School advantage is like being full pay. We know it’s there but we don’t like to admit it. Both of my siblings send their kids to traditional top suburban schools. The Great Schools 10, tons of APs, top sports, etc. We sat down and compared Naviance scattergrams and it was obvious. My kid’s school, by luck of a job transfer, doubled the chance for a high stats kid to get into an elite school.
I believe this is because schools analyse the data side of the application and like the predictions from my kid’s school. The advantage was mostly in ED, so I think it’s about locking in certain characteristics. Maybe it’s graduation rate and avg GPA or maybe it’s % that are full pay.
My favorite example is ED at Northwestern. If the applicant has a 1510 or above and a top GPA with rigor(you can see this in the weighted GPA), 100% get in ED. RD is the usual hit or miss, but ED was 100% for high stats kids.
The hook being from an elite high school or prep school has to do with those kids generally being very well prepared for college. College admissions at tops schools is first and foremost about finding kids who can do the challenging work . Colleges know that at some (not all) of the elite high schools that there are not easy A’s, that courses are rigorous and kids have the skills to succeed.
That’s not saying that kids from non-elite high schools are not prepared and can’t succeed at a top school - of course they can. But at the top high schools even those in the middle of the pack can get into a top school
This may have to do with such schools having well connected knowledgeable dedicated college counselors who have a good idea of what each elite college is looking for, so that they will steer students to applying to those elite colleges that see them as good fits. I.e. “finding the match” is handed to the students instead of the students having to find it themselves like those at other schools have to do.
Yes, some students in other schools “find the match” or (probably more likely) happen to hit the match to the college by accident with their well made applications, but that does not make the playing field anywhere close to level like is sometimes implied.
In addition, at those elite high schools, there are other advantages, such as better college prep counseling starting early (rather than realizing in 11th or 12th grade that the school’s advice that foreign language is not needed is incorrect, an actual example from these forums) and teachers who will write high quality recommendations and counselors who will tell the student which teachers will be best for that student’s applications.
So, whether or not there is a specific admission preference for students from elite high schools, there are other significant college admission advantages that students get for their parents’ tuition money.
And they still have to match. You shouldn’t imagine just going to an elite prep is all it takes.
But, back to OP. Why not explore whether there are T40 colleges (T20-60) where your child does match or seems headed to. There’s no shortcut to just naming a tier and either flooding it or jumping past.
If he or she has an issue with limited ECs, learn and be realistic about what those holistic colleges expect. Then, either work on the issue or consider the many colleges that aren’t holistic, that primarily look at stats and scores.
@alwaysmoving And, at our Chicago suburban school, kids with high GPA and over a 1510 get into NU at a rate of 1/10. Maybe 20 kids apply ED with those stats and two/three get in and they are almost always legacies. So, yes, where you go to school matters! NU used to take 8-10 in ED/RD but told our GCs a few years back that they won’t be taking as many kids from the Chicago area.
I definitely think going to a school that has a good relationship with a certain college can help, since that college probably has a better understanding of your school’s rigor. For example, out of the ~30 kids who applied to Brown from my public school last year, 6 were accepted. Same thing with Northeastern and BU; the acceptance rate from my school is much higher than usual. On the other hand, in my school’s Naviance history, no one has ever been accepted to UPenn (despite the applicants having very similar stats as those accepted to Brown). Obviously, there could still be other factors, but I think that just goes to show that where you go to school does have significance.
My theory is applicants demonstrate their fit in two ways. There is fit from their essays/ECs/recommendations, and then there is fit from their stats/data.
@wisteria100 I mostly agree with your post, but I don’t think Adcoms are looking for a balanced, well-rounded class. They are looking for their type of student. If Duke values service, they are going to choose a class which is heavily weighted toward service - I don’t think they will try to balance the class with students who ,for instance, show great intellectually curiosity but don’t have a demonstrated service background.
GC’s at private schools probably have a better sense of what these schools want than public school GC’s (ours have 600ish kids to deal with, and 90% of their time is spent on keeping kids in school and helping first gens understand our college system) so that probably gives those kids a slight advantage (if they are willing to listen to the GC!).
This is the myth that elites use to pass down advantages to their offspring. There’s about 35000 high schools in the US and we’re supposed to believe there’s only a few hundred which adequately prepare students to handle the coursework. Besides, the Ivies, unlike Caltech or MIT, aren’t known for particularly difficult grading.
I have yet to see evidence that there actually is a direct hook for attending a “elite” HS. There are certainly a larger number of admits from “elite” HSs, but that is not the same thing as saying attending a “elite” HS is a hook that increases chance of admission. Instead I’d expect the larger number of admits from “elite” HSs primarily relates to the following 3 factors.
"Elite" HSs tend to have a higher concentration of high achieving students. This is especially true of highly selective "elite" HSs. For example, Andover/Exteter/... type selective HSs often average a 98th+ percentile SAT among their student body. Non-selective HSs often have 2% or less of the student body achieving a similarly high test score. A much larger portion of the student body at "elite" HSs is academically qualified.
The vast majority of high school students do not apply to any "elite" colleges. This is particularly true of high achieving students who are lower income (see https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/2013a_hoxby.pdf ). Most HSs in the US average <= 1 Harvard application per year. A few of the most "elite" private HSs in the NE have over 100 applicants. High achieving students who apply to "elite" HSs are far more likely to also apply to "elite" colleges than the overall high achieving student population.
Students attending "elite" HSs tend to have a much higher rate of ALDC hooks than the overall population. These hooks can give a powerful admissions advantage at many "elite" colleges.
But you should not pretend that the elite well connected prep school is not a large advantage in helping you find the match and optimize your application to show your match to that college (assuming that it is one of the colleges that the counselors are familiar and/or connected with).
Ucb, OP noted Top 40. I think your comments hold, but it’s not a giant endeavor to look into 40 schools. Fewer, really, since many won’t fit the basics (location, some majors, etc.)
No question, elites have skilled GCs. And they cultivate the right EC opportunities, etc. But I think some posters make the assumption any possible advantages become certainties re: admits. We can’t say that.
@Homeschooler14 There are colleges which select purely on “academic accomplishments.” “Rack and stack,” not holistic. You’ll find plenty. But even that’s hard to define. 4.0 with easy classes? (Is that “fair?”) A transcript stuffed with AP, even meaningless ones? An assumption high school and college are ONLY about classes and homework? How would you distinguish among 20,000 4.0 kids for a few thousand spots?
Meanwhile, the private colleges get to choose the class they wish. It’s their game. And it’s wrong to assume kids get in simply because Daddy went there or whatever you think. Kids are vetted. Lots of threads arguing both sides of this issue.
Perhaps you’ll get a chance to explore more deeply, check some of your own assumptions, while looking into your choices where to apply.
But there’s one thread only, where posters get to gripe about what you think is unfair with selection processes or affirmative action. This isn’t it.
This varies by school. At least a couple of the info sessions we attended specifically said they look for balanced/well rounded/variety of backgrounds to contribute, etc, including the T30 that my (unhooked, average stats) D19 got into. Some were more specific about particular attributes- you mention service, this is something that was highlighted at the Georgetown info session. So again… fit matters.
The study found the following characteristics were associated with the highest chance of admission after full controls (table 3). I am comparing to an unhooked White male at a reference HS that is public averages >1.5 AP exams per student.
The 1.1x “odds ratio” multiplier* for attending an “elite” HS is nowhere near any of the hook categories. It’s far less of an advantage than the study found for being female. Considering the increased chance for being female and that the study only explained 19% of variance in admissions decisions, it is clear that they are missing some key variables. This is not evidence of an “elite” HS hook any more than it is evidence that being female is a hook. The author actually suggests the opposite effect from attending a selective “elite” HS in the abstract, as quoted below:
“A given applicant’s chances of being accepted are reduced if he or she comes from a high school with relatively more highly talented students, that is, if the applicant is a small frog in a big pond.”
Epenshade Study: “Odds Ratio” For Admission to “Academic Selective” Colleges*
Athlete Hook; 6.5x
URM Hook: 3.3x to 5.7x
Legacy Hook: 3.0x
HS has average of 0 AP exams per student: 2.1x
HS has average of 0 to 0.4 AP exams per student: 1.8x
Being Female: 1.5x
HS has average of 0.4 to 0.8 AP exams per student: 1.4x
HS is private HS: 1.4x
HS is religious HS: 1.1x HS is among “elite” 72 HSs: 1.1x
*The study calls these “odds ratios”, but they appear to be multipliers rather than odds ratios.
Selective prep schools look like they have an advantage, but their students are prescreened. Virtually all are in the top 10% of standardized test takers, they are achievement oriented (no stoners at all (not to say there aren’t kids who like to get high, but there is no social group of slackers). Combine that with great college counseling, highly educated parents, and of course you get “better” admissions statistics.
Having said that, top colleges are really wanting that top scoring, bright kid who has done amazing things/overcome adversity-- but from a public school in Appalachia. The fact that a kid comes from a prep school by itself confers absolutely no admissions advantage.
If you watch all the YouTube videos of ex adcoms talking about admissions procedures it becomes pretty clear that elite hs status is not, by itself, a hook.
Back to OP’s original question. The direct answer is yes. An unhooked student can get into a top school. However, his/her chances are impacted by the consideration of various hooks by the top colleges with holistic admissions. The degree of advantages enjoyed by hooked applicants vary by the colleges (a few top colleges don’t even consider some or all of the hooks). The more advantages a hooked applicant enjoys, the less likely an unhooked applicant will be admitted to the same college. That’s just simple math.
On the question of whether “elite” HS students enjoy an advantage, the answer is probably yes, but less so than it used to be. “Elite” HSs tend to have better reputation with some of the top colleges, often better counseling (especially the privates), generally better teachers, etc. But some of the very top “elite” HSs also suffer from some disadvantages as well for their unhooked students: a) no top college wants to accept too many student from a single HS; and b) an unhooked student at an “elite” HS may have to compete with higher number of legacy applicants to the same top college s/he wants to attend.
Closing thread. The discussion has turned to debate and a discussion of politics and Affirmative Action, neither allowed here. At this point, everyone seems to have been able to put in their 2 cents anyway.