Is it pointless these days for unhooked, high stat kids to apply to T40 schools?

I guess I will post back in a couple of months. My kid applied to 7 schools, 4 of them T40. She’s gotten into 2 schools already that were not T40, and feels sure she can be happy at one of them. So I think we’ll be okay either way! She does have a perfect GPA and a lot of APs, but then she has made mostly 5s on the exams.

Where are those statistics from? Those number exceed the number of poor kids that are at Harvard. 18.8% of all accepted Harvard students were non-ALDC Asian, so 21.9% of that is 4% of all Harvard admits, while non-ALDC White kids made up 25.6% of teh admitted students, and 14.6% of that is 3.7% of all admitted Harvard students. That adds up to 7.7% of all Harvard students being disadvantaged White or Asian. That is far higher than the most generous estimates of the number of Harvard students from the bottom 20%, which Chetty et al. had at 4.5% total.

We haven’t even started adding how many low income Black and Hispanic students attended.

One piece of the puzzle that my S20 found useful when narrowing down the schools to which he would apply was the ACT/SAT 25%-75% range (Assuming you have done your research on fit, and also that the student’s grades, course load, EC’s, LOR’s are all “average-excellent”). We were told that an “unhooked” applicant applying to a T40 school ideally needed to be at or above the 75% percentile for ACT/SAT.

For example (for “unhooked” applicants), if a school’s ACT 25-75 range is 30-33, then a 33 would give a good shot, a 34 would give a great shot & maybe some money, a 35 an even greater shot & some money. The money part more applies to private schools, but that is a different conversation. Also, if you are looking at a public school, be sure to distinguish between in-state vs. out of state numbers.

I know that you cannot generalize. This is only ONE piece of the puzzle to consider. However, I have found that numbers are hard to argue. When speaking about this process to students, colleagues, and fellow parents, it is hard to say to someone that Johnny is not as special as they think he is as compared to other applicants. I am a parent first. All of our kids are special, and as parents, we see how hard our “average-excellent” kids have worked. I am just saying… it is easier to refer to these numbers when narrowing down the list of which schools to apply.

I will also say that I completely agree with all of the above posters that the essay is the wild card. I think that piece of the puzzle, if done brilliantly, is what will get an acceptance for an unhooked applicant in the middle of the ACT/SAT range.

To the OP, time is a critical factor when applying. What is considered a waste of time is purely subjective. However, too many long shots, may not be the best use of time. IMO, having the numbers guide you and understanding that the 25th percentile definitely does NOT pertain to unhooked applicants and even the 50th percentile does not really pertain to unhooked applicants, can help you develop a balanced - reach, match, safety - application plan without too many disappointments.

Ok; I started reading this thread late. What is ALDC?

all I can think of is Abby Lee Dance Company. (from dance moms!)

Athletes, Legacies, Donors, Children of faculty

For T40, we’re mostly talking about holistic colleges that select based on more than stats. Stats matter very much. But the rest of the app forms a critical part of the impressions, the make or break.

As for Naviance, they don’t force you to “buy the bridge.” Kids aiming at a certain level of college really should understand the larger picture.

And frankly, since we’re talking T40, there are few circumstances where any essay can resolve lower than expected stats. (Or lack of rigor, empty ECs, etc.) And if a kid misunderstands what the personal statement is meant to show, it’s tough to hit it out of the park. See, all the factors depend on that right understanding of what IS meaningful to your targets.

And don’t forget that the supps include written responses, as well. How you choose to answer is a reflection of your knowledge of the college, your thinking, etc, as well. The whole dang app is your vehicle.

If we add “well-rounded” to the student description, I wonder if it’s an even tougher hill to climb, particularly for the most selective schools. I found this thread incredibly informative, although a bit depressing for the average excellent student. It does seems stacked against a kid w/out hooks but limited resources who’s trying to figure out on their own what schools are looking for and how to package that.

After reading this, I feel I should have discouraged my daughter from applying to so many reaches - but then I remember that, except for in-state and NMF schools, they’re almost the only game in town since she needs a school that meets full need w/out loans.

At the top of the schools, being over the 75% percentile may still very will not cut it unless you have out-of the-ordinary ECS. Niche was a useful reality check…seeing a see of red dots for 1600 SAT/4.0 GPAs was an eye-opener for her. Fortunately she has been unphased by the bad news so far…but I’m stocking up on ice cream for spring.

@TrendaLeigh why does she need a school that meets full need without loans? Lots of kids have student loans. They just need to be at a manageable level.

Here is the bottom line - it depends on what a person considers “pointless”. At what percent acceptance rates does a person decide that it is not worth their time and effort? From the data, it would seem that, at least for a few tens of thousands of applicants, a perceived 5% acceptance rate is still a good enough chance for them to put in at least enough effort to submit an application. For other it’s not worth really putting effort into a college to which they do not have at least a 30% chance of being accepted.

What is pointless is getting all excited and hopeful about being accepted to colleges to which many more applicants like oneself were rejected than were accepted. It is often worth throwing a Hail Mary pass, but one should not base their game plan on it.

Note that the applicants that Harvard flags SES “disadvantaged” in the lawsuit sample and internal Harvard OIR report corresponded to less than ~median US income. For example, a large portion of $40k to $80k income families were flagged as SES disadvantaged, as well a small portion of >$80k. This roughly corresponds to the income threshold for which Harvard reports zero expected cost to parents. Among the full sample, 12.2% of applicants were flagged as SES “disadvantaged”, and 16.5% of admits were flagged as SES “disadvantaged.”

In the lawsuit sample, ~44% of domestic admits were both non-ALDC and non-URM. These are the stronger analyzed hooks. Applying early and being SES “disadvantaged” both were also associated with a notable admissions advantage, but were not as powerful as the more traditional ALDC and URM hooks. In the lawsuit sample, ~25% of domestic admits were non-ALDC, non-URM, non-SES “disadvantaged” who applied RD. The lawsuit sample includes 2 of 6 years in which no early action was offered. If you only consider years in which early action was offered, then the total drops to ~16-17% of domestic admits. This latter group had a very low admit rate.

However, the OP was talking about T40 schools. Harvard is not a good representation for chance of admissions to >0 USNWR top 40 schools.

“So about 45% of all kids accepted to Harvard are unhooked, and at least 37% of all admitted applicants are academically accomplished unhooked applicants.”

The issue isn’t that there are unhooked kids at Harvard, it’s how tough it is to get in for them compared to ALDC, URM and first-gen. There’s a big difference between telling an athlete who has a commitable offer from Harvard that all he or she needs to do is write a good enough essay, vs a white or asian unhooked, who’s pretty much told, your essay better be one of the top 2 or 300 that Harvard reads.

"I’m not sure even the religion category is properly understood by anyone outside Duke. (There are legal limits around selecting one based on religion.) Do you know what “Considered” means, in contrast to “Very Important?” And absolute truths?

Sure so you can actually contact Duke to find out or clarify if you visit, that’s sort of the idea, to dig deeper in your words. But there would be no way to know that unless you saw it in the CDS. And nobody is saying they’re absolute truths, more like starting points to get an idea.

For T40 schools, would you say that a kid who checks the boxes for high SAT and GPA, good LORs, sufficient class rigor and somehow pulls out some good-enough essays would need more than some typical school-based clubs to pass the EC threshold?

Let’s assume the kid is dedicated to one of those school clubs, year round participation/fundraising, low-level leadership in it but doesn’t have anything otherwise different in his EC basket.

No out-of-school commitment to underwater basket weaving and didn’t start a company or a nonprofit, etc.

Does this kid still count as average-excellent with an acceptable shot in T40 Admissions or does that EC profile fall under the deficient category, necessitating a need to really shine in essays or in some way?

@OceanIsle - it’s hard to say. It seems like some excellent essays and a list of schools that makes sense for that kid (where the schools have been researched and time has been put into the supplemental essays to demonstrate fit) could give him/her just as good a shot as any average excellent unhooked student. Maybe not for the top 10-15.

Like others have said, what’s pointless to some is not to others. My S19 had some great in state options and then the rest of his list included reach schools (for acceptance or large scholarships). The schools were chosen for specific reasons in addition to financial aid, not just for prestige. I knew S could handle the potential disappointment and he was willing to do a LOT of essays for the very small chance of acceptance at many of the schools. While he did have great leadership roles/awards on two varsity teams and was class president (of about 800 kids) junior year, plus a few other things, he definitely fell in the average excellent category. If I had to guess, I think what tipped the scales for him were his essays and something that @Lindagaf has mentioned a few times. He’s likable and engaging, and I think that came through for a few AOs at least.

Athlete
Legacy or Lineage
Dean’s list or Development / Donor
Child of faculty or staff

OP, you still have to match what the individual targets look for. Great academics, great essays, great personality, you still need to match. Or they’ll let some other school want you.

Not sure everyone here agrees but you cant just be generically good. These colleges aren’t copies of each other.

And not sure why Harvard is once again some overarching example for the rest.

I really appreciate the wealth of advice on here. If I’m being completely honest, as the OP this post came about when I spoke with a coworker this week who appeared so completely misinformed about his son’s chances at selective schools that I felt sorry for him. The kid has almost all reaches on his list and has already tasted reality with several rejections.

It made me reflect a little and think, “I hope I’m wrong. What do I know? I hope some AO loves the kid.”

But my next thought was that my youngest really needs help with putting a list together. And when it’s all said and done, with prestige not being important to us, I think it’s me who is afraid for her to reach and be rejected. I’m not a risk taker. So I posted here to survey whether I should bother including a certain category of schools on our lists of visits or skip them since my kid is average-excellent in stats but unhooked.

However, in the end it’s going to be my daughter’s decision about whether or not she wants to apply to reaches or play it safe - not mine. Most importantly it will be about finding fit, and fit may mean taking some risks if she decides they are right for her.

My projection is that ideally she should have 1-2 safeties, maybe 3-4 matches, and a few reaches if she chooses. And I am really thankful to everyone here for all of your priceless insight.

Those are straight from the 2019 Arcidiacono paper that you have repeatedly referenced.

If you want a top-40 level school without the uncertainty of holistic admissions, apply to Canadian schools like McGill or University of Toronto. If you are Top-10 caliber, apply to Oxford or Cambridge. They are much more pure merit based in terms of admissions than top US colleges.

The closest merit based top school in the USA is Vanderbilt. The last time I looked on Naviance, about 3 years ago, it had pretty bright lines in terms of acceptance above a certain GPA and SAT range.

Top public US schools like UCLA, Berkeley, and Michigan are holistic but are prohibited from considering race, which may help the odds for many applicants. A downside is that the number of out of state students are capped.

I’d say, for the moment, set aside safety, match, reach. And hooks. Or ideas about applying some form of Early. You aren’t there yet, these decisions come after you explore and narrow down what sorts of schools interest her. I don’t think we know how young she is, her possible major or how her ECs connect. (Or if this is one child or more than one, with these concerns.)

Get something like the Fiske Guide to Colleges. It’s going to name names, give some descriptions, etc. She’ll need to learn/consider how distance or environment affects her, campus and student body sizes, LAC vs university. Discover which colleges offer her more variety and strength in her possible major interest area. What core curriculum requrements the colleges have versus other types. Plus which locations may offer more opportunity, to begin with. Eg, the pre-med needs the right local volunteer opportunities in the health field, while a govt major may want to be near centers of power, not off in the woods. And DO NOT left her fall in love with anything, at this point.

You look at stats ranges. Yes, roughly the 75th percentile for std testing. And top AP scores. Keep digging to learn more about what they look for in applicants, their criteria, not just your own. At some point, a list starts to form, “types” you can flourish at.

Again, the solution to a deficiency isn’t to try to make it up in some other category, for a T40. Especially not before you have any idea what makes a great essay. And are still left with an EC issue. Nor is it to just give up on T40s. There can be ways to fine tune or fix many deficiencies. But you need some understanding in order to recognize what the issues can be.

A comment on fit:

Our children are multifaceted, and so are the many schools to which they apply. My daughter can very persuasively tell you why she would do well at nearly all the schools on her list, and yet they are located in different regions of the country, of different sizes, and feature different cultures (eg Greek, athletics etc). They all have strong psychology and social sciences departments (a must) and are well known for their intelligent student bodies (although she tends to prefer the “work hard, play hard ethic” to the purely intellectual atmosphere).

I guess what I’m trying to say is that “fit” helps rule out some schools but it doesn’t necessarily narrow the field. And I imagine schools feel the same way about their applicant pools. Once you get beyond the stat filters, the “fit” question (which is subjective to begin with) is probably excluding a very small group. Yes, a few students will signal - through their essays, their interview or their recommenders - that they have no business attending Prestigious University X. But the rest will look just fine. -even fungible. And that’s the problem.

One last point: who my daughter is right now isn’t necessarily who she wants to be five years from now. Based on her background and contacts, you might conclude she’s a terrific fit for a northeastern LAC, but what she really wants to do is experience life in a larger setting and preferably another part of the country. That in and of itself can be an uphill battle - convincing someone that although you may not seem like the perfect fit now, you have a sincere interest in exposing yourself to new adventures. Some AO’s will welcome that mindset, but others will probably look upon it with skepticism.