<p>Ahmed rolled an eight-sided polygon six times. Each face of the polygon has a number from 1-8 painted on it. No two numbers are repeated. Each roll yields one number face up.
The first roll yields an even number.
The second roll yields an odd number.
The third roll yields the number 5.
The fourth roll yields a number smaller than 4.
The fifth roll yields the same number as the fourth roll.
The sixth roll yields a number smaller than the fifth roll.</p>
<p>Which of the following must be true?
A) Ahmed could have rolled a 5 three times.
B) Ahmed could have rolled a 2 more frequently than he could have rolled any other numbers.
C) Ahmed rolled more odd numbers than even numbers.
D) Ahmed rolled a 3 at least once.
E) Ahmed rolled a 1 on four rolls.</p>
<p>I chose B as well, but I don’t have the answer key with me. This is from Kaplan. I have to say that this practice test really sucks. Why make a Sentence Completion problem with choices not adhering to the proper part of speech? Anyway, if anyone has the Kaplan SAT book, I would really appreciate the answer for this. It’s practice test ten.</p>
<p>The most B can be rolled is 3 times.
number 3 can also be rolled 3 times.
Doesn’t that make B wrong?</p>
<p>^ Yeah. The SAT does not have questions with the structure “it must be true that it could be true that…”</p>
<p>Also, “polygons” are two dimensional! But that’s nitpicking. </p>
<p>A, C, D and E are pretty easy to disprove.</p>
<p>B is so grammatically contorted that it is hard to check. He COULD have rolled a 2 on the first, fourth and fifth rolls for a maximum total of 3 times. But unless I am missing something, he COULD have rolled a 3 on the second, fourth and fifth rolls, also for a maximum of 3. So I don’t see how you can say that it MUST be that he COULD have rolled more 2’s than he COULD have rolled any other number.</p>
<p>But I bet that the second “COULD” was a mistake on the part of the writer and that b was the intended answer to this idiotic question. So once again, like sweeping back the tide, I ask the CC community: Why are you wasting time with non-college board questions?</p>