Macalester vs Davidson

Hi, I have a student who was accepted into both Mac and Davidson, both with pretty good aid packages. She didn’t get to visit either one due to coronavirus. She likes the more traditional vibe of Davidson (sports, Greek life, big campus), however, is very concerned about the academics. Academic pressure is very stressful for her, as are competitive students. She is also concerned that the grade deflation at Davidson will make it difficult for her to get into medical school. She plans to major in Chem or another STEM field. She currently attends a respectable, but not prestigious, Catholic high school in the Bay Area, and took some AP classes, but didn’t have a super challenging course load. As a college advisor, I put high value on students being in a learning environment that suits them. Unfortunately, I have never sent a student to Davidson so don’t know it well, other than it’s an excellent school. Any insights about the academic environment at Davidson, and about the impact of grade deflation on med school apps would be helpful. Thanks!

I don’t know but Macalester seems like such a neat school in a location that has a lot to offer. Campus seems super small but neat. Davidson seems also like a very good school. Don’t know about which would be better for med school.