Is it pointless these days for unhooked, high stat kids to apply to T40 schools?

The best chance for a ORM, average-excellent student to get into a T40 school is to have all of the stats, ECs, glowing recs, essays that show self-awareness and then FIT. Just because a student has high grades and scores does not mean they fit the school. AOs want to be able to see, from reading the app, how the student is going to participate on campus and how well they fit the culture of the school. Vanderbilt is not Dartmouth is not Brown is not Yale. I’ve only had one child go through the process but, looking back, I think the AOs who read his apps knew what they were doing and he was accepted to the schools that fit him best.

So, kids need to show that fit on their app. Visit the colleges if they can, interview if it’s offered, talk to current students, sit in on classes, read the websites, meet with the AOs if they come to their high school and ask questions. And then choose schools that fit what the student wants from their college experience. Yes, this is a ton of work. Hopefully, though, it narrows down the list to the schools where the student would fit the best and have the best chance at admission.

The final step is to show it in the app. The AOs do not know the kids personally. They only know what you (and your recommendations) say IN THE APPLICATION. Students should think about who they are and what they want the AO to know about them and get that into the application. Paint a clear picture. At least, if that is done well, then the student has put their real self out there for evaluation.

Most applicants will fit just fine at most schools. All colleges have very diverse entering classes now, and there is no stereotypical Yale student who is different than a Princeton student. In fact, many students apply to both, attend wherever admitted, and would be equally happy at the other.

@Auntlydia I think that true. A student who seems more likely to fit at a smaller, maybe rural school will have a harder time showing fit at a larger or urban T20 university. Knowing that could be an issue is the first step though. It needs to be addressed, either in the CA essay or in supplemental essays, that the student is looking for a certain environment for college and why. And she will need to be convincing.

Our suburban high school gets kids into places like Vandy, Duke, Dartmouth, Cornell but seems to have a tougher time (like really tough - no one gets in) to places like Barnard, Columbia, Yale, Brown. I could be oversimplifying it but I think those schools just aren’t convinced that even the best students from our super rigorous suburban Midwestern high school will fit in their more urban environments. They know their current students and just maybe they do know for real that kids from a school like ours might have a harder time thriving in the city environment.

And, sure, any given student can fit different types of schools. But that’s where the supplements come in. The student needs to show fit specifically for that school in the supplements.

In the end, even the best and brightest ORM candidates do not fit at every top school and I think that’s hard for them to understand. They are 18 and have many accomplishments behind them. There’s no “re-do”. The app is pretty much complete by the end of junior year except for the essays. A suburban student can’t go back and spend all summers in NYC working for The Times to show they love the city. They can’t go back and be a leader at some canoeing camp to show they love the outdoors. Their applications are almost fully cooked and they have what they have to show. They should work with what they’ve got and find schools that fit them, not the other way around. And then, like I said, show the fit in the application.

1 Like

I actually think the emphasis on fit leads to a lot of unnecessary anxiety. There is no perfect spouse, job, house, or college, and being adaptable to one’s surroundings is a skill to acquire. One might end up in a college for cost or other reasons, or in a city for job transfer-one really can learn to bloom where planted. In entire countries, tens of thousands of students attend the national or provincial university without analyzing fit, and thrive, even if they are from very different backgrounds.

@elena13 Thanks for the reminder.

From my post about the average excellent student:

Another last piece of obvious, but overlooked advice: colleges want to admit people they like! Be likable, be genuine, (this applies to the essay especially). Tell your kid to get recs from teachers who really like them, who they like in return.

Here is the post, which OP might find useful. http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/1878059-truthful-advice-about-getting-into-top-colleges-for-your-average-excellent-student-p1.html

@Lindagaf yes! Likeable is a good thing! I’ve heard AOs say they want to read an app and be able to tell that the candidate will be a good roommate.

Kids who get the best recs are the ones with strong relationships with teachers. So, parents with younger high school kids should keep that in mind. Of course kids shouldn’t get to know teachers just because they might write them a rec but to deepen their high school experience. A student who is quiet in class but gets perfect grades isn’t going to get much of a recommendation. Those kids should try to get to know teachers outside of class if they are shy in class. I have no proof but I think those recs make a big difference. I don’t know if you’ve all seen recommendation forms but most of them have the teacher rank the student from 1-10 on everything from leadership to grit to team player, etc… And then they get to write a letter to flush out the details. Kids need to choose teachers who will have enough positive material to write these recs well.

As for fit not being that important, that is probably true at the biggest universities, even the top ones like UVA or Michigan. Once you hit mid-sized university in the T20, I think the AOs are looking for fit. It doesn’t mean that they want all students to be a cookie cutter of each other. It means that they can “see” the student thriving on their campus in some way, shape, or form.

At the boarding school level, schools tend to admit kids who will thrive. They are 14. They know that a kid who is a bad fit for their school is going to be a lot of trouble for everyone. For the kid, the parents, the teachers, the dorm parents, etc. Mistakes at this age can be pretty traumatic and honestly, lots of applicants don’t understand what they are signing up for.
So that “fit” is really an assessment of “will this kid be happy getting what we offer?” The admissions office does it’s best on this.

Colleges expect you to figure out where you will thrive and be happy. To them, fit is “does this kid bring something to this community that we need/want?” As an applicant, that’s the fit you need to convey. Of course, if you talk about wanting to do something the school doesn’t offer, they will know you didn’t do your homework. In choosing schools, you need to figure out what environment you want, but the school doesn’t care if you want to spend your weekends at frat parties, climbing a nearby mountain, or watching Netflix in your room. The distinction is important.

@Homerdog I find it unlikely that the AO’s at Columbia and Barnard (who happen to draw heavily from our school, btw) are rejecting your school’s students on grounds that they lack fit. It seems far more likely that they simply have better, more established relationships with GC’s at other schools in your area whose students’ profiles aren’t that different from those who applied from your high school.

In my daughter’s case, we are mid-way through the process. A few nights ago, she was accepted to UT-Austin. As an OOS northeasterner, she was supremely excited - and surprised bc our high school rarely sends kids there. (Her GC is hopeful this is the beginning of a new trend). Do I believe this is because she demonstrated a special fit? That would be nice, but I’m dubious that she showed any more fit for Texas than she did for Vanderbilt, which rejected her in the ED1 round. She had as compelling a narrative for Vandy as she did for Texas. (I trust our GC on this one as he’s a big fan and he read her app). And that’s where chance and subjectivity play a role. The issue isn’t whether my daughter can productively contribute to the school’s culture. She’s shown she can do that. The issue is whether there are 20, 40 or 400 people just like her. In real life my daughter is a unique, fascinating person. On paper, she’s a fungible widget (albeit an Average Excellent one).

@OceanIsle - I think you are on the right track. Frankly, coming up with Likely/Safety schools that your daughter would be happy to attend is more than half the battle. Too many students build their list from the top down, then feel crushed when they have to attend one from the bottom of their list. I think it is often the parents fault, bringing them to schools without a realistic shot of admittance. Fall in love with a safety, then look around at reaches with the expectation that they probably won’t work out. Very best of luck to her!

No, it’s, “Show, not just tell.” Don’t wast precious real estate in the app or supps “telling” them why you fit. It will either show or not. (You will either know what shows this or maybe you need to rethink.)

It’s simply not the point of the essay. Other things need to be conveyed there. This is one issue with the anecdotes. We may not truly know how our kids came cross in the written portions and assume some special use or process or savvy that wasn’t what it was, at all. Meanwhile, it appears we’re dishing out secret recipes. And assurances.

At the big public U level, of course they care less about individual personality profiles. They’ll put together a vast class of different sorts. It’s when you get past that to schools that are more vested in their individual differences, as colleges, that it becomes more important. Columbia and NYU need kids who can thrive in NYC. But they are distinctly NOT looking for kids who explain they want to go there because it’s “the City.” Again, you aren’t applying to the the City, but a particular college. Know what that school is about.

And a generic app (as if any college in location X or with certain recreation or classes will do it,) isn’t going to cut it, for the more competitive colleges. They won’t accept you because you want to be a doctor and “Your college is strong in premed.” They’re looking at your 4 year experience and that community.

Fine by me, if you want to take the attitde that any college will do it. But that’s not what adcoms are looking for, in the more instense holistic processes.

As well, you can be the nicest kid on earth and, if you don’t match, show the strengths and traits the adcoms identify in their communities, why should they accept you? There are lots of nice kids out there.

“In the end, even the best and brightest ORM candidates do not fit at every top school and I think that’s hard for them to understand.”

It may be hard for them to understand if they get into Yale and Princeton but not Harvard or into MIT and Cal Tech but not Stanford. They don’t know the substantial preference Harvard gives to athletes and legacies and Stanford to first-gens and URMs. They know that these groups get some preference.

Also adcoms are going to get things wrong, they’re human, so if you think they’re perfect in their decision making (i.e. no biases) then you’re assigning them an almost divine like infallibility. Doctors are the most trained professionals in the world, and they get 7 or 8 out of 10 right, so adcoms getting about 6 right would seem reasonable. Now they do get more than one review, but if both adcoms reading your app are getting the same marching orders (urm, geo diversity), you’re going to get the same result.

"But they are distinctly NOT looking for kids who explain they want to go there because it’s “the City.”

Well there was a quote from an admitted student from Nebraska, in a Columbia brochure that said I fell in love with NYC and knew Columbia was right, basically based on that. You can get away with that if you’re from Nebraska, but not if you’re from San Francisco, LA, Boston, or Chicago.

@Data10 clarified the apparent contradiction for me in #129. So back to the topic at hand.

On CC there are long lists of kids who fit in the “bright, accomplished kids with no hook” category who have been accepted into a T-40 school. In fact the “my high stats kid didn’t get into any of the T-40 (T-20/T-50/etc) colleges to which they applied” are rare enough that they attract a long list of kind posters who come to comfort and support such posters, as well as explain that this happens, etc.

@Data10 is correct above in stating that there is a major difference between the small list of colleges with >10%/7% acceptance rates, and about which kids and parents obsess, and the rest of the colleges from whatever “top-Colleges” are on the lists from USWNR or Forbes.

For example, UMichigan or GTech are top schools, yet the acceptance rates at these school for in-state applicants is such that bright kids from Michigan or Georgia, respectively, would have a decent shot at these colleges. There are also pretty good chances at acceptance for kids with high stats at colleges such as WashU or CMU, with acceptance rates in the teens. By “good chances”. I means something like more than one in three high stats highly accomplished kids who apply are accepted.

I would also agree that there is a big difference between T40 and T10 schools, not only in terms of acceptance rate but in terms of percentage of hooked admits. I learned from a Princeton AO that their hooked was as much as 70% of the admits—thats ALDC+FGLI+URM. As it does down in its ranking a school’s unhooked admit ratio goes up quite quickly. So, for the unhooked, the effective acceptance rate at T10 school could be as low as 2-3%.

When you are applying to those lottery schools you don’t consider fit, neither do these schools. The only way to have a chance is simply applying there. But the overall number of admits from each geographical area is consistent year over year. Say for Princeton, out of 1900 some offers, roughly 600 will go to the unhooked, and that’s about 12 kids per state for a medium sized state. If a kid is not even a top female applicant in the whole school district its unlikely she would be the top six in the state, thus it may be pointless to play the lottery.

I can think of plenty of colleges that are not very diverse in some dimension.

If restricted to “top whatever”, many of them have very skewed SES distributions relative to either college students overall or the general population overall.

Yes, different T40 colleges have different admission systems and different applicant pools, which can lead to very different degrees of diversity. For example, Caltech typically only has ~3 African American students per class. In some years, they have no AA women. URM racial diversity is very poor.

At the time of the NYT linked SES diversity study at https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/college-mobility/washington-university-in-st-louis , the majority of WUSTL families were from top 5% income, 16% were from bottom 80% families, and <1% were from bottom 20% families. SES diversity was very poor. They have taken steps to improve SES diversity since then, but still have more issues than most other selective privates.

" if they get into Yale and Princeton but not Harvard or into MIT and Cal Tech but not Stanford."

But a strong point here is that these are NOT all the same schools. Would you invest the time into learning about and matching yourself to one of these and then assume no further exploration is needed for the rest? Like, “Hey, if I can match myself to Stanford, I’m fine for Yale?”

This thread now has two approaches. Those speaking of your best app and those speaking of numbers. When it comes down to your own desire to be admitted, I hope you learn enough to present your best, that you know what that is, and don’t get foiled by the emphasis on percentages and categories.

Because no matter how much “you don’t consider fit,” of course “these schools” do. They aren’t throwing darts. They want the ones they want. It’s up to you to figure out what that is, for you, for your shot, regardless of category. Ignore it at your own peril. No guarantees. But why put out of half effort? If you’re that dispassionate, why not save yourself the time?

“But why put out of half effort?”

None of these kids put out half effort, and thought if they matched one, the others would follow. They were waitlisted at Stanford, where 2% of the applicants get on the wait list. 2400 get in, 700 get on the waitlist, that’s it, those are the top 3100 at Stanford. They would not wait list someone with a half effort app. Similar for the kid that got into Yale, Princeton and the Harvard waitlist.

Updating for the OP since I said I would. D20 got into UNC today. It can be done!

Regarding fit, I do think the way that colleges view fit is different than the way a lot of applicants view fit. Kids may look at fit as big vs small, urban vs suburban, Greek life vs non. Ad coms probably not really considering that. They are looking to build a diverse and well rounded class with a little of this and a little of that. They are looking more at what you will bring to campus than what you will get out of campus. A college who values service will look for kids who value service, colleges with an honor code look for kids who embrace that, colleges that value curiosity look for that etc. And I think it is not likely at all that urban schools are looking at suburban kids and saying they aren’t going to fit in a city environment, because virtually every school wants geographic diversity. Fit is important on both sides, but it is viewed by a different lens for each side.

Another possible tip/hook is going to an elite high school. This is speculative because colleges aren’t transparent about their admissions practices. However, there was at least one study which found going to an elite high school improved admissions odds.