Mentioning the Nation of Islam and Louis Farrakhan in my essays?

There are some essay prompts that ask, “Who inspires you?”

And the first person I think of is Louis Farrakhan.

The Nation of Islam is a major part of black history. I grew up very involved in the Nation of Islam.

I feel like I’m not being real if I can’t mention it, because that’s the first thing that comes to my mind when it comes to prompts like “Tell us about your background and where you come from?” I don’t think my essay will be compelling to me if I have to choose something else.

I mean, I could try.

Louis Farrakhan is pretty controversial, but it’s not clear to me what most people think of him. I know that many black people respect him.

But I’m wondering how it will be received by ad coms. What general opinions does this demographic (administration of leftist, majority white universities) have of the Nation of Islam and Louis Farrakhan?

Is even mentioning Farrakhan’s name without going into the controversial topics a bad idea? Some people say stuff like “I organized a bake sale at church,” in their essays.

Is it a bad idea to do the same for the Nation of Islam?

You never know who is reading your essay.

@jym626

Ok, so what would y’all think if you read that in an essay?

(Crowd sourcing opinions)

It doesn’t matter what I think. It matters what the reader thinks.

I think there are many reasons one could find Farrakhan interesting, and clearly as the head of a religious group that you grew up in (involved in), you would know more than many how charismatic, energetic, ebullient and naturally gifted at music he is. These things can be found to be inspiring, certainly.

Using your own language for considering how an essay on Farrakhan as inspiration might be received, I could say, you’re not being real if you don’t know that Farrakhan and the Nation of Islam have been received, and perhaps at times posited themselves to be, extremely polarizing. There is no doubt if you read the press on Farrakhan as head of the Nation of Islam that in such a role he is understood to be more than a figurehead of an organization found to preach and promote separatism, a biological and Divine origins story which places a hierarchical value on one group’s life over that of others, and more “controversial topics.”

You can find the press on opposition and protest to having speakers from the NOI invited to college campuses across the nation, and student groups of all creeds at the front of the protest lines.

This will not be lost on the admissions officers.

Using your own language, the first thing that may come to the minds of many when they see Farrakhan’s name, could work against you, despite the ideas and images that form in their minds being vastly different, even the polar opposite, of what comes to your mind when you think of him.

You cannot know how others will respond to the name, and as that is the point of your inquiry, the doubt you have about how others will respond is there, which means you are not altogether uncertain of the controversy surrounding NOI and Farrakhan.

While it is entirely possible to speak of the ways the NOI and Farrakhan have brought structure and meaning to your life, the other aspects of what are widely held and understood about those entities will also be considered as hugely influential on your thoughts and beliefs, perspective and philosophy. Such considerations will raise more questions about who you are, and how well you may seek to form and strengthen community on a college campus.

Someone here at CC says repeatedly that students want to give the college admissions officers all the reasons in the world to say ‘Yes,’ to them, and so should craft as much of an essay leaning toward ‘Yes’ as possible.

You are always free to assert your nuanced understanding of Farrakhan in the classroom and campus discussions, challenging and broadening other’s ideas, listening and sharing and broadening your own.

^ there’s your essay. Its still risky.

Oh, wait…I was hoping to be a little more than a little cautionary, but leaving it up to the student.

OP, have you, to use your ‘for instance,’ baked goods for service projects with them? Has that outreach been important to you/for you? Have you spearheaded any big projects because of the solid footing you are on in your life, partly due to the influence of the NOI and Farrakhan? (Just one other way to talk about you and where you take things. The jumping off point is a risky one, but in truth these essays should be about you.)

@waitingtoexhale

I’m never been entirely sure what MOST people think of Farrakhan, because he’s not commonly discussed.

I only know how he says he’s been treated, and that there are many people who dislike him and many people who love him. I just wondered what white people in this demographic commonly think.

But yeah, found this: http://www.thecrimson.com/article/1994/3/10/farrakhan-speaks-at-umass-amherst-papproximately/

If you said that you organized a bake sale at your mosque, it wouldn’t be risky. If a Christian student applying to a non-religious college wrote about how a well known and controversial figure in their religion had profoundly influenced them, it would be risky.

Some students have essays inside them that they have to write. Write it now and then decide if it’s right for your college apps or maybe you’ll decide it’s an essay meant for publication in some other medium. You may also find that what you have to write on this topic would be too long and deep for the college application but as you’re writing more themes and ideas will flow out that you can use.

@Otterma: “Some students have essays inside them that they have to write. Write it now and then decide if it’s right for your college apps or maybe you’ll decide it’s an essay meant for publication in some other medium.”

That is delicious.

@Applecake: That article is probably the least editorialized I’ve seen regarding how people view Farrakhan, some of the Nation of Islam’s statements and positions, and reactions and positions to the presence of a representative of the Nation of Islam as invited speaker. It was very interesting.

@Waiting2exhale That article is from the 90s, and Farrakhan was more prominent in the media at the time. Most news articles from mainstream media that I can find about Farrakhan are from the 80s and 90s. So I wasn’t sure if it was still representative.

A few weeks ago, Minister Farrakhan was welcomed to Rutgers University by the Black fraternity, Alpha Phi Alpha.

His full speech is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3XCQTdTWcVA The audience is mostly Black people, though a few are white, and they are pretty responsive.

But he’s here talking about the opposition to him coming to campus from Rutgers University’s administration: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-ZQxZR8XMY

The Nation of Islam’s own newspaper: http://www.finalcall.com/artman/publish/National_News_2/article_103395.shtml

His response to “Why am I hated?” is “Because of my love for you.” ( “you” meaning POC.)

So, many Black people like him.

IDK.

“Alpha Phi Alpha Fraternity, Incorporated!” That brought back memories, whoo!

I will view the videos and read the articles, but thought I’d chime in to say that “Because of my love for you,” is precisely the reason many Black people love (I know you used ‘like’) him.

There have simply been too many periods when we have needed to here someone of stature, someone educated and cultured, someone who has a national platform and the ear both of his own people, those with whom he worships, and national leaders, for the body politic of Black folks to turn away from that, the sweetest thing one ever hopes to hear.

There have always been others telling us we are loved, with messages of a reward in the sweet hereafter, as long as we endure the suffering of now.

It is a powerful message to hear someone say to the collective, you are all soldiers in an army founded on, steeped in, and grown from the seed of…love.

I am wishing you peace, @Applecake.

Come back and let us know how your search and selection process has gone next Spring.

Applecake,

Here’s the unvarnished truth: most people negatively regard Farrakhan as a separationist and an anti-Semite. That’s why many colleges don’t welcome him. It’s also why valorizing Farrakhan can prove radioactive. If you don’t believe me, ask Keith Ellison. I can’t say this will happen to you. But why take the chance? Choose another essay topic.

I’d acknowledge the controversy head-on, and try to paint an image of conflicting views from your upbringing. Try to subtly distance yourself from any views that adcons will find questionable?

I wouldn’t. Personally, I’m Jewish and I’d be biased against someone that claimed to admire him. Nothing personal against you, though! It’s just that I find some of his comments about Jews offensive. To someone that doesn’t know you, they may think that you agree with those views. It’s risky.

I consider myself liberal and open minded for the most part, but I am also Jewish and find Louis Farrakhan and his rhetoric frightening in the same way that I imagine Muslims and undocumented immigrants respond to certain comments by supporters of our president elect.

If you can word your essay in a way that demonstrates the positive aspects of Nation of Islam, of which I am certain there are many, including (from what I have read, a belief in charity and education), it might work, but I do agree that it’s risky.

Sigh. I guess I won’t do it. It’s too risky.

@techmom99 @greenteen17

But you shouldn’t be frightened. Not a single member of the Nation of Islam (and I’ve met thousands of NOI members) wants to harm Jewish people.

They just want more control over black communities and business, and their perception (THEIR PERCEPTION, I’m not saying this is or isn’t the case) is that members of the Jewish community have disproportianate control over many black organizations and businesses and entertainers. One common example I hear is of the managers and accountants of black rappers.

It’s more of a “we need to control our own”, than “we need to hurt Jews” mentality. They’re not thinking about hurting you, they’re thinking about helping themselves. Seriously, don’t worry. Nobody wants to hurt you.

I don’t want to get too much into that, because this thread will get closed, but you can message me if you want.

Anyway, I like the NOI, but I won’t write about it in the essay.

A quote from Farrakhan: “My god will wipe this country (America) from the face of the earth.”

Did he inspire you to apply outside the USA?

Either reader is going to love or hate you. It’s a risk, could boost or kill your chances depending upon who is reading. In today’s bigoted environment, I wouldn’t recommend using any controversial person but it’s your choice.