Making that list for the less than top students

OK, first a disclaimer: I know that the overwhelming number of kids here are the top students in their school, their state, and the country.

But I understand math well enough to know that they’re still not the typical college applicant. According to prepscolar, the median SAT score on the 2017 exam was between 1050 and 1100

So I would like to open a discussion about those kids.

I’ve never understood the idea of a college list full of reaches. By definition, those are schools from which you pretty much expect a rejection. I don’t understand why any kid-- or any parent for that matter-- would set the kid up for letter after letter saying that they’re not good enough. Each one of those letters is a brutal blow to the ego.

I’m a big fan of a list with perhaps a reach or two, but largely devoted to schools that the kid is likely to get into. Isn’t that the point of this whole exercise? To find schools you can attend?

My advice is to ignore conventional advice. Have a reach or two if you want. But spend this summer finding schools that you’re likely to get into. Schools where your SAT score places you firmly above the 25th percentile of admissions. Schools that you can afford, that look like you’ll be a good fit, where you can envision yourself living and learning and growing for 4 years.

Those schools are out there. We have several threads here

I think this is valuable advice for everyone. Finding the great match and safety schools (meaning they appear affordable and the applicant would be excited to attend) is an underrated but extremely important part of the college search process.

I’m so glad I found this site - I think many parents are unaware how much the college landscape has changed since we were applying! My son was an “average” student (dare I say a bit below average??) but I saw many of his friend’s parents in shock after rejection and wait lists from almost all of their list, with great stats. They didn’t realize how competitive it’s gotten! I will be much more prepared for D21!!

The “conventional advice” tends to be to pick a couple of reaches, some fits, and a couple of safety schools. Where do you find that the conventional advice tends to be to pick a ton of reach schools?

@bjkmom For a family with some resources to afford college with some merit aid or a good in state public, your advice makes perfect sense. I get the feeling that many families are just stuck on the idea of prestige for its own sake.

However, for families who need generous financial aid, the elite schools really are the best shot. The “meets full need” schools are really the top ranked universities and LACs in the country. There are some lower ranked schools that are very generous, like Bama, but in general, for a kid who needs close to a full ride, it makes sense that they are targeting these very prestigious institutions.

Our school is statistically average. The majority of the kids who head off to college pick one of our 14 true state schools. They might get rejected from some, but they usually make it in to others:

http://www.passhe.edu/Pages/default.aspx

Other favorites can include Pitt or Penn State’s satellite campuses (Johnstown, York, etc).

York College of PA is loved as are:

McDaniel
Juniata
Washington and Jefferson
Albright
Harrisburg University of Science and Technology
Wilson
Shepherd
Mt St Mary’s
Geneva
Grove City
Liberty
Eastern
Messiah
Lycoming
Elizabethtown
Lebanon Valley
Delaware Valley
Susquehanna
Towson
Hood
Washington
Stevenson

And undoubtedly a few more not coming to my mind early this morning. If I were at school I could have gotten a list, but school is closed for renovation for the summer - no teachers allowed in the building. (It’s an interesting year!)

Most of those colleges get pretty much no press on CC, but our students seem to usually get decent jobs from them when they graduate.

Higher scorel kids often consider colleges that do get press on here (Franklin and Marshall, Gettysburg, Muhlenburg, RIT, etc). I listed schools typically considered by all the “normal” kids (and some top kids as not all want higher level schools, or of course, as safeties admission-wise).

However, the student still needs affordable safeties, and the best-financial-aid schools are typically too selective to be anything close to safeties. Also, many of the best-financial-aid schools can be problematic for students with divorced parents.

@Creekland Throw in a few of the lesser-known PA Catholic colleges, such as Alvernia or King’s, and you have also described my kids’ (small, Catholic) high school in central PA.

Really appreciate your post, @bjkmom .

I just have to say, my daughter’s only “meets full need” college came through with one of the lowest financial offers. They accounted almost nothing for books, travel, personal expenses, and maxed out student loans and work study to “meet” our need (also used CSS to calculate higher estimate of our ability to pay). In contrast, out of state University of Iowa estimated a good $3000 more for those expenses and then subtracted our FAFSA EFC based on that more generous/realistic total. (So many good things to say about runner-up U of I). So you really can’t “count” on meets-full-need to meet YOUR need. I know there are some more genuinely generous Ivies and such out there, but we were not the only family in our crowd to find themselves underwhelmed by the meets-full-need schools.

I think that the average student will be going to non-flagship state schools or CC. He/she will only go to private schools if the family has enough money for full pay. The one standard deviation above the mean student could probably get some merit aid at local/regional private colleges or get into some of the state flagships.

It depends on how you define “average”. On CC, it sometimes seems like the “average” student is doomed to suffer a lifetime working as a barista because the only schools they could get accepted to were “safeties” such as their state flagship or Fordham, Wake Forest, or Lehigh.

The average student, especially in a state with a very competitive flagship, may very likely not get admitted to the flagship. However, that doesn’t mean there aren’t other options in the public system that would be affordable and they would get accepted into.

An “average” student who might struggle to get into a school such as Fordham, and likely wouldn’t get much in the way of aid, could do quite well at lesser-known schools where they might be a stronger contender. For example, people will often point to Guilford and Greensboro colleges in NC. Great schools, but some more affordable options could be Queens, Lenoir-Ryhne Gardner-Webb, Belmont Abbey.

My D applied to one reach school, and all the rest were schools where she was a top student and was offered entry into Honors programs. S didn’t even apply to a reach - he had no interest in going anywhere he might need to take out student loans. People told my kids they could “do better” - but I never saw those people offering to help pay for “better”!

The best school is one you can afford and where you get a good education. In NC, community college is becoming a common path due to the strong articulation agreements between the CCs and the UNC system.

I think this really depends upon where one lives. I’m not seeing it at our school. Kids who choose cc are almost always those who want 2 year programs there (vs moving on to 4 year afterward) or those who generally can’t make it in to a 4 year school. There are probably fewer than 10 (maybe 5) each year starting there with an intent to move on afterward - and some of those don’t actually end up moving on.

On this site and in some news reports I hear of oodles of folks choosing cc to save money, but I just don’t see it in our area - therefore I assume it’s very regional or perhaps depends upon the state. Here I see more who choose the satellite campuses of Penn St or Pitt for their first two years than our local cc.

We are not a wealthy district. Very few kids are full pay when it comes to college. More get SAT fee waivers than are full pay.

It’s completely different in NC. NC publics are strong academically and very affordable. There are clear agreements between the CCs and the 4-year schools as to course credit, and a guarantee of acceptance to a state university for good students.

Many NC community colleges are also strong, especially in the larger cities. At my kid’s private Catholic high school, we saw many students going the CC route and then continuing on, even though they could have gone straight to a 4-year and their families could have afforded it without huge sacrifice. Many parents had the mindset that it doesn’t matter where you go the first two years, so you might as well go to the local CC and live at home, then go live on campus the last two years.

CC is becoming more popular in NJ. If you are the top 15% of your class, its free and there are agreements with all the NJ 4 year publics, and many others, that all credits transfer. In my daughter’s super-competitive, highly ranked, wealthy public it’s actually the #2 destination behind Rutgers.

I believe Tennessee instituted something similar recently?

Seems like the PSU and Pitt branch campuses serve the same function that community colleges do in other states for pre-transfer students, but at a higher cost to the students.

In looking at @Creekland’s wonderful list, one comment: There are 2 “Mount Saint Mary’s” on the east coast-- and both are worth looking at for this population. One is MSM College in Newburgh NY, and the other is MSM University in Emmitsberg MD.

Emmitsberg, MD is the one I’m familiar with.

We send a LOT of kids to MSM Newburgh; it’s a lot closer to my Long Island home.