Need help with finding a dissertation topic!

<p>I’ll keep this short and hope someone will be able to help. I wanted to see about going to grad school but with my anthropology undergrad degree I don’t know what to study. </p>

<p>I am interested in mythology, mainly ancient Roman and Greek myths. I wanted to something in that area but don’t know what to do in terms of my research topic for my thesis. At one point I thought about writing a paper on comparison between how myths are represented in books and how Hollywood movies depict them and why. Professor told me that has been done and beaten to death. What do you think? What would a good topic to write about concerning ancient mythology? Any help is welcome, even mythology concerning any other parts of out history besides Rome and Greece. Thank you in advance! </p>

<p>For the humanities doctoral programs with which I am familiar, an applicant isn’t expected to have his or her exact dissertation topic figured out in advance. You will be working up to your prospectus, which will have the specific inquiry that you plan. You now know that you are interested in mythology, and have a draw to grad school. The courses that you take and the papers you write will shape your direction. Ask yourself what it is that interests you in mythology. The archetypes? The conflicts? The psychology? culture? Then talk with your current profs to identify departments and faculty who will offer courses and offer support for developing your research. If you have a true interest and the capacity for deferred gratification, all will work out, though realize that the job market for a Ph.D. in mythology will be brutal.</p>

<p>LOL! If only it were that easy. </p>

<p>The whole idea of a PhD program is that you study enough in a field and build up enough expertise that you can identify a topic from which you can garner an original idea and make a significant contribution to knowledge. If it seems open ended it’s because it is. Eventually you tread where nobody else has. </p>

<p>Are you looking for topic for a dissertation (PhD) or a senior thesis (BA)? If you’re writing a senior thesis, we can help you out. If you’re looking for a dissertation topic…don’t be. That comes further down the road. I found my grad school admissions essays while tidying up my computer the other day, and I was extremely amused by how much my interests and research foci have changed since then. </p>

<p>If you expect to engage with myths in a meaningful way, you will find it helpful to have at least a rudimentary knowledge of relevant languages. Relying on translations, however good, is not sufficient for decent scholarship. Ancient literature is absolutely full of word play that gets lost in translation (e.g. the infamous outis/me tis/metis pun in the Odyssey). Moreover, a lot of essential scholarship has been written in French and German. </p>

<p>The recent resurgence of interest in Greek mythology in books and film (Harry Potter, Percy Jackson, Clash of the Titans, Troy, Hercules, etc.) has been much discussed among academics, so your professor is correct. The use of mythological imagery in art has also been analyzed and discussed extensively. That said, there is much that could still be discussed, and new myth-inspired works come out all the time…so there is fodder for a paper, if it takes a new approach to the material. </p>

<p>@snarlatron why do you think the market for PhD will be brutal? Because there are a lot of people studying same as me or that there is a very small depend for expertise in mythology field? </p>

<p>These days it is very difficult to land a humanities tenure-track position. @Juillet gives some of the reasons in her post in this thread:</p>

<p><a href=“English PhD Advice for a puzzled undergrad - Graduate School - College Confidential Forums”>English PhD Advice for a puzzled undergrad - Graduate School - College Confidential Forums;

<p>Tenured profs have a good life and take their time retiring. When they do, they are often replaced with adjunct faculty. Schools are graduating too many Ph.D.s for the market but few see any self-interest in cutting back their grad programs. So any dream of one day being a tenured prof of Mythology at a top 200 school is unlikely to materialize. The creative Ph.D. will look for opportunities at less obvious schools such as regional and parochial colleges, seminaries, community colleges, and prep schools.</p>

<p>Many students find dissertation topics by working as a graduate assistant with a scholar who is doing his/her own research. The area that the student is assigned to work on typically becomes the focus for the diss.</p>

<p>In areas where scholars work more independently (like my field, English) you discover a topic as you write research projects for upper-level seminars. Seeing what’s already been written in an area helps you discover what kind of work still needs to be done.</p>

<p>Either way, it’s not something to worry about until you get to grad school.</p>

<p>@needhelp203‌ </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Both, plus what @snarlatron already said. Basically, humanities PhD students are cheap labor and prestige generators. Universities with doctoral programs are more prestigious (for whatever reason), and PhD students teach the lower-level undergrad classes that tenured professors don’t want to or don’t have time to teach - or, the classes that there aren’t enough of them to teach. So there are too many PhD students, especially in the humanities fields (science PhD students are less likely to sole-teach classes, although they do teach labs and serve as TAs). Mythology, specifically Greek and Roman mythology, is likely to be very popular. Most departments probably already have someone who can teach that; the field is well-researched, and finding a new niche is going to be difficult; so you will be competing for very few slots with a lot of other people.</p>

<p>If you are simply interested in mythology, you can read and learn about it and even take classes and do some amateur scholarship without becoming an anthropologist. You can get a job and live near a university; go to lectures and visit their library, audit classes, etc. You can read books about it.</p>

<p>If you really want to do scholarship on mythology - as in, you want to generate new knowledge about Greek and Roman (or other) mythologies by reading through dusty tomes in ancient forgotten languages in the basement of an archive, translating and analyzing that material, and competing to publish it in books, monographs, and articles - and your desire to do this is GREATER than your desire to do pretty much anything else in the world - well, then that’s when you need a PhD. Anything less than that, you can just be a really interested enthusiast, which is totally fine!</p>

<p>One way of increasing your chances is finding a niche that few people occupy. There are tons of people who do Roman and Greek mythology, or European mythologies in general (Norse, Celtic, etc.). That’s why we know so much about them - many scholars can read Latin and Greek, many digs have taken place there, many people have analyzed this stuff, etc. Fewer people do research on South Pacific mythologies or West African mythologies or Central Asian mythologies or Central American mythologies. You see? You go in as a Greek/Roman scholar, you compete with a bazillion other people. You go in as a scholar of West African traditional mythologies who reads Bambara and Twi, and suddenly you are competing with a LOT fewer people. You also open yourself up to more jobs, because now you can teach in an African studies department too, or a cultural and ethnic studies department.</p>

<p>I’m not saying that you should study something you’re meh about because 8 years of your life isn’t worth that, but it seems like you’re sort of broadly interested in myth so if the geographic region doesn’t mean a whole lot to you, then consider one that’s less-studied. Remember that the point of PhD work is to generate new knowledge, not to just learn about the old knowledge that already exists.</p>

<p>BUT</p>

<p>I wanted to see about going to grad school but with my anthropology undergrad degree I don’t know what to study.</p>

<p>From this I’m concluding that you probably don’t need grad school. If you don’t know what to study, then grad school is more or less pointless. The way it works is that you select a career first, and then the degree you need to get to that career. So if you wanted a career teaching and conducting research in anthropology, then you would need a PhD - but you don’t get a PhD (or an MA) and then say “Hmm, what do I want to do now?” Because then you might decide that what you really want to do is be a lawyer, and you just wasted 2-8 years and $$$ on something you don’t need.</p>