Is this too risque/heavy for an essay?

I’ve been thinking about the essay I’m going to write for my Amherst application and I would like some suggestions. I’m applying as a first-year, because my CC grades aren’t good enough to be reported.

I am a multiracial URM, below the poverty line individual, and it’s been almost 3 years since I graduated High School. I’ve had a pretty ridiculously stressful but eye-opening set of experiences since then.

I’ll give a brief summary of these and I want feedback as to which I should focus on in my essay, as it is probably too much to recount. Or, alternatively, if I should focus on something else entirely.

Summary:

At the tail end of my senior year, I was trying to apply to college amidst several stressful family events. Days before my birthday that year (in the fall), my mom tried to commit suicide. A month or so later at Christmastime, my dear grandmother began a severe decline in her health. At that time, I was really stressed and depressed and generally worried for the future, and reluctantly decided to go to community college, after all my top college apps were rejected that spring. I would have been the first in four generations to attend college in my family, and the pressure and stress was undeniable. I felt like an absolute failure. I struggled through community college, but still walked away with all A’s and one C during my first year. The next Christmas though, my grandmother passed from this world. I was so numb from the overall experience, and my second year in addition to working full-time, I kind of blew it. I had always been fairly spiritual, but my grandmother’s death made me question everything. I was a passionate writer before her passing, and after, I couldn’t even bear to pick up a pen, or even read. It made me feel too much.

I was still a mostly A student, but I failed a class, and had to withdraw from 3 classes between two semesters. I had never failed a class before, or even gotten a C in high school, and I felt like more of a failure than ever before. I had also started working full-time, and had one to two demanding jobs during different points in the year, and was struggling not to get kicked out by my (slightly recovered) mom and her husband. On top of this, I was also dealing with an awful series of my first relationships, being the president of one club in my college and an officer in another, and all of it together was just too much.

I woke up one day and just decided that I needed to be better. I was someone who was supposed to be a leader- I had younger siblings who needed me, a whole group of people that I was supposed to lead at my school, and myself. I needed to be strong, and being strong isn’t being stubborn to change. Everything wasn’t in my control, and that was okay. But I was making poor decisions with the control I did have, and that wasn’t okay. But regardless, I shouldn’t forever live in regret and mourning. I have a life and I should live it! I hadn’t cried in years, not even when my grandmother passed. I just let the flood gates go and became a new person. I cried until I thought my eyes were going to bleed.

After this, I got a better job. I cut off toxic friends and relationships. I started taking my health into consideration, and discovered a passion for cooking, like grandmother once had. I retook the classes I made poor grades in, and have gotten mostly A’s and one B in the others I’ve taken since. I’ve since been able to write again, even if it was painful at first. I also met the love of my life, someone who was not at all who I expected. I am happy.

And nothing worked out the way I had planned.

I know that others in my same situation may have made better things come out of it. They may have still been able to succeed in the midst of all the stress and despair. Maybe I could have as well. But I don’t ask those questions anymore. I’ve felt many tumultuous emotions throughout these past three years: grief, fear, numbness, pain, self-pity, heartbreak, betrayal. But even more importantly, I’ve felt love, compassion, kindness, understanding, and exhilaration, just from living. And now, more than ever, I find myself ready to take this world head on.

I’m not perfect, and I’m not the best. But if I have learned anything these past three years, I’ve learned that being perfect isn’t character. I don’t need to be the best, just me. Success without challenges isn’t success, it’s just mimicry, monotony, and expected. Well I’m not expected. I am extraordinary, because I have faced monsters and come out stronger.

One question I used to ask myself two or three years ago was “Why I had been rejected?” “I had done everything right, but it wasn’t enough.”

I know the answer now. It’s because I wasn’t ready. Had any of the awful things following my exit from high school happened while attending my dream school, I would have probably dropped out of college completely, and fulfilled all of the expectations the world has for a person like me.

But honestly, I’m not one to fulfill expectations. I like to stand out. I like to ask questions and learn more, and be more. And if nothing else, I can promise you that.


Sorry, this really turned into kind of an essay. Regardless, please give me some opinions on what I should write my admissions essay on. All of the experiences I wrote about are true to life, just so everything’s clear. Thanks guys!

I suspect you have to supply transcripts for all the classes you took, even if you are forfeiting the credits for them.

This wasn’t your question, but I have to ask: Why are you applying to Amherst? I would not have picked this as a fit based on the background you’ve presented here - starting with the fact that you’ve been out of school for 3 years and will be older than 75% of the students the day you arrive (and older than 95% in terms of life experiences). In fact, Amherst sounds like the opposite of a fit. But, to your issue:

Yes, your essay is risky and normally we CC-ers suggest that the high school guidance counselor lay out the family situation so you can focus on your goals and ambitions, what you have to offer the school, your particular passions etc… In this case, you won’t have the GC to write that letter, so you’ll need to share this info yourself. I would suggest that you provide it in the ‘other information’ section of the application. Your main essay could be about what writing means to you, since this seems to be important, or whatever else you aspire to and how Amherst - or whatever other schools you are applying to - can help you get there.

JustOneDad is correct that you will probably be required to provide the CC transcripts even if you aren’t looking to transfer credits. You may be considering a transfer student depending on how many credits you have and the schools’ policy. Ask them directly - send an email.

What other schools are you applying to? Are you in need of financial aid? How much can your family afford?

Honestly, I’ve been interested in applying to Amherst since I was young, I just didn’t have enough courage to do so. Now that I’m older, I still think Amherst is a lovely school with a great writing program, which is what I’m primarily interested in. I know I’m older than the incoming students, but as a CC student, I’m used to big age gaps with my classmates. I plan on applying to other colleges, both in and out of my state, but Amherst has always been a college I wanted to go to above all else, it’s definitely worth a shot, even if I don’t make it. :slight_smile:

I’ll speak with them about the transcripts as well- I was given the impression that they didn’t require them but I could be mistaken.

If I’m reading your post correctly, you currently have at least 60 college credits. I don’t know of any school that will consider you a first-year student. And even if the majority of your grades weren’t A’s, you’d still have to report them. Colleges get reports about students’ previous colleges from a national clearinghouse, so if you lie about attending other schools your app will be an auto reject.

Unfortunately, the best aid goes to freshmen. You have to submit financial info. for your parents (unless you’re 24, have been in the military, were a ward of the court, or are married). Fafsa only schools use the info. of the parent you live with most (or get the most financial support from). CSS profile schools use both biological parents & step parents as well. You need to run the Net Price Calculator for every school you’re interested in to see if they’re affordable.

You can borrow $7500/year as a junior and senior. If your parents are low income, you may qualify for a Pell grant of up to ~$5k/year. If you plug your parents’ financial info into the FAFSA4caster, you’ll be able to tell if you qualify. Forget about dream schools and focus on finding an affordable school where you can finish your degree. If you have your cc degree, they may have articulation agreements with local 4-year schools within commuting distance of your home. If you don’t have your cc degree, you may want to start there.