Marching Band Stereotypes

<p>I was sure I saw this on CC at one point…but couldn’t find - must have been someplace else.</p>

<p>The family and I were talking about HS and college MB stereotypes by instrument. I was in MB, many years ago, My kids went to different HS’s and both participate in college bands and it seems to be “generally” the same everywhere (remember these are stereotypes - meant to be funny and obviously not everyone fits).</p>

<p>We wondered if others had the same experiences?</p>

<p>Tubas: class clowns
Trumpets: feminine cleansing products
Saxes: Slackers
Drumline: pervs
Pit: complainers
Flutes: bipolar (giggly one sec / witches with a b the next)
Colorguard: flirts
Clarinets: serious musicians
Trombones: Quiet
Mellos: usually a mix, because for many it’s not their primary instrument</p>

<p>My corrections:
Tubas are the quiet ones in our band.
Trumpets don’t really even fit the ego stereotype, a third of our section is brown.
Saxes: Mostly agreed.
Drumline: Agreed.
Pit: Agreed (Gee our air conditioned practice room was too bright today)
Flutes: Agreed (some of my best friends are flutes…shudder)
Colorguard: I just don’t even pay attention.
Clarinet: Agreed (I play clarinet!)
Trombones: Pervs…their instrument name mandates it.
Mellos: Nonexistent almost…we doubled our section by adding one freshman. (hint that makes two.) </p>

<p>Overall marching band stereotype: Marching band nerds are sexy. Go band!</p>

<p>I don’t know so much about those instrument stereotypes, but at my son’s high school it was actually “cool” to be in marching band -very different than my high school 25+ years ago. Marching band members had pretty much the same social status as football players and cheerleaders.</p>

<p>It’s is a very economically homogeneous student body, almost no poverty or high wealth groups in our community. I suspect that has something to do with there not being much of a trend towards “clicks”.</p>

<p>I have always been told that trumpets consistantly think that they are the best, and are over critical of everyone else (including other trumpet players) - suggesting that every non-trumpet brass player plays something else because they arn’t “good enough” for trumpet (although I personally don’t believe that).</p>

<p>Anyhow, I recently ran across this:</p>

<p>What’s the difference between a violin and a viola? A viola burns longer. </p>

<p>What’s the difference between a viola and an onion? No one cries when you cut up a viola. J</p>

<p>How do you fix a tuba? With a tuba glue…</p>

<p>what’s the difference between a viola and a chainsaw? You can’t fake cutting down a tree! </p>

<p>What do you call 20 violists jumping out of an airplane? Target practice. </p>

<p>What do you call a trombonist with a week-at-a-glance calendar? An optimist. </p>

<p>how do you get 2 oboes to play in tune? shoot one :slight_smile: </p>

<p>What do you call a drummer without a girlfriend? HOMELESS! </p>

<p>How many Trumpet players does it take to screw in a lightbulb? Five. 1 to screw it in and 4 to tell each other how much better they would’ve done it. </p>

<p>How do you get two piccolos to play in unison? Get rid of one. </p>

<p>A girl went out on a date with a trumpet player, and when she came back her roommate asked, “Well, how was it? Did his embouchure make him a great kisser?” “Nah,” she replied. “That dry, tight, tiny little pucker; it was no fun at all.” The… next night she went out with a tuba player, and when she came back her roommate asked, “Well, how was his kissing?” “Ugh!” she exclaimed. "Those huge, rubbery, blubbery, slobbering slabs of meat; oh, it was just gross! The next night she went out with a French horn player, and when she came back her roommate asked, “Well, how was his kissing?” “Well,” she replied, “his kissing was just so-so; but I loved the way he held me!”</p>

<p>Know what the difference in an Oboe and a trampoline is? You’re supposed to take your shoes off before jumping on a trampoline. </p>

<p>How do you make a Trombone sound like a French Horn? Put your hand in the bell and miss lots of notes.</p>

<p>Put a clarinet on your dash in your car and you can park in the handicap zone!</p>

<p>I don’t appreciate that last one. :)</p>

<p>Tubas: In their own tuba world most of the time
Trumpets: Perverted, think they’re in the military, make fun of each other a lot
Saxes: Perverts. Major perverts.
Drumline: The most egotistical people you will ever meet.
Pit: Complain about practicing indoors in the air conditioning and not moving (the horror!)
Flutes: Flirty, girly girls with some questionable guys thrown in
Colorguard: Flirts and some inappropriate words are commonly used here
Clarinets: Either really bad and don’t care or really, really good
Trombones: We are the trouble makers that are the self proclaimed best section in the band
Mellos: Changes yearly. Last year they were perverts, this year they’re quiet and hardworking.
Low Woodies: The most annoying section because they are always trying to do more work.</p>

<p>Oh yeah, I forgot about the ego of the drumline.</p>

<p>How 'bout the personality of the drum major(s)? - do they match whatever instrument they used to play?</p>

<p>For us, it really depended on the drum major. Some completely abandoned their section and just became quiet “perfect” band students and others have remained their old ways whether trouble making or perverted or whatever their old stereotype was.</p>

<p>haha for my band:
Flutes- Agreed with bipolar.
Trumpets- slackers.
Clarinets- biased since I’m a clarinet player.
Saxes- Quiet ones.
Drumlines- serious and perverted. (Our drumline is intense at our school…)
Tubas- ALSO perverted.
French horn- there’s only 1 that I know, so I have no idea. The one we have though is amazing and serious about music. :slight_smile:
Trombones- Goofs! XD</p>

<p>Oops, almost forgot:</p>

<p>Baritones- they’re the quiet goofy ones who have no idea what’s going on. XD</p>

<p>I have worked with hundreds of band kids and loved every minute. They have been the most fun-loving, hard-working and respectful young people I have ever met. They truly give me hope for the future of this planet. To have ANY of them referred to as “pervs” or “feminine cleansing products” is very upsetting to me. I know that this conversation is not meant to be hurtful but it offends me. Thank you for respecting my opinion.</p>

<p>At my school, the marching band stereotype is bus ride orgies.</p>

<p>CLRN8MOM- I’m glad you spoke up. Frankly, I feel that this thread is out of hand and shouldn’t be continued. While I know that most of the kids posting are band members themselves, labeling groups of people is disturbing.
Hopefully, a moderator will see this and lock the thread.</p>

<p>Just because something is sophomoric does not mean it should be censored.</p>

<p>I agree, stradmom. But this is beyond sophomoric.</p>

<p>You guys are adults, right? Newsflash: No matter how much you think you know them, they act a little different when they’re around their peers…<br>
And I’m pretty sure most of them would laugh along with this and agree…</p>

<p>Although, the femine cleansing products was a big much. Lol.</p>

<p>It’s all in good fun. Nothing seriously directed at any specific people, just an identification and comparison of steriotypes.</p>

<p>But there is the rub…“stereotypes”.</p>

<p>Stereotypes aren’t always true, but every band’s members think about each other in different ways whether good or bad. No one I know (in my band at least) ever takes offense to their section being known as flirty or even perverted.</p>

<p>Though we aren’t in the habit of censoring our members, this material has been offensive to some folks so this thread will be closed. Please try and keep it clean.</p>