Looking for some schools to visit (virtually, of course)

Many of these places have advisors or clubs for premed or prehealth students. She should be reaching out to each college shes most interested in and see what the response is. It may help her get a better vibe as well.
This for example…https://www.stolaf.edu/orgs/list/index.cfm?fuseaction=orginfo&OrgID=603&currentaction=listallorgs

Does she have a top 10 or even a top 20 at this point? I think that may help guide posters to give you more of the info you are looking for versus throwing random info about random schools you may not even care about. But remember, ones opinion on “feel” of a college may not be your daughters (thus I suggested she reach out directly to the school advisors and clubs).

We have visited some of the schools mentioned above, though some were during the summer — Wesleyan, Conn College, Wooster, Kenyon, Hamilton (another NESCAC). Of these, Wooster had the friendliest atmosphere and a very “down-to-earth” vibe (and I understand frats are a small piece of the social scene — something DS was glad to hear). Not to say others were unfriendly or unwelcoming, but there was a difference. Another school with a similar feel was Dickinson, in PA, though I don’t know anything about premed. A niece of ours attends Haverford and while I’ve never visited, she is very happy there and is a high achiever but a very kind and gentle person — not someone who I think would be happy in a cutthroat environment.

I would not limit yourself to “meets need” colleges as the EFC can still change from year-to-year, whereas if your daughter goes to a school where she receives merit money, it should remain the same for all 4 years.

Regarding my recommendation of Rhodes- one of CC most beloved Parents had an exceptionally smart daughter, who he raised on a Texas goat farm. She was accepted at Yale [ with no FA- this was back in the bad old days before 2008 , when colleges increased the FA they offer middle class students] , and chose to go to Rhodes, which many of us on CC had never heard of, on a full ride scholarship. She was later admitted to many Medical Schools, and decided to go to— Yale to become a Dr.
Rhodes provides all the opportunities any pre-med student could wish for.

Amherst
Strong in both sciences and humanities with a terrific new science center. Meets full need. Friendly and collaborative. Diverse in many ways including geography.

Thanks for all the input. I was trying to make this a more focused thread and not necessarily get too deep into selecting schools. But maybe it would be more helpful if I gave more info.

Here are her visit impressions:

The first school she toured was WashU. Really liked everything about it. But I don’t think the premed culture is what she is looking for. So it isn’t really on the list anymore.

Rochester was her favorite when we toured. She really liked the look of the campus, mostly that it seemed like there was a theme to the buildings. Lots of red brick. Also liked the look of Colgate when we did a drive through, which is nothing like Rochester. But still a uniform look. Liked the openish cirriculum. Our tour guide seemed smart, slightly nerdy but in a quirky fun way. D really liked the feel there, but that could have just been the guide, IDK.

Bryn Mawr. Opposite tour guide experience. SJW, who was just REALLY earnest about everything. I’m sure a nice girl but an hour with her was exhausting. D was fairly negative about the school after the tour, but has somewhat mellowed.

Hamilton. Toured in drizzle when they were on break and we were sleep deprived. Didn’t like the mishmash of building styles (I liked it, but whatever). Concerned that with a small campus she might not find her people. Not a big fan of the isolated location and lack of a car, which she is used to having. Another school she was negative about after the tour but has since mellowed on. Personally I think this is a great fit for her.

Cornell. Too big. Her brother thinks he is at the greatest school in the country and chose it over Stanford. Just a couple days ago told me he made the right choice.

Drive bys of Colgate and Penn and Haverford. Not enough info to really have an opinion.

The local directional kind of blends into our town. There is a campus, but there isn’t a cohesive look to it at all and if you aren’t familiar with it you might not be sure which buildings at the edge are on campus and which are private businesses. I think she is exagerating that part, but that’s her impression. She wants to go somewhere with a campus that would look cute on a post card (my words, not hers). So NYU would be out, although it’s too big and a financial bad fit anyway. But the lack of a campus would definitely be a deal breaker for her.

About her and her wants:

Pretty sure either med or dental school is in the future. She can’t see herself doing anything else. Although she’s 17 and hasn’t been exposed to lots of things either. Which is why I would like her to go somewhere where she can keep her options open. She did say the other day anything that has her working in a cubicle is out.

Wants openish cirriculum, because between history major and premed classes that doesn’t leave much room for electives.

Not a partier, and she doesn’t see that changing. Again, she’s 17 so who knows. She isn’t judgemental about those who partake, but a campus where it is ok if you are drinking and ok if you aren’t is probably a good thing. I’m guessing that’s most places though. Pretty sure she has very minimal exposure to pot, and none to anything harder. Not really that much to alcohol either.

She has a group of 3-4 friends she is really tight with. She is hoping to be able to recreate a group like that. One of her brothers is super social, he has a group he is tight with too but there are lots of supporting characters in the group, and he is in more than one group of people. That isn’t her. She likes hanging with her friends but isn’t into big groups.

She can be lazy and is really catching up on her sleep and Netflix with the social distancing right now. However, she is usually the work hard/play hard type. Year round soccer player, and has another EC that keeps her busy off and on all year. Just going all of the time and when she isn’t she will do something with her friends.

Likes the feel and size of Rochester in particular, but a bit leery of the big intro classes. Also it sounds like there is more weeding out there than at the smaller LAC’s.

Not super excited about the isolation of a place like Hamilton or Williams, although that’s not a deal breaker. I think the big thing with that is that she is used to being able to get in her car and get away from people. So being on an isolated campus with no car and no Uber freaks her out a bit. Although this isn’t the most important thing to her either.

Otherwise kind of agnostic about surrounding town/city. Liked how Bryn was in a neighborhood, and would also like a school with a college town. Also ok with being in a city.

She has zero geographic preference, which I am ok with. From my POV, if Southwest flies to a reasonably close airport that’s a huge bonus. I just really hate dealing with everyone else. Carleton, Macalaster, Grinnell, St. Olaf are drivable, but most other places she is considering are not. Slight bonus if close to Cornell (i.e. Hamilton and Colgate. Although Ithaca isn’t exactly close to anything, and Southwest flights are not realistic either.).

Tentative list.

This is WAY too long. Also, it looks like she is chasing prestige. But the reality is that those are the schools with good need based aid. When you get to the schools most kids here use as low match/safety the financial aid really drops, at least for my situation. (I’ve done enough NPC’s that I keep it on a spreadsheet) So we end up with mostly reaches/high matches.

The instate flagship is probably the only true safety she will have. And it is a true safety, she is an autoadmit and even if she was full pay (which she shouldn’t be) I can make it work.

Having said that if she figures out what she is looking for we may add a couple lower match schools if the NPC’s work or if it looks like she might get good scholarships. Although with her current test scores she probably won’t get much merit anywhere.

Big schools

Brown (Open cirriculum, good for premed, been one of her favorites for a long time)
Cornell (because brother is there, otherwise this doesn’t fit with the others.)
Local Flagship (safety, also no essays so only takes a few minutes to apply)

Medium schools

Rochester
Case Western
Tulane
Emory (but concerned too competitive premed)
Wake
Rice

Small Schools

Pretty much all of the NESCAC’s, Amherst and Hamilton probably at the top of them
Carleton
St Olaf
Macalaster
Grinnell
Vassar
Claremont Colleges
Occidental
Colgate
MHC
Bryn Mawr
Smith (Although I’m guessing too SJW for her)
Haverford
Davidson
Lewis & Clark, but only if she gets big merit so it’s probably as reachy as Amherst

If you told her she could go anywhere as long as she picks today, it would probably be either Carleton, Brown or Rochester, depending on what she was feeling at the moment for size.

I realize this is a ridiculous list. Which is why I am here. Although as I type it out I’m thinking maybe she applies to a few from each list. Pretty easy to narrow down the big and medium lists. But that small list has 20+ schools on it. And probably there are a couple lower matches that should be added.

Would she be happy to attend the local flagship? If that would be very disappointing, try to find another safety/highly likely.

With the intent to shorten the list…

If WashU is off because of the prehealth culture (which is intense, but more collaborative than cutthroat), you might considering removing Cornell, Carleton, Emory, and Davidson.

Grinnell is isolated like Hamilton, Colgate, and Williams. Even tho it sounds like her negative perception of Hamilton has softened, why keep it on the list if she doesn’t want isolation (and you need to cull the list)? A downside of the isolated campuses for prehealth majors is getting patient facing volunteer/work experience. Do students make it work? Sure, but it’s harder to make happen at Williams or Hamilton than Rochester, for example.

Pitzer probably too SJW, Mudd would be out for prehealth, CMC, Pomona, Scripps…could be ok.

You say all of the NESCACs, but haven’t mentioned Tufts which is the largest, and among the least isolated. Another reach, but good campus, in a great city for prehealth majors.

While she could add more match schools, this list does seem to have enough (unless affordability is an issue per the NPCs/substantial merit is needed). CWRU, Rochester, St. Olaf, Macalester, Grinnell, Occidental, MHC, Bryn Mawr are probably matches.

Make sure she is demonstrating interest where that is considered…Tulane especially.

I am not sure I understand your budget situation, but seems like you do. Do any seem affordable per the NPC, and along with being one of her top schools, it could make sense to apply EDI/II? Definitely apply EA to all the schools that have EA.

Are there any rolling admit schools that are affordable that she would consider? Especially ones that are good for prehealth majors, such as Alabama or Pitt?

Again, I appreciate all the comments, especially ones like @Dustyfeathers and @Mwfan1921 who take a deep dive into what she is looking for.

To answer a couple questions:

A few of the schools mentioned Tufts, Connecticut and Barnard, got eliminated due to the curriculum not working great for a non-bio major doing premed. That was based on a relatively quick analysis by me of the requirements, so if you think I’m wrong point it out so I can recheck. Tufts and Connecticut in particular I thought would be good until I looked at that.

Smith seems great on paper, but the SJW contingent concerns me. I thought that was a major turn off for D when we visited BMC, but the more I think about it the personality of the tour guide could have been more the issue than the SJW aspect. I say this every time I mention that tour, I’m sure she is a nice girl. And she really loves BMC. D likes the thought of a place like that with the quirky traditions and love for the school, plus it’s a beautiful campus. But the over the top nature of the tour guide was just too much. She is probably different when not giving a tour. But she seems like the kind of person who it is exhausting to be around. So D was really turned off.

Carleton she likes the idea of the 3 classes for 10 weeks. It isn’t really the intense nature she is trying to avoid I think, more the intense atmosphere that is designed to eliminate 75% of the premeds. My understanding is that is what is going at WashU. Is Carleton the same way? If so this will probably drop off. I agree Cornell is the same way, maybe it drops off. She is mostly just interested because her brother is there (not a premed).

She has been showing the love to Tulane as much as possible. The current situation probably helps her because we probably wouldn’t go to NOLA just to do one visit, but now I think that is less expected. She was in contact with them before, and hopped on an online info session last week. They specifically said they were noting who was on the presentation and that showing the love was very important to them.

She may do ED or ED2, not sure. I’m pleasantly surprised by the aid her brother is getting. But I’m self employed so I’m afraid that the offers could be all over the place. That scares me a bit to use the ED card and then have to decide if an offer that includes paying $10,000 a year more than her brother has to pay is one we begrudgingly accept or we take our chances at RD. Ideally she would have a few offers to compare.

Being self employed, it depends on how the school views a few things where I come out on FA. I have been using a less favorable lens to view it than her brother’s school does when I do my calculatons. A couple schools like Pitt and William & Mary don’t work for me financially. Generally the more elite private schools do.

Tulane and Case would be EA, which bumps them up a bit in the consideration.

Initially the open curriculum was a main criteria for her. Which is why Hamilton stayed on the list. Plus it seems like a friendly and somewhat balanced place. The rural location isn’t great, but being less than an hour from her brother (who has a car) gives both D and mom a bit of peace of mind.

If she uses that as the main factor, then the list is probably:

Brown (big)
Amherst (tough admit)
Rochester (big premed classes)
Hamilton (rural)
Vassar (maybe too artsy for her)
Smith (SJW atmosphere concerns me)
Wesleyan (SJW and artsy)
Pitzer (same)

I guess like most things in life, it’s all about trade offs. Also about making decisions with imperfect information. She might love any of the above schools despite the flaws that I have picked up from the internet and college guides.

I guess I went from growing up on a cattle ranch to law school at NYU, having never seen the campus and spending only 24 hours in NYC 5 years earlier (on my only trip to the East Coast). And that was in the pre-internet 90’s. I had NO IDEA what I was getting into. It was an adventure though, and even though I didn’t want to stay I lived in and around NYC for 6 1/2 years before returning home and had a great time. She is much more exposed to the outside world than I was.

FWIW, Wesleyan is a few blocks from a community health center as well as a hospital:
https://www.wesleyan.edu/jccp/get-involved/community-directory.html

IMHO, if you can stand Brown’s level of quirkiness, not to mention variety in architectural styles, Wesleyan shouldn’t be that big a hurdle for her. Also, it’s easy to forget that in addition to the arts, Wesleyan attracts the second highest level of tax-supported scientific research in NESCAC (Tufts, of course, would be #1.)

@dadof4kids ,
there are NO true safeties on that list!! And most of them are highly selective, and reject the vast majority of applicants, regardless of how qualified they are.
You need to encourage her to cast a wider net, ESPECIALLY as you are self employed, and she may need to go to a college that offers merit $$ once her older brothers are out of college.

I agree that “meets need” may not when older brother no longer in college.
I am concerned the NPCs are just a minimum. When my eldest was applying in 2015, actual bill from colleges admitted to - from private colleges - was in NPC+$10k range, even with so-called grants or merit.

UPDATE to post#30:

Wesleyan 3D printers are running at full speed:
http://newsletter.blogs.wesleyan.edu/2020/04/06/wesleyan-labs-create-donate-face-shields-to-local-hospital/

On seeking need based aid:

@menloparkmom @Hippobirdy I have run the NPC’s for 4 years for all of those schools (plus others), making my best estimate at which siblings would be in college and what my variable income will be for each year. With 3 kids in college her freshman year, it’s great. Senior year when she has zero siblings in college and my income is where I expect it to be will be a bit tougher. But over the 4 years it is still a workable number. So a school like Alabama with an automatic Presidential Scholarship would be more expensive now but cheaper her senior year. Overall I think I’m better off with the need based. I certainly don’t think 2020 will be a banner year for me, I’m still making some money now but will struggle to have 2020 income even match 2019. Stay at home orders are definitely bad for my bottom line.

The one variable I guess is if my income takes a large increase at the end. I’m rebuilding a business, so barring some major disruption (like COVID-19) it should have slight to moderate increases each year. If that process goes faster than expected, then I will pay the college more but also be making quite a bit more than I am now and presumably her brothers are at least somewhat self sufficient (neither will likely pursue grad school so when they graduate they hopefully start real jobs). So in that case I get hammered at the end by the school but my net amount of income left in my checking account every month is still higher than what it is now.

On lower matches and safeties:

This is a struggle. She will be disappointed but not devastated if she goes to the in-state flagship. I’m hoping when we visit and meet with someone from the honors program she will be more interested. Her big issue is that she knows a lot of kids who aren’t great students from her HS that end up there. But once she got there honestly I think she would realize there are a lot of really smart and motivated kids who also go there and she would be fine.

Schools like Lewis & Clark and Puget Sound (we enjoy the Pacific NW so I looked a bit there) and Creighton (drivable) are quite a bit more expensive for me. I don’t know that they are worth $75,000 more over 4 years than the state flagship. It’s a lot easier to justify an additional $15,000-30,000 for a school like Vassar or Rochester. I know that’s a personal decision, but kind of where I am on it.

I don’t know that schools with competitive merit scholarships are really any less reachy if she needs the scholarship to attend. If she had a 35 on her ACT before this happened then maybe she would be in better shape for those.

Having said all of that, when she figures out more what she wants, I will run some more NPC’s on similar schools and see if there are some low match/safeties that work. But running an NPC is not a super quick deal, because I am changing several variables and running each one 4 times. And I don’t want to devote a whole day to doing that for 100 more schools. So that won’t happen until she gets her wish list narrowed down a bit.

“I don’t know that schools with competitive merit scholarships are really any less reachy if she needs the scholarship to attend. If she had a 35 on her ACT before this happened then maybe she would be in better shape for those.”

@dadof4kids

Here is a list of automatic merit scholarships that was compiled by CC members. Be SURE to check the schools individual websites as the scholarships may have changed. MANY colleges have early application deadlines for scholarship consideration, so be sure your DD gets her apps in before any deadline if your find any that might work for her. etting her ACT score up will help , but it is not critical for many of the colleges on this list.

http://automaticfulltuition.yolasite.com/

“So a school like Alabama with an automatic Presidential Scholarship would be more expensive now but cheaper her senior year.”

Huh??? Alabama’s merit scholarships are for 4 years. As are most Merit Scholarships. So how could they be cheaper her SR year??

Unlike FA awards, a student does NOT have to reapply each year to receive them. Some do stipulate that a minimum college GPA must be maintained in order to continue to receive them, and that usually varies between 3.0 and 3.5

https://www.uah.edu/admissions/undergraduate/financial-aid/scholarships/merit-tuition-scholarships

“UAH’s merit tuition scholarships recognize incoming first-time freshmen (including international students) who have demonstrated superior academic achievement in high school. All merit tuition scholarships are four-year awards for fall and spring semesters, renewable each semester based on full-time student status and satisfactory academic progress.”

"Renewal Criteria

Merit tuition scholarships are renewable for up to eight total semesters of award. Renewal each semester is contingent upon meeting the following requirements:

Remain classified as an undergraduate student;
Enroll full-time each consecutive fall and spring term;
Earn a minimum 2.00 UAH GPA each semester;
Maintain a minimum cumulative UAH GPA of 3.00;
Earn a minimum of 6 credit hours each fall and spring semester and; 

Earn a minimum of 24 combined credit hours from fall and spring of the same academic year"

We were also self employed parents when our DS applied to colleges. And as our income did fluctuate a lot year to year, we wanted to have options that we knew would not cost us an arm and a leg.

@menloparkmom I appreciate the info and will check it out.

What I meant on the Alabama Presidential Scholarship being cheaper or more expensive was compared to getting financial aid at a full needs school.

It looks like the Presidential Scholarship leaves a cost of about $25,000, if you look at total COA and not just out of pocket. Her freshman year would be cheaper than that if I use financial aid. But her senior year I would pay more than that. Hope that makes more sense.

I get what you are saying about the income fluctuations. Without getting into too much irrelevant detail I don’t think right now I am at a large risk for wild swings. But it is definitely something to consider.

Your daughter seems to have a solid head on her shoulders and will likely find her tribe anywhere.
I try to remember that there’s lots of different “cliques” in my kids high school (which is about the size of some of the small LAC’s) but somehow my kids have found their way and done well. I have faith that the high school teachers and the curriculum are there to support my kids and that means more to me personally (and its why my kids high school is one of the top schools in our area). So while I think its impossible to avoid competitive kids or mean kids, having professors and a college that wants my kids to succeed is important in college selection imo.
I know that rankings and awards only mean so much but I know for my kids personalities and learning styles that certain awards or rankings (perhaps class size or “best professor” awards) would work better for them. If large class sizes dont appeal to her I would cut those off her list (again, bigger classes sizes to her may make her feel more “weeding out”). If shes going to take more history courses and such it seems she isnt doing the “typical” premed biology path so maybe she would automatically feel less cut throat?

(My S19 took a tech path route so he was easy. My S23 is going to be the difficult one like your daughter as hes all over the map. I feel for you!)

Hamilton offers a shuttle to nearby suburban areas that runs hourly, which might be of interest to your daughter.

https://www.hamilton.edu/campuslife/transportation/the-jitney

Rhodes College! Friendly, collaborative culture. Generous aid, including merit. Lots of research and internship opportunities for pre-med students.