Is it unethical of my school that............

<p>Hi,</p>

<p>My school used to have a program that engineering students with 3.2 GPA at the end completion of junior year will be guranteed admission to grad school.
It is a 4+1 5year BS/MS program. We were told about this program from the stuff in the engineering school when we starts college. And many students choose this the school because of this. </p>

<p>However, just last semester, one of my friends applied for the program and was told the program has been altered. 3.2 GPA no longer gurantee admission, GRE might gains advantages to admssion, and requires rec letters.</p>

<p>Right now, the new program is not yet publically anounced. Most students don’t know about it. I think someone gonna get screwed up pretty badly when they realize the program been changed.</p>

<p>What do you guys think?</p>

<p>Thanks,</p>

<p>-AUSCGUY</p>

<p>May I ask which school it is?</p>

<p>…a usc guy…? My guess is it’s USC…!</p>

<p>Anyhow. Do you have this old program in writing, or was it just sort of… an unspoken thing? If you guys have the old program in writing, then it’d be a lot easier to go to the administration and appeal that though the new program is changing, that your class and the others who are currently in the engineering program ought to be grandfathered under the old program, and after you guys graduate, then it should change…</p>

<p>Good luck… Sounds kinda like a bum deal, but this sort of thing unfortunately happens all the time in the academic world.</p>

<p>Yes, your guess is right. </p>

<p>I have the old program in writing. It is not an unskopen thing. </p>

<p>Before I decided to attend the school, I attend an accepted-student tour to the school of engineering. We have the director of admission(who is in charge of both undergrad and grad) told the ENTIRE accepted prospect engr. students, along with the parents, that there is a 4+1 program. It was a MAJOR selling point since my school’s grad program is pretty good. And it certainly attracted many students. </p>

<p>I really feel like we are been fooled to attend the school.</p>

<p>I don’t think its unethical unless they deceived you on purpose, which it doesn’t sounds like they did. As long as they are telling new imcoming students what the new requirements are, I think it is alright.</p>

<p>Yes, but they’re going back on their original promises at the time of admission. They sold them a bill of goods and then failed to deliver. They can tell new students what the new requirements are, but I think that the students that were there already really should be grandfathered under the old policy…</p>

<p>well, I am already a junior now, even too late to transfer</p>

<p>Yup. Definitely talk with your advisor, and get a group of you guys together and try to talk to the dean of students, or the student affairs administrator, or whoever the person in charge of students is at USC, and try to find out a) whether or not it is their current intention that you’ll be grandfathered by the old policy, and then if you guys won’t be, b) whether or not you would be able to be grandfathered by this policy.</p>

<p>This is bogus. You’re not imagining things, it’s really a bum deal, and they’re being asshats about it. Be polite and proactive, get everything (EVERYTHING!) in writing if and when the administrators agree to let you guys continue on, and have the written policy with you when you go to meet with anyone, but don’t walk away from this one without a fight, if it’s the difference between going to graduate school and not going to graduate school.</p>

<p>Good luck!</p>

<p>I’d fight for it.</p>

<p>this year i took the accepted engineering students tour at USC (and am now attending). it wasn’t necessarily a selling point for me, but the 4+1 program seemed really nice. on more than one occasion they said a 3.2 was necessary to apply, but i don’t really remember them saying it guaranteed acceptance. it was just a requirement for consideration. </p>

<p>i may be wrong (i’m still new to the college thing), but it seems like if everyone who had a 3.2 in engineering was guaranteed acceptance to the program, i think the graduate program would be overwhelmed with too many students.</p>

<p>-aibarr
Thanks so much for your suggestion! But I am kind of worry if I get blacklisted. </p>

<p>-phobos
The new program requires 3.2 in order to apply. The old one gurnatees.
It may not be a big selling program for you because now it is not guranteed.
The specific rules of the old program was printed on the university catalogue.</p>

<p>Here is exactly what it says:
"The 4+1 Program offers qualified students the oppounity to stimulataneously complete the requirements for the B.S. and M.S. degrees in five years. Students are eligible for the 4+1 Program upon completing 96 or more units toward their B.S. with a GPA of 3.2 or higher. Qualified students who are interested should see their advisor in their junior year to begin planning for the inclusion of graduate program in the fall of their seniot year. Eligible students will be automatically accepted to the M.S. program without needing to take the GRE. All requirements for both B.S. and M.S. degrees must be met; however, up to six units of course work will be counted toward satisfying the unit requirements of both programs. Application information may be obtained in the School of Engineering Office of Aadmission and Students Affaits. Students should see their departmental for assistance with course selection. "</p>

<p>did you even talk to matthew opray in RTH 110? Go ask him what you can do, before you jump to conclusions (unless you’ve already talked with him, I guess)</p>

<p>i alreay emailed him about it, asking him a good number of quesitons about the new program before the end of the last semester. I also have a freind who went to see him face to face.</p>

<p>…and? Did he respond?</p>

<p>You can read about the new program in the 2006/07 catalogue. It doesn’t require the GRE at all, I think, and as for the 2 letters of recommendation, I would certainly hope that in 3 years at USC there would be 2 professors who had a positive impression enough to write a letter.</p>

<p>It may be unethical however, Do you want to compete in a new environment where the GPA is much higher, where seniors are told not to bother in studing for GRE, and accomplishments are wows. ??</p>