<p>well honestly i dont understand what we could do by finding the particle. Create another world with it? we clearly dont have enough force and matter to do so.</p>
<p>the physicists are so excited over the evidence for the higgs because of the grants and approval to build even larger, more wasteful partial colliders that it means they will get.</p>
<p>of course, this physics and the billions of dollars invested in it is a colossal waste of both human capital and some of the brightest human minds. </p>
<p>that’s not to say it’s not better than some things. physics is cool and interesting and awesome. but compared to what those people could be doing and where the money could be going, it’s an absolute shame.</p>
<p>:).</p>
<p>i meant particle collider. oops.</p>
<p>um, i know why people appreciate physics i think. i like physics. i read all that you wrote. nonetheless it is good to be aware that there is a lot of indication that the physics community is mostly excited because of the money they will get from this discovery (the further support), not because of the discovery itself. the physicists who <em>really</em> understand the standard model were already convinced of the higg’s existence. </p>
<p>also when this science uses the most intelligent humans and billions of dollars - things which are immensely valuable - i think it is important to question whether this is a decent use of those resources, and how much such expenditure should be encouraged. </p>
<p>“cool” and “deep” are not sufficient reasons for diverting the attention of some of the most capable humans. </p>
<p>anyway.</p>
<p>i am just saying, theoretical physics will proceed no faster because of this verification. there was not a need to do it now. most of the impetus for verifying the higgs <em>now</em> was for keeping money flowing to these theoretical physicists it seems.</p>
<p>you are right i didn’t read your post really carefully. i kind of dismissed it as physics hype. it was written nicely and the points were good, but after inspecting it again i think that’s mostly what it was.</p>
<p>if verifying the higgs had not received so much publicity, and if it had not been so costly, and taken the effort of so many smart people - then fine, i wouldn’t care.</p>
<p>but when the future of humanity rests in the actions that we take today. when everything is not pretty and life is not as good as it should be for everyone, it just seems so wrong to me the amount of attention that some branches of theoretical attention receive -and the talented minds that are lost to it.</p>
<p>i feel like young smart people are not being exposed to the range of possibilities enough - instead they are pressured to develop their mathematical talents, not given the time to find their own path, and eventually it is too late, they are immersed in theoretical math or physics, completely immersed in the complexity and challenge and struggle of those fields - making progress that only few humans can make - and cannot come out.</p>
<p>anyway that’s my rant.</p>
<p>You must not be familiar with the physics community or the state of physics research if you think this verification will accelerate research significantly, or make the research measurably more productive … from what i read that is not the case.</p>
<p>you know nothing of the math behind the physics you mentioned. as the advancements are mathematical, i do not know how could claim to know what kind of magnitude the effects of knowing some properties of the higgs would be on that mathematical development. you think it will be big due to the extreme attention that the discovery received. but it seems equally probably that the magnitude could be really small.</p>
<p>there’s no reason why the extent of the celebration of the result should correlate with how much research the result will stimulate. some of the most uncelebrated advances (often theoretical) have stimulated the most research.</p>
<p>I do not know the math either, nor what the physics community thinks or the state of the research. however there seems to be some evidence that the particle collider was mostly built to get some experimental results - not because the experimental results (like confirming the higgs) are crucial to the development of theory, but because they are crucial for funding, which is necessary for the development of the theory. </p>
<p>it is a more complex picture, but it is likely a more true one i think.</p>
<p>wouldn’t that make some sense?</p>
<p>yeah i was sharing my perception of the whole higgs thing, since this turned into higgs discussion. i saw that you had a different perception of it - which is what inspired me to share my perception, so both views could compete for attention, or whatever.</p>
<p>I feel like you were offended by my view though. maybe because i didn’t give enough respect to yours. but i was just really trying to add to the idea pool. make it more diverse.</p>
<p>Penguin, do you believe in polygamy? Because if I were you, I would want Caltech all to myself.</p>
<p>So guys, how bout this rain?</p>
<p>What rain? None here.</p>
<p>no rain here either, just heat. Trade?</p>
<p>I love summer storms
we got a really brief one too</p>
<p>Off-topic, bro will never die.</p>
<p>+1, yankee.</p>
<p>+9001 to me</p>
<p>No. 10char</p>
<p>Gram!!! <3</p>
<p>I missed ya too, yankee.</p>
<p>-9000 to grammarnazi</p>