In real life, my opinions/reactions on how kids choose targets is much tougher than what I can say here. (Imagine that.)
I’m not sure even the religion category is properly understood by anyone outside Duke. (There are legal limits around selecting one based on religion.) Do you know what “Considered” means, in contrast to “Very Important?” You think these are major differences? And absolute truths? That there really is some hierarchy where a VI tops a C? And that the colleges are passionate about getting it exxxactly right? Try to imagine the paygrade of the folks who tick those boxes!
No college defines its exact formula and gets detailed enough to glean that if you provide X and Y, you’re a lock. Or have a better shot than the kid with X and Z, and no Y. Or that a superb Y overrides a poor Z. Or that, what the hey, just write a great essay and you’re in. (Folks saying that generally can’t explain what a great essay is, for a college app. It’s not just being you, considering that this is an application for a spot, not a general blurb about yourself.)
The higher the tier, the less leeway to flub any part. No matter what the CDS says about Very Important or not. (That doesn’t speak to quality or content.) You still have an entire app to fill out and it must make sense. To them./u The whole of it. There isn’t room here to list all sorts of flubs, but be logical. Back up and examine your own assumptions.
And, for Heaven’s sake, what makes anecdotes hold any weight? (Some are ridiculously vague, with no further info on the student or the application, what made that app work, despite some issue.) Or stories about how things worked 20+ years ago, when we were seniors?
It doesn’t take being an insider to recognize what makes sense or not. Lol. Nor does claiming to have oodles of experience mean the advice is spot on. Know enough about your own targets to be logical.
One thing you can count on: for a highly competitive college, they have their pick of applicants. If you can’t handle the effort to take the level of courses, if you can’t get consistently top grades, plus the corresponding scores, if you have some quasi political stance about all this rigamarole, what are you doing putting those colleges in your sights, in the first place? If you want to say XX has been your dreams since kindergarten (huh?) but bemoan that you can’t come up with an essay topic- or go to lengths to explain why your grades dropped or what’s not fair about your high school, etc, think about whether you do match.