I’ve visited both campuses, and I absolutely fell in love. However, I have a downward trend on my transcript due to health condition. But, I’ve scored 34 on my ACT. I know Northwestern has higher acceptance rate for Early Decision, but I don’t know if I should apply to Northwestern. When I contacted both schools, UChicago was more generous about my transcript issue than Northwestern. In addition, I think my essays (including supplementary essays) are outstanding, so I’m stuck between Northwestern and UChicago. My intended major will be International Studies. Please help!
Not sure what your looking for here…reassurance that one will offer a better chance of admittance?
I agree with CU123…but if you do ED to Northwestern you are bound, and won’t know if you could go somewhere better… I would do U Chicago though
Downward trend on your transcript is a big red flag when a school student is predicting your success in college level work. If Northwestern seemed “ungenerous” about your transcript issue and U of C has one of the lowest admit rates in the country where 34 ACTs are a dime a dozen, please go to your college counselor to make sure you have a full range of matches and safeties too. A high ACT score does not compensate for a lackluster GPA/transcript as the latter is achieved over years and not one morning. Good luck.
IMO ED should only be used if 1) an applicant has an absolute top choice and 2) if the applicant has no need to compare financial offers between schools.
You said elsewhere that you will be applying ED to Northwestern and that your GPA was 3.1. Are you changing you mind? Do you prefer UChicago now? I’d certainly ask your guidance counselor to discuss your illness and its impact on your GPA in his/her recommendation.
@ys1017 Do not think too much of the fact that Chicago appeared more generous with your issue. Their objective is to get you to apply no matter your qualifications in order to drive down their acceptance rate. Chicago is especially notorious for this practice.
If your GPA is indeed 3.1 then the chances are minimal at both schools. What was your GPA before your health condition? Is it 3.7+ ? If so, you could have a chance if you can explain well why your condition led to such a decline in your GPA. If your GPA was sub-3.5 to begin with, then your chances are probably next to zero.
@Penn95 yeah I had 3.8 before my health condition affected my gpa.
I would recommend against using your valuable essay space to explain a GPA drop but rather ask the guidance counselor to put it in his/her letter. Does that individual think that in the context of your school, its history with elite admissions, and your particular class that he/she thinks you have even a plausible chance at admissions? I hate to rain on your parade but short of a campus building with your family name on it I can hardly imagine your success at this tier with a cumulative 3.1. You also mentioned in another thread that all your AP scores junior year were 2’s. Even if not reported the schools will assume you got at best a 3. You are expecting a school like U of C or Northwestern to overlook your poor showing on college level work in the context of a bad illness which is I think too much to expect. I think you would have more success specifically not applying early in any fashion and getting all A’s your first semester senior year so that your counselor can write how well prepared you are for college level work and show it by the transcript. ED/EA is for students whose application could not be made better by senior year grades and that hardly describes your situation. Please go back to your counselor and discuss this further.