Again, I appreciate all the comments, especially ones like @Dustyfeathers and @Mwfan1921 who take a deep dive into what she is looking for.
To answer a couple questions:
A few of the schools mentioned Tufts, Connecticut and Barnard, got eliminated due to the curriculum not working great for a non-bio major doing premed. That was based on a relatively quick analysis by me of the requirements, so if you think I’m wrong point it out so I can recheck. Tufts and Connecticut in particular I thought would be good until I looked at that.
Smith seems great on paper, but the SJW contingent concerns me. I thought that was a major turn off for D when we visited BMC, but the more I think about it the personality of the tour guide could have been more the issue than the SJW aspect. I say this every time I mention that tour, I’m sure she is a nice girl. And she really loves BMC. D likes the thought of a place like that with the quirky traditions and love for the school, plus it’s a beautiful campus. But the over the top nature of the tour guide was just too much. She is probably different when not giving a tour. But she seems like the kind of person who it is exhausting to be around. So D was really turned off.
Carleton she likes the idea of the 3 classes for 10 weeks. It isn’t really the intense nature she is trying to avoid I think, more the intense atmosphere that is designed to eliminate 75% of the premeds. My understanding is that is what is going at WashU. Is Carleton the same way? If so this will probably drop off. I agree Cornell is the same way, maybe it drops off. She is mostly just interested because her brother is there (not a premed).
She has been showing the love to Tulane as much as possible. The current situation probably helps her because we probably wouldn’t go to NOLA just to do one visit, but now I think that is less expected. She was in contact with them before, and hopped on an online info session last week. They specifically said they were noting who was on the presentation and that showing the love was very important to them.
She may do ED or ED2, not sure. I’m pleasantly surprised by the aid her brother is getting. But I’m self employed so I’m afraid that the offers could be all over the place. That scares me a bit to use the ED card and then have to decide if an offer that includes paying $10,000 a year more than her brother has to pay is one we begrudgingly accept or we take our chances at RD. Ideally she would have a few offers to compare.
Being self employed, it depends on how the school views a few things where I come out on FA. I have been using a less favorable lens to view it than her brother’s school does when I do my calculatons. A couple schools like Pitt and William & Mary don’t work for me financially. Generally the more elite private schools do.
Tulane and Case would be EA, which bumps them up a bit in the consideration.
Initially the open curriculum was a main criteria for her. Which is why Hamilton stayed on the list. Plus it seems like a friendly and somewhat balanced place. The rural location isn’t great, but being less than an hour from her brother (who has a car) gives both D and mom a bit of peace of mind.
If she uses that as the main factor, then the list is probably:
Brown (big)
Amherst (tough admit)
Rochester (big premed classes)
Hamilton (rural)
Vassar (maybe too artsy for her)
Smith (SJW atmosphere concerns me)
Wesleyan (SJW and artsy)
Pitzer (same)
I guess like most things in life, it’s all about trade offs. Also about making decisions with imperfect information. She might love any of the above schools despite the flaws that I have picked up from the internet and college guides.
I guess I went from growing up on a cattle ranch to law school at NYU, having never seen the campus and spending only 24 hours in NYC 5 years earlier (on my only trip to the East Coast). And that was in the pre-internet 90’s. I had NO IDEA what I was getting into. It was an adventure though, and even though I didn’t want to stay I lived in and around NYC for 6 1/2 years before returning home and had a great time. She is much more exposed to the outside world than I was.