amazing ones out there. That said, Dickinson (PA) might be worth reading up on – as I remember from visiting there with my D, the school has an international focus.

You’d have to check out their FA situation, but take a close look at Dickinson and Macalaster based on size and your academic areas of interest. Both are very international in scope.

When you look for college “matches,” it’s not just what you love, what future you want, but where you can academically thrive. The 27 and uw gpa suggest you widen your ideas.

Have you looked at other colleges? You can find many with the appeal of Colby, where you can flourish. Look into their aid policies, run their NPCs. And consider southern schools, not just up north.

Yes, get a Fiske guide.

If you got invited to fly-in, a high rate of fly-ins are admitted. It’s never a guarantee, but its as close to a likely letter as you’ll get from Colby. I would think if Colby really wants you, it’s peer schools will too. Bates, Middlebury and Bowdoin are all NE schools probably looking also for good student URMs from the South.

I don’t know what the FA situition is at some of these, but they could be a good fit if Colby doesn’t work out.

Dickinson, Union, Gettysburg, Franklin and Marshall, Trinity, Denison, St. Lawrence, Hobart might be worth a look. Depending on how the ACT goes, test optional schools could be good, and both Bates and Bowdoin (and Trinity) are in that group. I agree with @preppedparent that your invitation to the fly in means you are in a special category of applicant though.

Thank you guys so much for your help! Will look into the book and these schools.

U.S. News can also be a good source for exploring overlap colleges. For example, Colby appears in the St. Lawrence entry under “Students Also Applied to”:

https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/st-lawrence-university-2829