I’m torn between taking advantage of ED as a legacy at a very prestigious school (think Cornell/Dartmouth/Duke/JHU/UPenn) or trying my shot at HYPS. If I have a decent chance (anything greater than 30%) of getting into at least one of the four of HYPS, I’m inclined to take the risk. What do you think my probabilities would be? What would you do in my position? Here is my profile for reference, and thank you in advance.
Stats:
SAT: 1600
UW GPA: 4.0
SAT Subject Tests: 800 Math II, will take two more this year
APs: Two 5s, will take five more this year (school doesn’t offer AP courses)
Extracurriculars:
- Founder of a successful organization to increase youth civic engagement in my state
- Politics Club (Founder and President)
- Debate
- Member of Student Council
- Intern on political campaigns
- Investment Club (President)
- Math Team
- Physical Activity Club (Founder and President)
- Students of Color Club
- Educational Volunteer at library
- Volunteer at a local animal shelter
Other:
Intended Major: Political Science and Philosophy
Ethnicity: Middle Eastern
Gender: Male
There is a very small EA bump at HYPS.
No one can answer your question. You are certainly a qualified applicant but so are the majority of the other students applying. No one has a greater than 30% chance of acceptance at a HYPS school unless their parents donated a building. The ED legacy bump will give you higher odds but also not a sure thing. I see legacies being deferred every year (Cornell).
Applying ED should be used for your favorite school. If that isn’t where you have legacy, then don’t use it.
Your time would be better spent worrying about pulling together an exciting list of match and safety schools.
It’s really impossible to chance any particular individual accurately for admission to one or more of HYPS. There are too many idiosyncratic factors that go into an application for anyone who does not see the actual application to give an informed guess.
However, students with 1600/4.0 GPA as a group certainly have greater odds than 30% of getting into at least one of HYPS. You can go through the Harvard litigation material yourself to confirm this - it is not really that hard to do.
Objectively, your accomplishments are impressive. The only relative weakness I see would be lack of national level achievements, but most kids who are accepted at HYPS do not have such achievements (although many unhooked students do).
The EA bump is real at HYPS, but is likely pretty small. If you were a URM, I would advise wholeheartedly to try your luck at HYPS early - getting into one with those stats as a URM would be much higher than 30%, likely higher than 75% (again, of course, with the caveat that no one on here can see your particular application).
At least judging from the material released by Harvard, the legacy bump is very large. If you choose to forego ED at the legacy school, you are really giving up a very valuable option, because I doubt that legacy will be worth nearly as much in the regular decision round than in the binding early one.
Overall, I think I would lean towards going ED at the legacy school, unless you really and truly want to be at one of the HYPS schools. A particular one, that is. Say, you really, truly want to be at Princeton for x,y, and z reasons. I do not think a general desire to be at one of them should outweigh the large bump that legacy will give you. It is hard to get into the T20 schools. Just my opinion.
Thank you all for the thoughtful replies. It might be worthwhile to say that I am not spellbound by the possibility of breaking through the hallowed gates (or, more aptly, Kafkaesque castle) of HYPS. Rather, I just think there would be certain evident advantages to attending one of these schools (superior academia, alumni connections, job opportunities, etc.). Consistent with OneMoreToGo2021’s logic, I am thus leaning towards the ED option. There is, however, another approach I have been considering.
Thanks to the generosity of my family, I will have a substantial sum made available to me on my 18th birthday. This money, in turn, would allow me to take full advantage of a gap year; I could explore new countries, learn a language, or volunteer. Regardless of college decisions, this is an opportunity I would like to pursue.
With this plan in mind, I was thinking of applying to only HYPS during my Senior year and then deferring to take the gap year if I am accepted to at least one of the four. In the likely scenario where I am rejected everywhere, I would take the gap year and apply ED to my legacy school during the next admissions cycle. Are there any apparent drawbacks to this strategy? Would my ED odds be hurt by the gap year? Again, thank you all for helping me out.
^You are lucky to have that option. The downside is “losing a year”, but if you can make your gap year meaningful, sounds like a plan.
The general decision on ED or not though needs to be driven more by where you really want to go. Further, of the schools you named, I am only aware of Penn requiring the legacy advantage to be used ED. FWIW, S had virtual guaranteed ED options at several T20 schools through the athletic recruit route, but chose to EA at an HYPS without an athletic recruit guarantee because that was his clear first choice. It turned out for him. I might have a different opinion if it had gone the other way, but he also had other acceptances in hand before the RD deadline from rolling admissions. That goes to the point of having good matches/safeties in your back pocket.