Memory Foam Mattresses/Box Springs or Other Economical Options

D2 will be starting grad school end of May and moving to a first apt where she will need to provide her own bed. We bought a bed frame/headboard/footboard but will need to get a mattress/box spring.

I figured we would just get something in her town and have it delivered if we purchased a regular mattress set up. (2nd floor apt and no I don’t know how it will go getting it in the door(s)!!!

But today I was looking at Costco at the memory foam mattresses. I’m going to look up the reviews on Costco.com but thought I’d ask here too. I’m sure there are fans and not fans of any type of mattress…
Though not the price listed online, our store showed this one on sale for $159:
https://www.costco.com/Novaform-8%22-Full-Gel-Memory-Foam-Mattress.product.100465402.html

First of all, what are the layers we would need for a memory foam mattress? Box/spring under the mattress? Does a regular mattress cover fit on top of it? I noticed at Costco they also sold memory foam mattress toppers but those were as much as the mattress itself!!

On the box spring subject - has anyone ordered one of the split box mattresses from Amazon? If so please let me know if there was one you recommend.

Beds are a lot of work!

We got a thicker version of the mattress for kid and used it on platform bed without any box springs.

I think most don’t have box “springs” anymore.

Our temperpedic foundation is really a platform. That’s it.

Last time we bought a full size bed (4 years ago) it also came with a platform foundation, not a spring one.

Agree with @BunsenBurner just get a platform bed. IKEA has plenty.

Or…look at Bed in a Box. Everyone we know who has gotten one for their first apartment has liked it.

We already purchased a bed. It’s actually a bed exactly like her bed from home. Weird story but we found it next to new at a thrift store and it’s exactly what she wanted - maybe I’m not understanding…it did come with metal underframe with three metal bars and then a whole bunch of wooden slats that I’m not even sure how we use those! Does that make it a platform bed???

Here’s the bed https://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/S49277313/#/S89277311

This is a platform bed - it will work with your memory foam mattress. :slight_smile:

Ahh…I haven’t bought a bed in awhile - I assumed a platform bed was a solid surface.

So what about protection for the memory foam mattress - something besides a regular fitted mattress cover??

From what i remember, most foam mattress need a foundation. This could be a sheet of plywood, slats (I seem to recall spacing of no more than 2"), bunkie board, to name a few. we got a very affordable metal one that sits on the standard slots from Amazon. Shipped in a small long box and was very easy to assemble.

Here’s what we bought for our cabin - a queen-sized memory foam mattress for $216 and a metal platform bed for $78:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00GTCL3SQ/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o06_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B06ZZDC1VB/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o07_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

It’s wonderful!! It seemed amazing that the mattress could fit in such a small box. It took about a day for it to expand fully, but once it did it worked great. The metal platform bed came with slats and required no additional material.

It’s so comfortable that now I’m wondering why we spent $$$ on our Tempurpedic bed at home.

We got a bed in a box mattress and the bed frame posted above by @MaineLonghorn for our D in college who only needed a bed for one semester. She loved it and it was SO easy to assemble and set up. She used her memory foam mattress topper on top but not sure she really needed it.

D just got this one and loves it:
https://www.amazon.com/Zinus-Memory-Green-Mattress-Queen/dp/B00Q7EPSHI

She got a full size mattress and I believe a 10 inch one, rather than 12. It expands within a day, might smell a bit the first day.

Very helpful to see models people have tried - thank you!

I have the same one as @arisamp’s D has. I haven’t slept in it but those in the family who have love it.

My kids bought ikea beds and mattresses and said they were OK. Have heard that overstock sells beds and box springs and delivers free!

Our beds - all of them, MB, guest, and kiddo’s - all have similar slats. Never had issues with memory foam mattresses sitting on top of the slats.

Mattresses are such an investment - and it’s difficult when you can’t try them out - plus when you get one you usually need to use it right away - since we sleep nightly!

One reason I thought about the Costco one was for ease in taking it back if needed. The one I was looking at was 8 inches but they did have a thicker one - 12 maybe? This D is used to a high bed at home (box spring + very tall mattress ) her bed always reminds me of Princess and The Pea. :slight_smile:

So maybe I should think about getting one at least 10 inches thick.

How about this “cooling gel” feature? It that typical? Effective? I can see her now wanting a mattress that is too “hot”.

I’ve never had an issue with memory foam being too hot, and I get hot easily (why I live in Maine and not Texas). We don’t have AC so some nights are fairly warm, also.

Cooling gel is just a nice gimmick. I recommend trying a pillow made of the same material first. The pillow does feel cool at first, but then after a few minutes it feels just like any other pillow. :slight_smile:

@abasket - we had the same concern about buying a mattress without trying it. Bought the one I linked to after hearing several recommendations from a friend. Both her sons, niece and friend all bought the same mattress and liked it!

This weekend we are going to try and find some brick and mortar stores that have a memory foam “bed in a box” concept set up for D to sample laying on. I hear that West Elm has a higher end brand - Casper maybe? We don’t buy a higher end model but D needs to get an idea of what she is in for with one of these. Have you seen these types of mattresses set up in brick and mortar stores to try out?

Also, I have my eye on the Amazon one mentioned above a couple of times. But wondering if anyone has purchased a certain model/brand from Costco? Again, easy to get, easy to return so have to consider their options.

Make sure you read the reviews if you buy from Amazon. I was looking at one that seemed to have a great rating but once I started reading reviews, there were some big issues.