MSM vs NEC for bass

<p>hi, a friend of mine just got accepted to the following: NEC, MSM, BU, and Peabody.
he wants to major in performance as a bassist so he’s considering NEC or MSM. Does anyone have any suggestions for him? suggestions and advices from bass players are highly appreciated!</p>

<p>That is an interesting choice, but I would think it very much depends on the studio assignments because BU, MSM and NEC all have four or five bass teachers. </p>

<p>Tim Cobb (MSM) and Ed Barker (BU) are two of the best in the business. If he can get into either of those studios, I would recommend he jump at the chance unless a sample lesson showed a major incompatibility. If he can get into both, he will have a very hard decision to make. Larry Wolfe, Todd Seeber and Jim Orleans are all very good and all three are available both at BU and NEC, so the decision among them is more about which school worked out better for him. </p>

<p>I do not know a lot about the other teachers at MSM.</p>

<p>You might PM Cosmos, who studied with Cobb while in high school. She may well have had sample lessons or masterclasses with some of the others.</p>

<p>Hey, </p>

<p>What studios? That makes a considerable difference. Here are my thoughts: </p>

<p>MSM
-Tim Cobb: in my opinion, the top teacher in the world. I studied with him so of course I’m biased, but Tim’s first-class in every respect. He is a great teacher and a great player and a nice man. You can’t go wrong studying with him.
-Jeremy McCoy: it will be his first year teaching at MSM in 2009, but he is fantastic and also would be a great person to study with.
-Orin O’Brien: great, great teacher and player. I haven’t studied with her so I can’t make many comments. </p>

<p>BU
-Ed Barker: a lot like Tim. He’s amazing - great player and teacher and nice person.
Choosing between BU and MSM would be more of a choice between going to a conservatory or university.
-Todd Seeber: if your friend plays German bow, studying with Todd would be great. He’s a very good teacher and player, too. </p>

<p>NEC
-Larry Wolfe: the nicest guy on the planet and a great teacher and player. Very solid choice of school and studio. </p>

<p>Peabody
-the school is fluctuating right now, but if your friend wants to get lessons with Hal Robinson, it would be a good choice. Compared to the other schools though, Peabody wouldn’t be a good choice (according to me anyway).</p>

<p>Without knowing studios, I think my choice would be:
1 MSM with Cobb
2 BU with Ed
3 NEC with Larry
4 MSM with Jeremy
5 BU with Todd
6 MSM with Orin
7 Peabody</p>

<p>Unless there has been a recent change, Hal has not taught at Peabody for at least five or six years. He had a couple of students at Temple several years back too, but last I heard he is only teaching at Curtis and taking a few private students nowadays. I would put him up at the top of the list with Barker, Cobb, and Paul Ellison out at Rice.</p>

<p>The bass teachers at Peabody these days are Paul Johnson, John Hood and Jeffrey Weisner. They used to have Rob Kesselman, but he moved on not long after Hal.</p>

<p>Actually, you’re both right.</p>

<p>Beginning Fall '09 Hal Robinon will be Artist Faculty in Residence:
[Peabody</a> Institute - Strings: The Peabody Double Bass Department](<a href=“http://www.peabody.jhu.edu/doublebass]Peabody”>http://www.peabody.jhu.edu/doublebass)
From the P-y website:</p>

<p>Peabody is pleased to announce the appointment of Harold Hall Robinson, principal bass of the Philadelphia Orchestra and instructor at the Curtis Institute, as Peabody Artist-Faculty in Residence. Beginning in Fall 2009, he will join current Peabody double bass faculty faculty Paul Johnson and Jeffrey Weisner in this newly created position. Mr. Robinson will visit Peabody multiple times over the course of the year for day-long classes, presentations and intensive group lessons with Peabody bass students. Each student will work collaboratively with both their primary teacher and Mr. Robinson to develop her or his own artistry and musicianship.</p>

<p>Thanks everyone for all the helpful comments! Fortunately it seems like he got into all the studios he wanted (I don’t know which ones…). Now I think it comes down to the experience people got from going to either NEC or MSM. Does anyone know which school is better overall?</p>

<p>They both are excellent. If anything, NEC may have a slight edge in the upper strings and chamber programs, but having said that I may have well have opened the door to a number of violent diatribes and heated discourse. </p>

<p>It’s 6 of one, half dozen of another as you’ll get MSM BM’s doing grad work at NEC and vice-versa. Two winners, the choice is NYC over Boston. Each has its merits.</p>

<p>I’d say go with MSM. It’s in NYC and there are some fantastic opportunities to take advantage of there.</p>