New American Idol thread

<p>no wind beneath my wings but you are getting a Bette song ;)</p>

<p>

It’s from a much lesser known movie called Once.</p>

<p>cross posted with cartera</p>

<p>Well I do love Bette and Lil is no Bette.</p>

<p>Has she hit a note on pitch yet?</p>

<p>My bottom 3:</p>

<p>Lil
Matt
Anoop (not because i want him there)</p>

<p>I agree, I wait to see what Simon will say and I don’t really care what Paula or Randy have to say. I do like Kara’s judging too. Lil is doing The Rose …I loved Bette’s version but Lil is doing a great job of it…making it sound like a church song though.</p>

<p>sorry Lil… very, very pitchy - she’s going to get pounded by the judges.</p>

<p>I really hate when Lil opens her yap trap to dispute Simon.</p>

<p>Notice how Paula kept a positive note to Lil’s performance without saying a darned good thing about her performance tonight?</p>

<p>my bottom 3:
matt
lil
danny</p>

<p>I agree mafool. I’m voting for Chris - if I can remember the number.</p>

<p>Lil was really pitchy. Adam was much more boring than he was last week. Love the song from Once.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Big mistake. I predict she’s gone tomorrow night. Or, as she sings it: ni-i-i-i-i-aight.</p>

<p>Time for Lil to go home. She started out the season so well, but steadily went down hill from there.</p>

<p>For me, tonight: Kris>Adam>everyone else</p>

<p>bottom: Lil</p>

<p>Why do they insist on calling her Lil Rounds as in Lil Kim? It was clear from the family night clips that her name is Lil - as short for Lilly.</p>

<p>You wanna think Lil is gonna nail it…she gets some nice strong notes in there, then blows it…I think she should go. imho:</p>

<p>Liked: Anoop, Kris, Adam (but I’d like to hear him sing something ‘pretty’… enough with the jumping and screaming around altho he is sensational)</p>

<p>Didn’t do it for me: Allison, Matt, Lil</p>

<p>Little bit of both: Danny</p>

<p>Sick of: Paula</p>

<p>Just watched tonight’s show off of Tivo. Did I see Katie Couric in the audience? Thought I saw her twice.</p>

<p>I do believe it was Katie Couric; at least that is who I assumed it was!</p>

<p>West Coast here. I have a question…what is Quentin Tarantino doing on this show? What kind of musical background does he have that justifies his input into their music?</p>

<p>I wondered the same thing about Tarantino although his movies do have great soundtracks!</p>

<p>This was Anoop’s best performance so far IMO. I really liked him during auditions and love his college stuff on YouTube, but tonight is the first time I’ve seen that level of performance from him on the show.</p>

<p>Adam was amazing as always - he’s just so far above the pack.</p>

<p>Tarantino ruined tonight for me. I didn’t think that his suggestions were worthwhile or added value. I realize he was just pimping his upcoming film. Maybe I had a problem with him because I’m not a fan of his movies. I’d understand his critiquing of acting but not singing.</p>

<p>Was it just me, or did they let Adam’s song go longer than everyone else’s?</p>