<p>“This statement has to be the biggest load of horsesh** and it reeks of idiocracy… So please avoid the rhetoric and misguided generalizations people and use a little common sense…so let me dispel this stupid claim…”</p>
<p>Shantytown, are you really just an unpleasant person? Or are you just disrespectful online? Your tone is almost unbearable (warning).</p>
<p>Look, in order to “dispel any stupid claims” you might first want to establish credibility. And I am afraid that both your tone and the substance of your posts does not help you. For someone who uses the phrase “common sense” so often, one would think you would actually use it.</p>
<p>“Let’s take the largest law firm in my home city of Miami…”</p>
<p>Uh, it may be just me but when I think “biglaw” I think of Wall Street Law, I think of Cravath, Wachtell, Skadden, etc. I don’t think about “Miami”. I’ve had great mojitos in Miami, but the lawyers I’ve worked with on M&A deals came from the Street.</p>
<p>“If that’s still not enough for you, then let’s look at the largest law firm in the world…”</p>
<p>You were right in predicting my objection, clearly Miami is not what most people have in mind when they say BigLaw. Now, you call people stupid for making generalizations…and you do the same (and in a rather annoying tone)? </p>
<p>LooK: first, you have failed to provide salary data for that Miami firm; second, you have failed to ignore the personal connections those “third-tier” partners had, which helped them get where they are; third, using the “largest-firm in the world”, really? since when does size=prestige or even quality? </p>
<p>“Clifford Chance. Among the very few US partners in the firm”</p>
<p>Well, if most people who made partner there are not from the US then your comment is certainly useless. Most people here are trying to position themselves (as Americans) in order to have a successful career in the US. If your point is that graduates from law schools overseas can be just as successful, then point taken–but completely irrelevnt here. Again, for someone who critiques the “generalizations” of others, one would expect that he/she would write with more clarity and precision (and not just say: “stupid…myth…common sense…largest firm in the world…” and expect to have any credibility.</p>
<p>“here are some “third tier” examples: David Dibari (Albany), David Evans (Maine), Jerry MarLatt (Southwestern), Christopher Roman (Akron)….”</p>
<p>Additionally, Shantytown, do you know what the academic records of these people is, respectively? If they graduated #1 in their class, were the editor of law review, etc… it has been stated on this forum that with such academic record one may still land a partner-track position at some “biglaw” firms (in the loosest meaning of the word). But since you probably have no clue what their individual record is, or whether they got their jobs and promotions due to connections or nepotism, once again, your generalizations fail to be of any use. Moreover, considering that not everyone on this forum can expect to be #1 in their class at a third-tier school (when it is a known fact that people actually fail out at those schools, as opposed to, say, Harvard, where you have to work really hard to fail), then encouraging people to go to the best school they can get into (whether T-10, T-14, or the best regional school the get into, eg UF or of Washington) is sound advice–and meet your precious “common sense” criteria.</p>
<p>"These are certainly just a few examples and all that was needed was to actually take a look. "</p>
<p>Again, in case you fail to realize this: no one cares about a handful of examples when there are hundreds of firms out there. Those are, at best, the exceptions which prove the norm.</p>
<p>Lastly, unless you respond (that is, if you feel compelled to) in a civil manner, I shall not waste my time with you any longer.</p>