Is it to one's advantage to apply SCEA as a URM?

<p>Hello! I applied early to Harvard, and I am half black so I guess I would be considered a URM. Harvard has always been my dream school, and for me there was never even a question over whether I wanted to apply early or regular decision. However, my mom was recently talking to a family friend who is a college counselor at another school and she said that it is to my advantage that I applied early because I have good credentials and I’m a URM. Is this true? I am not sure what she really meant by it, or if she was just trying to be supportive. But if it is true, then why?</p>

<p>SCEA works to your advantage if you have outstanding credentials – that’s true if you are a URM or not. If you have so-so credentials as a URM, Harvard will most likely defer you to the RD round, as they will want to compare you with the rest of the applications pool. So, it really depends on many factors.</p>

<p>Here’s what William Fitzsimmons said about last years SCEA admitted students: [Let</a> the admissions begin | Harvard Gazette](<a href=“http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2011/12/early-action/]Let”>Let the admissions begin – Harvard Gazette)</p>

<p>“Given increases in our overall applicant numbers over the past few years to nearly 35,000 last year, the Admissions Committee took great care to admit only those we were certain would be admitted in Regular Action,” said Fitzsimmons.”</p>

<p>Gibby, how come SCEA helps those with outstanding credentials? From the Fitzsimmons quote you cited, it sounds like everyone has better (or the same) chances in the regular round.</p>

<p>My D had strong stats (2300+ SAT, 34+ ACT, 750+ SAT IIs, URM) and was accepted. Her very good friend (also URM) had nearly identical stats and was deferred then rejected (though she is attending another HYP). I have no clue why my D was accepted and her friend was not. I do believe her essays and recommendations were strong, but her friend’s may have been also. It definitely was not the ECs, as my D did not have many (though she had a varsity sport that she played year-round). You’ll know soon in any event. Very best of luck to you.</p>

<p>Thank you! I am not sure where she was getting this from then.</p>

<p>I don’t disagree with your family friend/counselor. I think it helped that my D was considered in a pool of 4500+ instead of a pool of 35000+. I just don’t think it’s a slam dunk for URMs applying SCEA, as some seem to believe. And I agree with gibby that outstanding credentials are a must, URM or not.</p>

<p>Couldn’t agree more: there is no slam dunk for URMs. And it is beyond risky for URMs to proceed in the application process based on the myth that URM status trumps most other factors.</p>

<p>This year in particular will be no walk in the park for any race. The Harvard article said something like 20+ percent increases in Native American and African American applicants.</p>

<p>Yeah, I agree. But just to clarify, I personally applied early because Harvard is my first choice, not because I thought I’d have a better chance now than RD.</p>

<p>“This year in particular will be no walk in the park for any race. The Harvard article said something like 20+ percent increases in Native American and African American applicants.”</p>

<p>I don’t think the increase in AA and NA applications will affect the chances of a qualified non-URM of getting in. The percentage of admitted AA’s will probably remain around 12%. The only difference will be that they’re more qualified than in years past. At least that’s what I’m project.</p>