I’m thinking of not applying to Princeton because, for many reasons, I don’t want my college experience to be terribly stressful and consumed by schoolwork. What do you think of this as a reason for not applying?
You need to find your fit including academics of the right style and level of challenge for you.
It seems that many students try to go to the highest ranked university that they can get into. This often means going to the most stressful and academically difficult university that they can get into. This might be good for some students and bad for some others. Smart students vary a lot in terms of how well they deal with stress. Some exceptionally intelligent students do not deal well with stress. One possible reason might be that they have things that they would like to think about in addition to their classes.
Sometimes even the same student can vary over time in terms of how they deal with stress. A student who does not know why they are at university might deal very badly with stress. The same student a few years later if they have decided that they really want to learn about a particular specialty might be very comfortable studying long hours and working very hard in order to do exactly that.
You should try to find a school that is a good fit for you. This is not always easy since high school students generally don’t have experience with being a university student. However, IMHO you have brought up a very reasonable issue for you to think about.
Maybe this isn’t so much a question about Princeton, and more so a question of “should I be applying to college at all?” In which case, the answer is, it depends. College is stressful–this is not unique to Princeton.
Well, as an index, what’s the 25th percentile ACT at Princeton, 32? Though this represents thoroughly high academic preparation, of course, your peers at Princeton would still overlap substantially by academic considerations with students at relatively modestly-selective colleges. In comparison, Caltech, which reports a 34 ACT for the 25th percentile, might be another matter.
Well, I’d be at the lower end of Princeton’s ACT even if I got in.
From a more subjective aspect, how familiar are you with the cases of students (however isolated) who have fabricated their entire records for the purpose of admission into highly ranked schools? Generally, once admitted, they’ve often performed reasonably well even in an honest context. The academic difficulty and precision of some top colleges may be partly illusory, and, in your case, you would have the benefit of having been accepted legitimately.
If you have 15 schools that you like better than Princeton, then don’t bother. On the other hand, if Princeton checks all your other boxes, go ahead and apply. If you are accepted then you can revisit the question in April.
My daughter felt the same way. She didn’t apply to certain schools because she was nervous about how she would handle the stress. It worked out nicely for her… and goes under the heading of “fit.”