Is it pointless these days for unhooked, high stat kids to apply to T40 schools?

“And it still escapes me how the CDS helps.”

It is very helpful as a starting point, it shouldn’t be the entire research of course, maybe that’s your point. However having the colleges be more open about what’s important, the EA/ED numbers, gender acceptance rates, stats, and being in a standard format is very helpful. As a tech person, openness and standardization are two things that benefit the customer a lot ( in this case, the student and family).

I agree with that @theloniusmonk . Going back to my earlier example, Duke considers your religious affiliation and Harvard doesn’t. I think we should all understand that simply ticking the box as being a member of the United Methodist Church isn’t going to hold the same weight as being actively involved as a member of the congregation.

No doubt Harvard will also be interested if you are an active member of your church, not because of your religion, but because you are involved in something you care about. I think it’s likely that because Duke is upfront about stating that they consider this, being active in the United Methodist Church is going to have a little more importance at Duke than it would at Harvard. That’s useful information.

After going through the college admissions process with an unhooked, extremely high stat kid (5.2 gpa/35 ACT), double varsity athlete, strong and meaningful EC’s from a nationally ranked public college prep school, I would not let my daughter go through it again. Grueling work for essays, invitation scholarship programs, etc. She was only admitted to a few T100 schools and ultimately chose to leave the country for undergrad. I have a second daughter who will be applying this year to colleges and we will not go down that road again because it is too stressful, too much work and depressing when the rejections start rolling in.

^^ This is definitely a consideration. Some kids can handle the rejection better than others. If a kid is going to find it soul-crushing, that needs to be factored into the strategy.

Many of the savvier families I know have thought that one through up front.

I think it’s also the culture of the high school. During rejection week, ( that’s what I call it), I asked my son how many kids got rejected. He told me like “everyone”. Point is some got rejected to “x” school and some got in but pretty much everyone gets rejected from somethings. Of course except for that one kid… Lol… But he even got rejected… Lol…

Parents/schools have to lay realistic expectations and talk about handing rejections early in the application process. My saying was “get ready, it’s coming” “Should we have pizza or ice cream or both at the pity party”? BTW - both worked ??.

The saddest posts on CC are from the kids who are devastated at the rejections. We old timers have seen posts from kids here saying the most heartbreaking things, filled with self-loathing and self-blame. I always wonder how those kids got to a point where it was THAT school or nothing.

This post is a classic. The good news was that he seemed to have come to terms with his choice by the end of the process. I would love an update from this student, but he hasn’t returned, as far as I am aware. http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-admissions/1891200-asian-rejected-from-everywhere-postmortem-p1.html

The most important thing is a balanced list. That doesn’t mean 19 reaches and 1 safety. That means, for the sake of sanity, maybe 2-4 reaches, 3-4 matches, 1-2 safeties, or something similar. My eldest applied to 12 (too many, too much work, some schools she wasn’t truly interested in) and the other applied to 7 (and even that was too many, for him.)

Do research and make a balanced list. If I were doing it a third time, I suspect the applications might be down to five or six, or maybe even one. ED can be a clear path to maintaining sanity for the decisive kid.

@Lindagaf. Exactly if I was doing it again my son had the perfect list of 5-6 schools. After I pushed him to apply to 12-15 from our psychotic list of 38 (yes you read that correctly) he ended up with acceptances from his original list… Lol… It was the unknown that was scary.

I don’t think the kids are prepared by their schools /parents properly. I got to give my son’s school credit looking back. I actually emailed and thanked his counselor on this 4 years ago. They actually “made” "the kids apply to safeties. Safeties that had real merit money also. So like every kid had a few true safeties with money in their pocket. I was actually insulted when I didn’t know any better that his counselor would actually suggest such a school for my son. Like “how dare he”… Lol. I was so uneducated on this back then… Typical parent, I guess. Many of the kids did get into the schools of their choice but couldn’t afford to go… So what good is that, right?

I am helping a friend with an extremely lovely but tippy top daughter. Getting her mother to understand what a match /safety is was like pulling teeth. I actually sent her those great podcasts that you posted. Thx.

I think grade inflation really tricks kids into believing they are tippy-top caliber students. I am blown away by how many kids on this forum have perfect GPAs and 10 APs, but mediocre scores on those APs. You shouldn’t have an A in AP Chemistry but get a >3 on the exam, IMHO.

Regarding college rejections, I actually think it’s healthy for some kids who have been “perfect” throughout middle school/high school to face some adversity and humbleness. Whether it’s applying to jobs, asking someone out on a date, or applying to very reach colleges, it’s ok to get rejected sometimes. It’s how the real world works as life will give some disappoints; it’s how you handle it is the important part.

@gardenstategal we were definitely not a “savvy” family apparently.

Lol, @dopefuture. We were almost certainly more clueless! But we had friends who had been through the process who were quite aware and strategic. The way I would be if I had a gaggle of kids.

In real life, my opinions/reactions on how kids choose targets is much tougher than what I can say here. (Imagine that.)

I’m not sure even the religion category is properly understood by anyone outside Duke. (There are legal limits around selecting one based on religion.) Do you know what “Considered” means, in contrast to “Very Important?” You think these are major differences? And absolute truths? That there really is some hierarchy where a VI tops a C? And that the colleges are passionate about getting it exxxactly right? Try to imagine the paygrade of the folks who tick those boxes!

No college defines its exact formula and gets detailed enough to glean that if you provide X and Y, you’re a lock. Or have a better shot than the kid with X and Z, and no Y. Or that a superb Y overrides a poor Z. Or that, what the hey, just write a great essay and you’re in. (Folks saying that generally can’t explain what a great essay is, for a college app. It’s not just being you, considering that this is an application for a spot, not a general blurb about yourself.)

The higher the tier, the less leeway to flub any part. No matter what the CDS says about Very Important or not. (That doesn’t speak to quality or content.) You still have an entire app to fill out and it must make sense. To them./u The whole of it. There isn’t room here to list all sorts of flubs, but be logical. Back up and examine your own assumptions.

And, for Heaven’s sake, what makes anecdotes hold any weight? (Some are ridiculously vague, with no further info on the student or the application, what made that app work, despite some issue.) Or stories about how things worked 20+ years ago, when we were seniors?

It doesn’t take being an insider to recognize what makes sense or not. Lol. Nor does claiming to have oodles of experience mean the advice is spot on. Know enough about your own targets to be logical.

One thing you can count on: for a highly competitive college, they have their pick of applicants. If you can’t handle the effort to take the level of courses, if you can’t get consistently top grades, plus the corresponding scores, if you have some quasi political stance about all this rigamarole, what are you doing putting those colleges in your sights, in the first place? If you want to say XX has been your dreams since kindergarten (huh?) but bemoan that you can’t come up with an essay topic- or go to lengths to explain why your grades dropped or what’s not fair about your high school, etc, think about whether you do match.

There are plenty of unhooked, and even ORM kids at top schools. If you kid is dead set on an ivy league school, go for it, but just be prepared to be rejected.

You are right - I meant to write Arcidiacano’s academic deciles, not Harvard’s academic ratings, and I over estimated the numbers of those as well

HOWEVER, this only really modifies my clim. The largest group of admitted students are still smart unhooked applicants.

The accurate numbers are:

Highest decile non ALDC White + Asian: 15% of admits
Second highest decile W + A non-ALDC: 10% of all admits
Third highest decile: 7%
Fourth highest decile: 5%

So, smart white + Asian kids made up about 37% of all admits in the years analyzed by Arcidiacano. Non-ALDC White + Asian kids made up 45% of all admits. ALDC kids made up 29% of the admitted students, while non-ALDC African American + Hispanic kids made up 21%.

Non-ALDC made up 71% of all admitted students, but the “missing” 5% did not provide their race. However, since the vast majority of applicants who do not provide their race are White or Asian, the percent of non-ALDC W + A applicants among the admitted students is almost certainly close to 50%. Once you remove the low income A+W students from this numbers, the unhooked students are pretty close to 45% of all admitted students.

So about 45% of all kids accepted to Harvard are unhooked, and at least 37% of all admitted applicants are academically accomplished unhooked applicants.

That is still the largest single group.

@gardenstategal It is much smoother the second time around. The oldest child is always the test subject lol.

The problem is also Naviance. Naviance software tricks kids into thinking they have a chance when they do not.

@MWolf

You’re still ignoring that 14.6% of non-ALDC white and 21.9% of non-ALDC Asian admits are disadvantaged.

@Knowsstuff - I like this idea…going to keep a full supply of Chicken nuggets & Entenmann’s pound cake in my house during the month of March (my kid is picky).

Our high school is very good about discussing the pitfalls of Naviance. They tell students and parents to discount the stray outliers, and focus on the bulk area for admits. They also encourage us to come in and speak to our GC for more specific information. In private, they will break down the admit numbers and let you know which admit “checks” were hooked students. They won’t give out a student’s private information, but you at least know if the 3 admit “checks” were unhooked or hooked. Our system also displays which students applied ED, EA, or RD. This information is VERY helpful when evaluating Naviance.

@MWolf

You’re not properly accounting for international students. The Arcidiacono paper showed non-ALDC whites and Asians were 45% of the domestic admits, not 45% of the overall admits. Their sample excluded international students.