For most real world students and their families, the top criteria are (1) is it affordable? and (2) does it have the desired or possible majors of interest?
@ucbalumnus yes your absolutely correct, for most the first question is affordability. For those who have no concern there, its prestige, academics, or both.
Areas of study (for 1NJKid, one area of interest is unavailable in almost all colleges at the undergraduate level); Curriculum and course rigors; People (professors, fellow students, etc., especially in the areas of interest).
The latter two are often seen as proxies for prestige, and the last one, if it means such things as admission selectivity, is what much of prestige is based on.
I don’t agree with that characterization. Neither course rigors nor the quality of people are necessarily the results of prestige, which is mostly associated with rankings these days. Should they imply prestige? Perhaps, but the implication doesn’t work in the other direction (i.e. they aren’t guaranteed by prestige).
Curriculum and course rigors; People (professors, fellow students, etc., especially in the areas of interest).
Proxy for prestige? I don’t think so. Missouri S&T is plenty rigorous in most of the engineering disciplines, with fabulous faculty and students. Not a proxy for prestige at all. Rutgers for philosophy, poli sci or math? Plenty rigorous, not a proxy for prestige. Anthropology at Beloit? History at Earlham? And most of the Catholic colleges for Classics or philosophy (not just “the prestigious ones” like Notre Dame and Georgetown).
I’ve also got a list of allegedly “prestigious” places which are either somewhat or totally overrated… but I’ll keep that to myself. I’ve done enough hiring and recruiting from various colleges and universities across the country to realize where there is sizzle but no steak…
Academics, fit, affordability and prestige are top factors. I don’t care too much about major as most kids change majors or later go to graduate/professional school. An overall comprehensive undergrad education at a smaller, vibrant, nurturing and inclusive college is more important.