<p>I got into a debate a couple nights ago with a peer of mine. She believes that structural engineering is more of an art than geotech, due to the fact that you have to be creative with where you place beams, columns, etc. To her, the numbers are definitely part of the process, but she thinks it relies more on an intuitive feel.</p>
<p>I’m on the other end; I think geotechnical engineering is the art, not the science. To me it seems that you would need to focus more on the creative aspect and less on the numbers.</p>
<p>They are both arts and require some intuition, but in different ways.</p>
<p>There is more creative freedom with structural, because there are many different structural materials and techniques that can, at least in theory, be used in many different ways by the “artist”. In contrast, there are limits to what even the most creative “artist” can do with dirt. </p>
<p>But geotech makes greater demands on the “artist’s” understanding of the medium. Structural engineers can take the properties of concrete or steel for granted. The properties of natural soil, on the other hand, can vary by orders of magnitude from place to place, may change depending on its orientation, and and may change again between the wet and dry state. There is zero consistency or quality control in its production. All soil is provided an as-is basis, with no warranty from the manufacturer; the “artist” must assume all liability for its use. It’s much harder to really “know” natural soil than it is to “know” standard construction-grade concrete or steel.</p>
<p>Structural engineering works on understood properties of structures. That is, the strength and load bearing are known and published. </p>
<p>In geotech each site must be specifically reviewed and investigated. The art in geotech is to determine the right number of boreholes and ensure that the sampling program is sufficient to characterize the soil and underlying medium to properly support design criteria. Also complicating geotech are the environmental aspects which open a whole new discussion.</p>
<p>We pretty much know all the properties of steel and concrete. However, we don’t really know much about soils. A lot of geotechnical engineering is based on empirical data and a lot of assumptions are made based off of the limited amount of data derived from boring logs and samples.</p>
<p>Structural engineers do not, in any way, shape, or form, determine where columns and beams are placed. That’s done nearly entirely by the architects, and by the way the building “wants” to be.</p>
<p>Geotechnical engineering involves a lot more intuition and judgment calls, because it’s basically all jury rigged anyhow. It’s much more of an art than a science.</p>
<p>Go out, meet a few structural design engineers, notice how they’re pretty much all uptight and anal retentive and obsessive compulsive. (I <em>am</em> a structural engineer, so I’m allowed to make these sorts of observations!) Then track down some geotechnical engineers and notice how much more laid-back they are.</p>