If it helps, I sometimes like to point out that colleges do not provide outcomes, they provide opportunities. So, your outcomes then depend on which opportunities you choose to pursue, and how it goes for you as an individual.
With that understanding in mind, it turns out there are very few outcomes, almost none in fact, which are available only for the graduates of some very good colleges and not others. And in fact, at the level you are talking at least, the opportunities are not so different either. The biggest difference tends to be the student mix they are serving.
So if you as an individual can identify and make good use of the opportunities that make sense for you, you will likely end up with good outcomes. And the degree to which that depends on which of these types of colleges you choose is very likely much, much less than what some people seem to think. It more is a function of your choices IN college, and generally how well you do IN college.
Now if you are just more excited about the total experience at one college versus another, and are able to comfortably afford them both, then great, choose the one that excites you more.
But I get super nervous when people start trying to justify spending a lot more for college based on things like career outcomes. Because I am very skeptical the exact college you choose (within this sort of range) has much to do with that.