You’ll find encouragement in this thread:
Also, people say that, if you can picture yourself doing something else other than theatre, do that something else. If you absolutely must do theatre, do it! Don’t let 2 prescreen rejections stop you. You passed two! Yay! (As the above thread points out, being redirected to Ithaca’s acting audition is a good thing. Not what you had hoped, but it’s not a rejection. A few other people on CC have been redirected there this year, btw.)
I actually think your list looks good. You have a safety. Are you academically a shoe-in at Muhlenberg? If you are, it’s a good safety. Have you looked at the big list of schools by state at the top of the forum? If you haven’t, look there. You may find a few more that interest you.