Is my College List too Top Heavy?

Hi, I was refining my list of colleges and I just wanted to make sure that my list wasn’t too top heavy. I’m IS for VA and my stats are:

SAT: 1540
Math ii (projected): 800
Chem (projected): 800
Rank: Top 5%
Major: Biomedical Engineering or Data Science depends school by school

ECs:
EMT at fire dept
Worked at hospital (paid)
Interned at local University in bioinformatics
Interned at world-renowned research institution in bioinformatics (paid)
Organized 200+ person hackathon
Teach class to elementary age kids about STEM
Debate national qualifier (ranked top 40 in nation and 8th in state)
Won multiple debate tournaments (regional)
Debate captain

The programs with “(med)” are a special grad program I am applying to within the school (but I am considered for the undergrad program regardless of the grad school decision).

Also, it would be great if someone could confirm that the schools on this list do truly fit into the category I placed them in (reach, match, safety).

Reach:
Northwestern(Med)
CMU
JHU
Duke
Penn

Brown (med)

Rice (med)

Match:
Gtech
UVA
Umich
BU (med)

Safety:
VCU (med)
PSU (med)
Upitt (med)
George Washington(med)

Thanks so much for your help!

I think your list is quite apt! Great work!

OOS acceptance rate to UMich is 19% or slightly less. You will either apply to LSA or CoE for Biomedical Engineering or Data Science. The CoE would be slightly more difficult in terms of admission, since there are far less enrollment spots in the class.

The two most important factors in terms of considering your app for UMich are uwGPA and course rigor, class rank isn’t considered, so while the 1,540 and EC’s are outstanding, even a uwGPA of 4.0 would still mean UMich is a REACH for all OOS.

I’ve brought up this example several times before to illustrate, but a CC member has a son who applied to UMich with a 4.0/1,600, was deferred EA, then waitlisted and rejected. The S went to CalTech, so stats alone aren’t enough at UMich.

I cannot comment on the other colleges. Good luck!

@sushiritto
Thanks for the response; I initially planned on applying for BME, but because of the ease of switching schools (LSA to CoE), I decided to apply Data Science (and because I love Umich’s DS program more than their BME).

Also, my sister currently attends Umich, and had similar stats/ECs - I’ll have to check if they consider this (family).

My uwGPA is unfortunately around 3.85… I go to a pretty rigorous school but I was hoping they would see (via my class rank) the rigor. Good point though.

Thank you!

Yes, but you would have to achieve a GPA of 2.5 taking some rigorous courses at UM. Sounds easy, but I’m told you can typically expect a large drop in GPA from HS in these courses.

https://www.engin.umich.edu/admissions/undergrad/cross-campus-students/admissions/

I think having your sister already attending UMich helps, possibly, with the “demonstrated interest” category of admissions. But “demonstrated interest” is just “considered” per the UMich CDS.

Having said that, I did have a long back and forth via PM’s with a Class of 2023 parent who already had a kid at UMich, but the younger kid was deferred in EA, then rejected late in RD. And ultimately decided to attend Wisconsin. So, there’s obviously no guarantee with your sister being there. I still wouldn’t call it a “match.”

As you may know, the average GPA for the Class of 2023 is 3.9. So, your 3.85 is competitive.

BTW, with UVa in-state, I’m not sure why you would want to go to UMich. UVa will be cheaper and a similarly great education without the bad winters. :smiley:

GT also favors instate, and out of state is less than 20%. Your “why GT” essay would have to be really compelling, as I have seen top students get deferred and denied. Though your EC’s look like they could help .

UVA and W&M are excellent in-state options, so it’s hard to justify Michigan and Georgia Tech at out-of-state prices (or any other public university, for that matter).

The same goes for the expensive private colleges on your list barring substantial financial aid. Have you run the EFC calculators? Medical school is quite expensive, and it’s best to keep undergraduate debt to a minimum.

I recommend adding at least one small(ish) college to your list, though it will be hard to find a liberal arts college that offers BME or Data Science. You could probably snag some decent merit aid from a good liberal arts college like Rhodes or Furman.

List looks good. Like the debate experiences.

I’d bet you’ll get into a Reach. Go for it!

The bs md programs are all reaches. No safeties there because of the program. Maybe targets. It’s so hard in that category.

Pitt bs md program is more selective than brown pleme and the others. I think they take 10 students a year.

@privatebanker
Thanks for your reply!
Yeah, I totally understand the insane competitiveness of bsmds, but because I can get admitted into the university while still being rejected from the actual bsmd program (eg I can get into Upitt undergrad while still being rejected from upitt gap), I considered them safeties because the scope of this post is referring to the undergrad, not the actual program.

@sushiritto
All of my family lives in MI, so I’d like to potentially go there bc of that.

@warblersrule
Although I am applying for BSMDS, I’m not sure I want to pursue medicine in the future (I’m also interested in a PhD) so med school isn’t necessarily a built in cost rn.

Also, I’d be willing to take out loans of up to $100K and my parents can pay a little, but nowhere near something like CMUs $70K/yr, so I’ll need significant aid, so that’s def something to consider.

Great point, though, thanks for your advice.

@statisticsandml well that makes sense. Thank you.

Ah. I agree if you take out the smaller programs and look at the whole. Solid list. I would gladly go to any you have listed.

If you’re talking about $100K in loans for undergraduate programs, that probably won’t fly (unless your parents are willing to take out a home equity loan, or something like that). There are strict limits on federal student loans. $31K total for dependent students.
https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/types/loans/subsidized-unsubsidized

In addition, having a lot of undergraduate debt going into medical school would just make your total debt after medical school even larger. Would you really want to start practicing medicine with $400,000 or more in debt?

If you apply to the BA/MD program at Boston University and are denied you will not be considered for regular undergraduate admission.

Your first step should be to run the Net Price Calculator on each of their websites for a financial aid estimate.

Congratulations on truly excellent work. Your ECs are outstanding (and interesting - which is also important). There’s no doubt you’ll get into a fine program. Just realize, as I’m sure you do, there will be many stellar candidates at all these programs, especially at your matches and reaches. Are you capable of doing well at any of them? I’m sure you are. Many would describe admissions at top schools to be a crap shoot where there are just too many qualified candidates for spots. So luck will play a role too.

Although you didn’t ask about cost, discuss this with your parents to get the most realistic picture of what’s doable. Merit aid at these top schools is a whole different level of competition. Fine to shoot for it, but have alternatives in mind. Leave room for flexibility (MD vs PhD - most PhD programs are funded so totally different scenario than med school).

Best of luck and please let us know where you land. You kids do amazing things today!

@rickle1
Thanks for the vote of confidence and reality check. I’ll let you guys know!