Logical Fallacies and Rhetorical Analysis Help

<p>I was doing a mock-test, sort of a self-drill, with a released 2009 FRQ on collegeboard’s website, and after I formed a response to the E.O.Wilson prompt (a rhetorical analysis prompt), I realized that I talked a great deal about logical fallacies in my essay.
Well, the question asked me to talk about rhetorical devices and I guess logical fallacies are distinctly different things from rhetorical devices… But, anybody who has read the passage (whose prompt asks us to analyze the satire that Wilson uses to belie the futility of the heated polemic between the environmentalists and their critics) would understand that Wilson is deliberately using logical fallacies (such as slippery slope, either-or fallacy, and hasty generalization) to flaunt very flagrantly the logical loopholes of both arguments–this is satire in and of itself, where Wilson puts himself in their shoes and uses an extended style of hyperbole to belie their faults…</p>

<p>Do I get a low score if I talk about logical fallacies for the rhetorical analysis prompt? Is this acceptable? Also, if anyone is conversant with this prompt, I talked about anaphora and an extended antithesis as well in my essay: what do you think?</p>

<p>Thank you very much in advance :slight_smile: I am just in dire need of advice…</p>

<p>Since logical fallacies are considered rhetorical devices, I don’t see why your answer would be nonresponsive to the prompt. It sounds fine to me, as long as you explain the purpose of the fallacies and the greater argument being made through those fallacies (which it seems that you did).</p>

<p>The scoring rubric for each FRQ is posted online, if you want to compare your answer or look at the grading standards.</p>

<p>I’ve learned in AP Lang that almost everything is a rhetorical strategy lol… short sentences are. Long sentences are. Omitting conjunctions are. Adding excessive conjunctions are. Etc. etc.
So yeah, you would definitely be fine in using logical fallacies in your essay.</p>

<p>@Miami. </p>

<p>That’s funny. I have the same impression.</p>