Musical Parents!

In many threads, posters have mentioned taking lessons or practicing their instruments. I’d love to hear more from you all.
I studied piano from 3rd grade through college. Post college, I lost access to a practice room and then, well - life just got in the way. Mom still had our piano and it is one of the things I insisted we keep - and there it sits. I want to start playing again.

Anyone else out there that’s returned to an instrument after a long hiatus? Or have you always been consistent?

4 Likes

I always wanted to play the piano. Alas, no money for either piano or lessons. My mother took lessons through high school and was a decent player. She took it up again after I left for college using one of the pianos at the HS where she worked and, later, bought a lovely small baby grand. Today, at 89, she is her church’s pianist.

I regret having no musical knowledge but will enjoy the journeys of others here. You all will get a “like” from me just for having musical skill.

8 Likes

I’ve always said I’m a great example of what you can do with a relatively smart kid with a good work ethic and give them good training. I started at age 4 and studied through college - all because I had a mega talented older sister.

My Mom knew little about music - but always wanted to - but someone discovered my sister had perfect pitch at 2 when she was singing stuff perfectly. Our neighbor was starting lessons and pulled her along - and got lucky with a julliard trained Chinese woman - who put the fear of god into you, though when I went back years later discovered she wasn’t even 4.5 feet tall lol.

My sister however was the laziest child you ever saw. She admits it now and feels bad. But she was still featured on NPR as middle schoolers with Joshua Bell and played with symphonies at that age. Turned down recruiting teachers from big music schools to go to tech and find a husband.

But back to me. Because I had the same good teachers, I can play anything, but recognize that I am just not at that level. Also I can play music. I have no creative talent. Jazz completely baffles me. But my biggest accomplishment was that I won the collegiate competition in my state - and was the first non music major to do so.

Then I got married and took 35 years off. I started up again january 2025 to give me something to do other than be obsessed with the global news. I’ve enjoyed learning new things and relearning some old. At some point I MIGHT play publicaly with my sister. Maybe. A big we will see

17 Likes

I played piano and violin as a child, piano because my parents thought it would be good for me and violin because my father’s violin (purchased from the Sears catalog in the 1930s) was in the attic. Hated piano, liked the social aspect of orchestra.

When my kids were taking Suzuki lessons, I discovered that I too could rock Twinkle Twinkle Little Star. Over the years, I’ve taken lessons on and off and now play in an adult ensemble called “Never Too Late” which is a lot of fun and also a string quartet where I struggle to keep up with the other three talented musicians.

We laugh a lot and figure we’re building neural synapses even if we’re not making beautiful music.

13 Likes

I’m a singer. I’ve been fortunate to be asked to sing the National Anthem at a number of events (sometimes at 7:30 am…it’s not the best song for that hour).

I started off as a music major in college, but I also had to take piano lessons…and I just never caught on. Like @ChoatieMom , we didn’t have the financial resources for a piano or piano lessons. So, I switched colleges and majors.

But I continued singing (and acting and sometimes dancing) in civic theater productions after college. I was fortunate to be cast in a number of great leading lady parts in some terrific musicals.

I was also a member of the adult choir affiliated with the children’s choir my kids were in. That was fun. We got to sing together for a few years.

My high school choir director was really the person who taught me the most…and we sang terrific music with him. Our choir was an award winning group that toured annually. I was a senior soloist with them and a member of a small group ensemble, and the chamber choir. We sang amazing music!

I now own a piano. I took lessons for a couple of years, and really, I should stick to singing! The teacher, however, has asked me to play keyboard for a ukulele group she has. So…I’ll try that.

And as you all already know, we have two very talented musician kids.

15 Likes

I played piano and took lessons from age 5 - 18. I loved playing for myself but hated recitals and had terrible stage fright. Finally worked with a teacher through HS that didn’t force performance and was Ok with me learning just for the love of music. We still have a piano in the house but I rarely play anymore and I’m super rusty. It’s one of the “go back to” items on my list.

Along the way I also dabbled in guitar and percussion.

I also started clarinet in 4th grade and then moved to tenor sax by 6th. Band was my real love. In HS I was in marching band, concert band, symphonic band, wind ensemble, jazz ensemble and played in the pit orchestra for every musical. At one point or another I’ve played all the single reeded instruments. Won tons of awards school and state and had every intention of continuing in college, alas, course conflicts with required classes derailed that.

I went back to playing in a band in my late 30s and performed with my county community band for ten years and had a blast. That band even got to perform at Severance Hall which was a total rush.

I too have a very musical daughter. She taught herself to play by ear at age 3 and was composing in elementary school. She had a gift early on for putting her heart and soul into whatever she was playing. She far and away passed any of my musical ability long long ago. We thought for sure she was going to opt for conservatory but as most know, she shifted gears in HS. Thankfully she still plays too.

10 Likes

I play the bassoon. Yep, the big double reed instrument that I often have to explain.

I started playing in middle school and looking back I was actually pretty good. Played in a very high level audition based HS regional orchestra and we performed top repertoire.

But my family did not really encourage my music. I never even had private lessons. It was always impressed upon me that it is something I can do in my leisure time but that I needed to pursue a science/health related field.

I played in my college orchestra then took a hiatus during grad school. In my late twenties I picked up my bassoon and started with our local community orchestra. There I met my DH who is a fabulous bassist. And a wonderful husband!

In our days before kids, we played so many gigs together. Both of us worked full time during the day, but music jobs were our outlet and date nights.

I then took a long break from my music when kids came along. We have 3 very talented musicians. So my non work time was spent driving them to lessons and enjoying their concerts and of course the usual sports teams and play dates and all of the other exciting activities.

But music was always such a big part of our lives. Our kids played together. We had impromptu jazz sessions in our home. I still occasionally brought out my old bassoon at Christmas to join in on playing carols.

Trust me when I say bassoon is not one of those instruments you can just dust off and play after lots of time off.

A few years ago, when all kids were out of the house (and off of our budget) I bought myself a beautiful, new bassoon. I started practicing regularly, re learning about reeds on YouTube. I am now back to playing in 4 different orchestras! So back to date night gigs with my husband after all of these years away.

And a very special moment was when our middle daughter decided to play her cello again after many years off and started in one of the orchestras this year with my husband and me. So lovely to look across the stage and see them making music together.

13 Likes

I played viola from 4th grade through high school. I went to music camps every summer beginning in junior high, and I took private lessons in high school. I wasn’t fabulous or anything, but I earned 1’s at solo & ensemble for solos. Why did I choose viola? There wasn’t as much competition as there was for violin players. I tried to pick it back up 25 or so years ago, but it’s hard. I might try again, but I need to get my bow rehaired.

My D is a very talented singer who sang a lot in school, church & musical theatre. Like me, she stopped in college. She hopes to join a choir down the road. My S is fabulous both on the guitar and the drums. He plays metal and post-rock, and he can bang those drums like nobody’s business. He & his buddies have a band that practices on weekends and plays shows every few months - they have a small but loyal local following. He will never stop playing - it’s part of who he is. H played in a bar band for a few years, but now he just plays guitar for his own relaxation.

8 Likes

My mother had perfect pitch and was an incredibly talented singer and pianist. She also played the clarinet, and my father the sax. They had both been in marching band and my mother part of a touring choir when she was in college (before she dropped out to marry). When Dad got his tenure track position as an assistant professor and they purchased a home, one of the first things they got was a piano. I think they paid weekly for it! I was thrilled. My first teacher was Czech but then I studied with a wonderful woman who lived a block from our house. For my last recital, Mom and I did a duet together. Mom had kept all of the programs - it was fun to see what I had done over the years. I am nowhere near being able to do that now. In college I’d reserve a practice room and go down and play when I needed some stress relief. My D is not at all musical.

5 Likes

I grew up playing piano and flute and still play, albeit mostly piano. I’m also fulfilling a lifelong dream to learn the tuba. I am a total beginner, and I am so terrible at it. It’s an absolute blast.

7 Likes

Just love what you did with the pun there. :sweat_smile:

4 Likes

For anyone so inclined, it is really never too late to pick up an instrument.

If you played and read music in your younger days of course it is easier.

But in my opinion, having an interest and having fun is even more important. And even if your recital is a beginning piece that you perform for your cat, it is really exciting to do something new and be proud of yourself for doing it.

After so many years of most of us devoted to our kids and their accomplishments, it is good for us to shine.

5 Likes

Well, if singing counts, then I can play. I sang (alto 1 or 2) in our church choir from 15 through HS and then in a choral ensemble all through college. I can’t read music, but I hear it well enough to blend tunefully into a group. No solo acts for me, but I do like to sing.

5 Likes

This may be TL;DR!

I play classical guitar. I started when I was six years old (on a baritone uke that had its four strings tuned like the top four on a guitar) because I was too small for a guitar. My first teacher had also been a kindergarten teacher so she was a good match. I learned chords, but from the very beginning I was taught to read standard notation using Alfred Method books. After a couple of years, my mom located a young man who was a classical guitar student at our local college, and I started taking lessons from him. I had lessons until I was 17 and moved from Florida to Arkansas - no teacher for me there.

Sometime around age 13 I thought I wanted to major in music. Because of this I started taking piano lessons as I knew I’d have to pass a piano proficiency exam. I was a pretty quick study, but it was still frustrating because I could read anything, but couldn’t play anything. And adding the bass clef thing later in life was challenging. I’d also never studied music theory which is something most piano teachers insist on. I took lessons for a couple of years and decided a music major wasn’t for me because I didn’t feel I could have the financial security I wanted. My band instrument (five years) was flute, and I played bassoon one year. The bass clef learning from the piano helped with that!

There have been times in my life that I played my guitar less frequently, but I have never stopped playing. In college, I played in on-campus coffee houses. I never really enjoyed live performance (nerves).

After ds was born, I knew I wanted him to play piano as a FIRST instrument. I do think it is the best instrument to learn first because it teaches reading in both clefs and includes theory from the get-go. He started at age four. He’s really quite good and has perfect pitch. A combo of natural talent and a strong work ethic. He, too, considered music as a major but also dismissed the idea by the time he was a junior in high school. He won the state piano competition his senior year. It’s his only instrument. Like me, he still plays (he’s 29). I think for both of us, it serves as a type of therapy.

Anyway, because I knew he’d have to do live performances through piano recitals, I wasn’t going to ask him to do anything I wouldn’t do myself, I started playing in church. I did that for many years - as a soloist, in a duet with both flute and cello, and even in a praise band (I do NOT sing). So, I became much more consistent in playing then.

I think one of the reasons I dislike live performing was because my mother always wanted me to play for people - to show me off. When ds started taking lessons, I told him I would probably ask him to play for people, but he always had the freedom to say, “No.” He never turned me down, and he is a natural performer.

An arranger/composer friend asked me to start a YouTube channel to post his works. I did that about fifteen years ago. During Covid I posted two pieces a week. I have over 300 videos on there. Since I never learned to like live performing (even though I did it), it’s a perfect way for me to share my music. I can do as many takes as I want to get something (while not perfect) that I can live with. Being classically trained means I can play most anything. I rarely play standard rep anymore. I have a modest number of subscribers, though one video, (“Nothing Else Matters,” by Metallica) has over 20,000 views (still modest by YT standards - ha ha). I’m also in a large Facebook group called Old Guitar Pickers.

Told ya’ - TL;DR :joy:

Edit: I now play in the handbell choir at church.

11 Likes

@ChoatieMom singing most definitely counts! It’s the instrument you always have with you!

5 Likes

I forgot that…in addition to the college choir and musical my freshman year of college, I also played on a handbell choir… and I loved that. I played the top four bells!

7 Likes

I had piano lessons in early years, then played violin from 5th grade through first year of college (G&S Society orchestra). Those years included several summer camps, both locally at MSU and once in Vermont.

I didn’t keep it up, but made sure son was exposed to music and had piano lessons. I dithered on moving his Yamaha upright when we moved from Illinois. But in the end I felt like a home wasn’t cultured without a piano (grew up with a baby grand in the basement). A year or so after we moved I took an adult beginning keyboard class just to get some use out of it. Also, after years of only treble clef, it was an chance to relearn the bass clef. And both hands together!

4 Likes

My mom had both me and my older sister take piano lessons for several years. We were pretty bad and didn’t practice and I had the worst time trying to play both hands at the same time. I could generally do the melody on the right hand but adding the left was just beyond me. We bought a keyboard but ended up giving it away as none of us used it.

In 7th grade, I played the violin (very badly). Gave it up after 8th grade. Also tried playing ukulele every summer but never was able to do more than strum a few cords.

S and D each took an instrument. S played trumpet & D played violin. S has a better ear but D likes music a lot more and follows the musicians she loves & attends some of their performances & musicals & operas. Both gave up their instruments after HS & they’re gathering dust in the closets.

2 Likes

I did not have a musical childhood; my mother was tone deaf and experienced music as noise. My father as a child of the Depression was adamant that if the choice of electives at school was between typing and music you had to take the one that would help you earn a living. So I was in my 50s when I joined an auditioned women’s chorus. I never learned to read music as a kid but I’m pretty good at matching pitch and can memorize easily. I was astonished when I passed the audition and for the past 20 years singing in the women’s chorus has been my favorite activity. I love everything about it, the rehearsals, the performances, hanging out with 150 of my closest friends. In the summer I sing with an SATB chorus but the women’s chorus is my first love.

11 Likes

A few more random notes while I sit in the Airbnb waiting for peeps to wake up. H and I get up super early compared to most people. 6am on vacation is sleeping in for us.

Relearning as an adult - I find it fascinating now how I learn. My sight reading ability is crappy, but is improving some. In the old days, I was great. For my last two years of high school, I played for a Unitarian church choir - they had my sister the prior two years. Talk about lucky. But they sang all the big works, Mozart requiem, Brahms requiem, Bachs b minor mass, etc. while they learned it, I had to play all their parts simultaneously for them and/or mine. I also played the organ for the Catholic Church starting at 12 whenever the choir sang from the messiah. The organist was great, but couldn’t play that. I could do that, but forget foot pedals.

However, I still seem to learn quickly. That pleases me. But I find that my brain can’t read the music fast enough if I try to focus on it. However if I just let my brain see the page it, and not think about it, it does fine. I do struggle with really high and low note that are well off the staff. Sometimes I just write the letter above/below them. I also haven’t tried to actively memorize stuff. Most of the things I play, you have to have it just about memorized to play it, but I’m too chicken to pull it away completely. In the old days I had hours of repertoire memorized at any given time. But I just play for myself now, so who really cares.

I also played the trumpet from 5th grade through 10th. Can’t say I was a huge fan, but I did very well in auditions. Sight reading 1 line was cake. I knew all my scales, arpeggios from age 6, and knew how to play musically. I struggled with range (I didn’t practice much), and some other technical things. I despised marching band and was glad when I could quit.

But honestly - I was in it for the competitions and the $$$ you could earn. I had enough saved to pay for what my scholarships didn’t cover (off campus rent, food, etc for 4 years). I also loved if you won a competition, you got to play for the “old ladies groups” and that meant missing school!

9 Likes